rossc wrote:
What makes a good film?
Sure the Critics can marvel over this or turn their noses up at that, but in the end it is a product for the consumers. If Joe Public like a film and are happy watching it, it is a "good film".
If it is fanciful and with a brilliant plot but people are not interested in it and don't recommend it, it is a "bad film".
I don't think it's that simple, to be honest. I mean,
Plan 9 From Outer Space is officially the Worst Movie Ever Made, but it's tremendously entertaining in its awfulness. Sometimes bad can be good precisely
because it's bad, if that makes any sense
In a Cameron-related example, I can say without shame that I enjoy
Aliens far more than I do
Alien, even though I know that in terms of film-making technique, innovation and style, the latter is by far the better movie, in pretty much every respect.
_________________
Why so serious?