No More Nostalgia Critic

Post Reply New Topic

I am disappointed that the NC is ending, but honestly I haven't really been into his reviews the past few months, I do think it's better to end with dignity than to let the show drag on. I do hope he comes back on occasion, since there are movies I would really like to see him review.

Milo and Otis was reviewed by the Nostalgia Chick, btw.

Doug's show was nothing more than a masterpiece in the genre of "Internet Reviews", if you will. I will miss the Nostalgia Critic a lot and to be honest I don't think it was getting stale in the slightest. The show gave me many laughs. Now I have to go and revisit his Batman and Robin review.

After rewatching his first season (2008), here are my personal top 11 favorite reviews. I'm excluding his Top 11 list videos and any other special vids he may have done (the AVGN feud, evil Teddy Ruxpin).

11. Mortal Kombat: Annihilation
10. Howard The Duck
9. Saved By The Bell
8. Double Dare
7. Super Mario Bros Movie
6. Jingle All The Way
5. Godzilla
4. Surf Ninjas
3. Kazaam
2. The Wizard
1. Batman & Robin

Honorable Mentions: Drug Cartoon Special, Street Fighter, Tom & Jerry Movie

EDIT: I probably should clarify that these were my favorites from just the first season. I should have my 2009 list up pretty soon.

Last edited by crmoore on 10 Oct 2012, 1:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Here are probably my top 20 though not in any particular order and I'm only including films. Remember I said probably as I might miss some out. I originally wanted to do the traditional 11 but there were so many films I decided to extend it to 20 and yet I'm not sure if I put the right films on.

1) Judge Dredd
2) All the Star Trek reviews at once
3) Turkish Rambo
4) Airbourne
5) The Legend of Titanic
6) Santa Claus the Movie
7) Felix the Cat
Babes in Toyland
9) Blair Witch 2
10) Thomas and the Magic Railroad
11) The Room
12) Good Burger
13) North
14) Captain America
15) Cool as Ice
16) Ponyo
17) A Simple Wish
18) Mr Magoo
19) Richie Rich
20) Steel

All right, here's my Top 11 NC Reviews list from the 2009 season:

11. Gargoyles
10. Moonwalker
9. Full House
8. Ernest Saves Christmas
7. Star Wars Holiday Special
6. Good Burger
5. Judge Dredd
4. Superman IV
3. Adventures Of Sonic The Hedgehog
2. Fern Gully
1. Casper

Honorable Mentions: Red Sonja, Alone In The Dark, North

2010 list should be coming ASAP, but at first glance it looks like it was a slower year IMO.

Well, it seem he's back : http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-critic/38009-the-review-must-go-on

Tollorin wrote

Yeah I know. February 5th I believe with a film called The Odd Life of Timothy Green. Have absolutely no idea what that's about but we'll see.