TheSilentOne wrote:
Mythos wrote:
TheSilentOne wrote:
I personally enjoyed Class (the newest Doctor Who spinoff) but I guess it wasn't popular enough to get a second series and a lot of people I talk to really disliked it.
I watched a bit, but it was clearly meant to be tween, a bit too mild for me. It also had a very strong Waterloo Road vibe, which made me feel like they were pushing a bit too much for the schoolyard drama genre which is far too overdone at this point.
To be honest, I haven't had interest in Doctor Who since Matt Smith became the Doctor. I think they reached the whole running out of ideas mark at that point.
I see what you are saying. My personal favorite of the spinoffs is Torchwood followed by The Sarah Jane Adventures. Now that I think about it, Class was somewhat like Waterloo Road (which I actually enjoy too, got into it because I wanted to watch Jenna Coleman's episodes, but it hooked me for a while). I remember seeing someone on Tumblr compare Class to Torchwood saying it was like an alternate universe of Torchwood, and that the characters were somewhat similar but younger, high-school versions.
I didn't really watch Torchwood but I did see bits here and there. I was interested in Doctor Who at the time but I don't think I ever really cared much for spinoff shows.
In my opinion, a Doctor Who spinoff which is a lot darker / grittier than the show itself would have a lot more appeal to it. I think Torchwood was maybe a bit like this but, again, I didn't watch it much so I don't know.
On that note, Netflix picks up a lot of shows that have potential and I think Doctor Who being a BBC show really drags it down, with lack of funding and limitations on touching upon more sensitive topics (the BBC are fairly renowned for being a bit too safe with their content). In this sense, a Netflix show, or anything similar, would be rather intriguing in my opinion.
As it stands though, most of these shows are a bit too tame for me. Don't get me wrong, I'm really not into scares and such, but there's a lot more they could do with the franchise if they targeted a more mature audience.
I guess it's really opinions at this point though. Some people like hard themes and others just want something lighter. I can respect that.