You may not recognize many because they are older. You can take issue but that is my observation and the internet is 90% about opinions. You will find that people like Hayao Miyazaki are harder on the current anime industry than I. You have to keep in mind that I have been into this for a long time. I have over 1000 DVD's/BD's and about 2 TBs of fansubs. I find too much modern anime panders too heavily to the otaku subculture. As I mentioned, Miyazaki really hates that fact and believes it has limited the realism as characters are so 2 dimensional. The prevalence of fads in which everyone is doing the same thing is another problem. The Moe fad that started in the mid 2000's lead to a lot of shows that relied heavily on "cute girls" in favor of substance. Harem anime beyond more generic that it ever was has been another issue. Some of them are so similar it is frightening. Not all Moe or Harem anime are bad but both have fallen into a mold that is stiff. Another formula which has been a quick go to is "Ordinary teen encounters monsters/demons/etc.. and finds out he/she is the chosen one who can wield massive power to defeat them. If male, they usually encounter a girl who needs to be saved which awakens powers."
Not all titles with these cliches are bad but I find you have to dig for the ones that are legitimately good. Recent titles I have found entertaining include Madoka, Oreimo, Gundam Unicorn, Wooser's Hand to Mouth Life, Anohana, Fate/stay night Unlimited Blade Works, The Tales of Princess Kaguya, Sword Art Online, what I watched of it, was interesting. Even of the titles that are more mediocre I can find entertainment but I get more excited when somebody fansubs (or Discotek licenses) what is considered a classic in Japan. I feel like we have traded talented storytellers for otaku. It is like fanfiction, just because you are passionate about it does not mean you can produce something that is good. I actually do want to watch Little Busters as Key is actually very good at doing romance/harem stories.
We, in the US, actually have fewer companies now releasing anime than 10/11 years ago. Not counting Hentai specific companies (there were several of those) there were 14 distributors. Today there are 10, arguably 12. We have gained Aniplex (Their prices make me think it more a loss than a gain), NISA, and Crunchyroll if you want to count it. We have lost Pioneer/Geneon, Bandai Entertainment, Bandai Visual USA, Central Park Media/US Manga Corps, AnimEigo (mostly samurai films now), Urban Vision, Synchpoint, ADV (split into Sentai and Section 23), and Tokyopop. Manga is still around but doesn't do anything. Anime is actually not at it's peak anymore. There was a time when it made a lot more money and companies more actively went after licenses. A lot of companies ended up bankrupt due to drops in sales and interest. It has been argued that the mindset of fans who got into the medium in the past 7 or so years is greatly different from those who were into it during the bubble in the early 2000's. A major reason why we still get as much as we do is because the licensing costs have fallen considerably and US companies are more likely to invest in a show before/during development. There was a time when licenses were up 10 times higher than today but sales were strong enough that companies could stay in business and continue picking things up left and right. It is more "mainstream" but not as strong or lucrative.
On the Mecha genre... One of the strengths for a long time was the depth of ideas. Mobile Suit Gundam and the first sequel Zeta are both excellent anti-war stories. Most of the Gundam title set in the Universal Century fit in this category. Mecha has gotten kind of flashy. Or, in the case with Gurren Lagann, tries to be deep but falls on it's face.
jrjones9933 wrote:
If you read the previous pages, you'll see that I fiercely defend people's right to like what they want, MrBear, but I take issue with you calling modern anime generic. With more companies importing anime, we have a vast, diverse array of choices, Sturgeon's Law nonwithstanding.
I don't recognize a lot of your favorites, but I see a few giant battle robot shows. I haven't found a lot to like lately in that genre. Infinite Stratos kind of got on my nerves, and I didn't make it past episode 2 of Majestic Prince. I did like Idolm@ster Xenoglossia, though.
I keep meaning to watch Clannad. People have suggested it when I said how much I liked Little Busters.