Rating the Batman Movies

Post Reply New Topic

Live action only. Keep in mind that the Burton and Schumacer movies are not in countinuity with the Nolan ones.

Batman (1989) 9
Batman Returns (1992) 7
Batman Forever (1995) 5
Batman & Robin (1997) 2
Batman Begins (2005) 10
The Dark Knight (2008) 10

Batman 89 - 8
Batman Returns - 9
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm - 10
Batman Forever - 3
Batman and Robin - 0
Batman and Mr. Freeze: SubZero - 8
Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker - 8
Batman Begins - 10
The Dark Knight - 10
Batman: Under the Red Hood 10
Batman: Year One - 10

Last edited by LexingtonDeville on 25 May 2012, 8:20 am, edited 2 times in total.

Doing some extra ones, but limiting it to theatrical releases only.

Batman '66: **1/2
Batman '89: ****1/2
Batman Returns: ***1/2
Batman Mask Of The Phantasm: ****
Batman Forever: ***
Batman & Robin: *1/2
Batman Begins: *****
Dark Knight: *****

These spam threads are really starting to irritate me and should just all be grouped into one thread but oh well...
Batman (1989) 6.5/10
Batman Returns (1992) 7/10
Batman Forever (1995) 3/10
Batman & Robin (1997) 0/10
Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm 9/10
Batman Begins (2005) 7/10
The Dark Knight (2008) 7/10

To quote The Dude: "Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man."

1989: 10/10

Returns: 9/10

Mask of the Phantasm: 10/10

Forever: 6.5/10

Batman and Robin: 3.5/10

Sub Zero: 8.5/10

Return of the Joker: 10/10

Begins: 8.5

The Dark Knight: 9.5

Red Hood: 9.5

The Dark Knight Returns: Unknown

Batman 1989 ***

Batman Returns ***

Batman Forever ** 1/2

Batman & Robin * 1/2

Batman Begins *** 1/2

The Dark Knight ****

Batman (1966): B-
Batman (1989): C
Batman Returns: C-
Batman Forever: D+
Batman and Robin: D
Batman Begins: A-
The Dark Knight: A-

Batman Mask of the Phantasm: A-
Batman Sub Zero: B+
Batman Beyond Return of the Joker: B+
Batman Year One: B+
Batman Under the Red Hood: A-

I agree, and you go and post in here even though you are calling it spam, nice.

Batman (1966) 6
Batman (1989) 9
Batman Returns (1992) 7
Batman Forever (1995) 8
Batman & Robin (1997) 3
Batman Begins (2005) 8
The Dark Knight (2008) 10
The Dark Knight Rises (2012) 7

Batman (1989) 8
Batman Returns (1992) 8
Batman Forever (1995) 0
Batman & Robin (1997) 0
Batman Begins (2005) 10
The Dark Knight (2008) 10
The Dark Knight Rises (2012) 10

The Tim Burton films were okay but they could use work in some areas.
Batman Forever and Batman and Robin need to have their titles switched.
Batman Forever: The only problem I had with this movie was Two Face's character. I just prefer the Dark Knight portrayal.
Batman and Robin: So many things wrong with this. The Plot is dumb. A little too cartoony is some areas. George Clooney. Mr. Freeze's Puns, man, THE PUNS!! ! Batgirl shows up out of nowhere.
Do I have to? Oh, Alright. (*cough*joelschumacherishistorysgreatestmonster*cough cough*)

Dark Knight Trilogy: Everything is done right.

Batman 1989: A

Batman Returns: B+

Batman Forever: C+

Batman & Robin: F

Batman Begins: A+

The Dark Knight: A+

The Dark Knight Rises: A+

Updated version:

Batman 66 - 3
Batman 89 - 8
Batman Returns - 8
Batman Forever - 3
Batman and Robin - 0
Batman Begins - 10
The Dark Knight - 10
The Dark Knight Rises - 10

Mask of the Phantasm - 10
Sub Zero - 8
Return of the Joker - 8
Under the Red Hood - 9
Year One - 9
Dark Knight Returns - 8

Batman (1989) 6
Batman Returns (1992) 5
Batman Forever (1995) 1
Batman & Robin (1997) -1
Batman Begins (2005) 9.5
The Dark Knight (2008) 10
The Dark Knight Rises (2012) 9