Does Shelton from the Big Bang Theory have AS?

Post Reply New Topic

a person in a different tv series that I think might be an aspie is Dr. Temperance "Bones" Brennan from 'Bones'.

I don't watch The Big Bang Theory, but I watched an episode a couple of days ago, and Sheldon definitely appeared to have aspergers. I think I had read about him being an aspie though (but didn't know who was who), so I knew one of the characters had AS.

I have never seen the show, but the following may be of interest to the OP and others.

"On the potential for Sheldon's having Asperger's syndrome
''I did not know enough about Asperger's to be utilizing any Asperger-y traits early on. And I still didn't know what it meant exactly ... to have Asperger's ... until we were being asked about midway through the first season — after having aired several episodes — 'Does Sheldon have Asperger's?' And I went to the writers and I asked and they said, 'No.' ...
It seems to me that there's a lot of wonderful qualities that could fall under Asperger's or autism that are so colorful. I think [the writers] really celebrate those [traits]. ... I think it's such an original reaction to [see] the world through a filter like that — to look at the world through those eyes.'' "
From "Jim Parsons On The Science Of Sheldon, 'Big Bang' ", Fresh Air (NPR)
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/stor ... =130156625

nah, i doubt it. i mean sure he has the intellect of Einstein x100, but he seems to social to me

We Aspies can of course learn to become sociable. I still think he's one of us.

Now everyone, break out into that song from Todd Browning's Freaks!:

"One of us! Gooble, Gable! One of us!"

-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer

He is over-qualified really.

But I'm reluctant to start to diagnose fictional characters. All teens are identifying with their favourite characters and prescribing their personality traits on them. Probably that is why most main characters are so bland and boring. I've always preferred the villains myself. They usually have interesting personalities.

According to the creators of the show, he does not have AS. Word of God > all.

Word of Peter says that he couldn't possibly have more AS symptoms though.

Most likely they don't want to make him officially AS to avoid any complaints from the AS community about negative portrayals.

What other sub-culture or identy (assuming Asperger people are a subculture or identy) would be happy to be portrayed and denied. Imagine if Sheldon couldn’t see, used a white cane and walked around with a Labrador and they said he’s not blind, we call it Sheldony. Or Sheldon had a relationship with another man and they said he’s not gay, it’s just Sheldony. Other groups would not accept this.

Aspergers is not regarded in the same way as other minorities.

You can be a socially stunted genius and still be NT.

I'd say definitley. I'm watching the second series now, aside from a few episodes, I am quite impressed

Heh.. I'd say I'm more like Raj that Shelton >.<

Sheldon is one type of AS, another less obvious Aspie film character was the Rainmans brother (played by Tom Cruise) who showed AS traits, when told his brothers name he thought in pictures and misinterpreted raymond for rainman, having seen him standing in the rain by a car. Also he had a special interest in cars knowing all the specifications of the cars he sold and lining the cars up, (we all know that one), further he was only concerned with his own welfare regarding the money the rainman was to get, These are two different portrayals of AS, Sheldon is less threatening to NT's the rainman character is very threatening to NT's, Are they positive models for AS individuals, I think not. Aspie's need to decide what aspects of our characters we wish to portray and create a universal character to be used by the media, little man tate (film), perhaps.

I'd put good money on this. I mean consider this, people are asking these writers of a comedy show if the character they often portray as petty, rude, prone to temper tantrums and childish behavior and betraying his friends over seemingly minor issues and who is at times downright unlikable... has what's regarded as a very severe condition that's perceived as affecting mental state. I'm sure you guys all know what it's like when someone knows of your condition and they can't stop talking to you as though you're 6 years old who's slow and hard of hearing, right? And they think they're being really understanding, kind and standing up for poor poor disabled you since you can't speak for yourself. That's the people I so would not want to deal with getting letters from, those people are crazy!

So long as they refuse to give him a label he can just be quirky weird Sheldon, and they don't have to worry as much about angry letters and can take him in whatever direction they want to as a character. For a TV show to go out on a limb like that I think they know if they want to avoid bad press they need to spend a lot of time showing positive sides as well and not seem disrespectful. In a comedy like the Big Bang Theory, not being disrespectful is gonna be very hard considering how varied people's outrage tolerance is.

He's ambiguously autistic: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/M ... lyAutistic

Abed from Community is definitely a character with Asperger's, which was even addressed quite brazenly in one memorable scene where the main character, in a fit of rage, attempts to insult him by saying he has it. Abed doesn't get emotional about it and the others around the table change the subject by making the obvious jokes about the sound of the word. It was a big moment for both Jeff Winger and Abed Nadir as far as character development.

Agreed.

Totally! He knows everything and blurts out his knowledge all the time, even when no one cares. He always says things to other people that are completely untactful and make him seem rude and disrespectful. He seems to have OCD as well.