Skibz888 wrote:
From what I understand, 'Robin Hood' originally began life as a script called 'Nottingham', which would have been based on, of course, the Sheriff of Nottingham and subverted the Robin Hood mythology from a whole different perspective. Those who read the original scripts said it was an excellent concept, but once Ridley Scott signed on he completely changed everything and the film ended up being another hum-drum retread of the Robin Hood fable. I've honestly heard more people talk about the 'Nottingham' that never was rather than the 'Robin Hood' which actually got made.
I joined the rest of America in not having seen 'Robin Hood', but I did see both cuts of 'Kingdom of Heaven' and agree the director's cut was the superior choice. I doubt any cut could fix the mess that was last year's 'Exodus', though.
I'm actually glad they didn't make
Nottingham. Not only did Ridley Scott have no interest in it, Russell Crowe didn't like it because it was basically
C.S.I. Sherwood Forest, which sounds terribly gimmicky and not too interesting. I also read an interview with one of the
Nottingham screenwriters (Ethan Reiff) in which he went into more detail about the script, and it just confirmed my suspicion that they made the right decision in tossing it.
And the story they went with certainly isn't "another hum-drum retread of the Robin Hood fable." It's not really the traditional Robin Hood story at all, which is why I wish they had changed the title to something like
Robin Hood: The Early Years or
Robin Hood: The Beginning. It's a story about medieval England on the verge of civil war, with the dueling sides brought together to combat a French invasion by the man who becomes Robin Hood about sixty seconds before the credits roll. It has much more in common with
Kingdom of Heaven than any other Robin Hood film I've seen.
Of course, you can see the film and make up your own mind, if you do decide to watch it at some point. Just make sure it's the director's cut you watch, and don't go into it expecting anything like the traditional Robin Hood story.