Well, I very much enjoyed it, but then again I also really enjoyed X-Men 3.
It's fun. Entertaining. Got a lot of humor, some good action, and ties up the story. However, there's so much about it that doesn't work that I don't know why it is that I enjoyed it as much as I did! I guess it's one of those movies like "Van Helsing" that's entertaining on the surface level, but only on the surface level.
Everything you did and didn't want to know about "Spider-Man 3":
-Are the special effects sh***y compared to those of "Spider-Man 2"? Yep. Atrociously rubbery. Think "Blade 2," except slightly better and used far more often.
-Does Spidey 3 make some really awful storytelling decisions? Definately. There are things that reek of "convinient" and "sloppy." Characters just happen to stumble into situations that wind up defining them.
-Does Venom suck? Oh, god, Venom is terrible! His voice is wimpy as hell--actually, it's not even his voice, it's just Eddie Brock's voice. That's right--Venom's voice doesn't change when he becomes Venom! He's never referred to as Venom, his face looks off...one of the best things about Venom is that he has this monstrous face with a huge friggin' tongue. No tongue here. Normal-shaped face, just with fangs and Venom-y eyes. And half the time the face squirms off so we see Venom's body with Brock's face. Venom's body, by the way, just looks like a black (and very CG) Spider-Man, and doesn't even have the white spider emblam. I never thought I'd be glad he was only in it for the last 20 minutes--if he had been in any more of it I would have been too annoyed by it to enjoy the movie. I mean, I'm not a fanboy--I never read the comics. But I know what Venom looks like, and without that huge tongue he's just not nearly as cool or monstrous. The scene where Eddie Brock becomes Venom is very cool, though.
-Is there really a "The Mask"-style dance scene to show Peter's corruption? Yes, but it worked in the film better than I thought it would. The scene wasn't overlong and served its purpose, even if it would have been better for Peter to realize his mistake while almost killing Rhino or something.
-Are there as many annoying screaming women as there were in "Spider-Man 2"? Thankfully, no.
-Does MJ get kidnapped AGAIN? Of course--she must have fantasies of getting raped or something.
-Do we get to see the imprints of her nipples like in the last two? I didn't notice them this time. Maybe she finally learned to never go outside without wearing a bra!
-What about the already-infamous "Butler" bit? Yeah, everyone in the audience was laughing their butts off at that part. But they still clapped at the end.
-????Bruce Campbell??? Oh you betcha. He's got a good cameo this time. Very funny! I'm a little disappointed though--I was hoping his cameo would be of a villain who Spider-Man kicks the ass of in some montage or something. Stan Lee's got a cameo, too, as always. The audience cracked up when he randomly walked into the shot.
-What about that skinny Russian chick who gave Peter milk and cake in Spidey 2? She's back with a cookie-serving vegence! Sadly, she doesn't knock over anything in this one, so no funny kitchen fires. I'm so glad the rumors of her becoming Black Cat weren't true.
-Is there another annoying scene with people on the street "singing" the Spider-Man theme song with untrained voices and out-of-tune violins? Thank god, none of that.
-Is there more gratuitus posing in front of flags? Sigh...it's a series tradition, unfortunately.
-How's Sandman? They Dock-Ock him out, meaning they make him all sympathetic and s**t. It's kinda cheesy. I prefer Neil Gaiman's The Sandman series--completely different Sandman from a completely different universe, I know, but who cares?
-What about Harry? For sheer Harryness, he gets upstaged by the spactacular "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix" trailer. His arc's a bit cliche here but, again, it worked better than I thought it would.
-So despite all this you actually enjoyed it? Surprisingly! It made me laugh, and I got caught up in the action and the characters...it was fun. Just a fun night at the movies. Fans of the comics will loath the thing, but go in with low expectations and you may walk out pleasantly surprised. Hopefully.
-BONUS QUESTION: I want a spidey shmock. So buy one.