CyclopsSummers wrote:
I think this might be the crucial difference between Family Guy and The Simpsons, though. The Simpsons drew from a wide, varied spectrum of cultural references, socio-political ones, pop cultural ones, it was very much an everyman's comedy show. Family Guy also enjoys great popularity, but you can see that it draws from a much narrower pool of references. Who cares about Growing Pains or The Facts Of Life in 2014? How are you gonna stay relevant if you want to sell those jokes to 15-year-olds?
And I actually like Family Guy, which is not a popular opinion on most online communities I visit. I therefore do find it surprising to see that Family Guy is criticized here for being too elitist or exclusive, even if they draw from 80s movie and TV references and push Seth MacFarlane's personal political views without throwing in all that much nuance, since the complaints I usually read about the show draw attention to how it caters to the lowest common denominator by going for the quick jokes, featuring lots of coarse and violent jokes that are seemingly unrelated to the narrative. And I can agree with that, even if I do get a lot of laughs out of this show. But that's what surprised me about this thread. That Family Guy would be viewed as 'in-jokey' at all, when it is usually played up as the opposite of that.
I actually like
Family Guy quite a bit myself, and so does my daughter (I know, boo, hiss to a dad like me for letting my nine year old watch the show!).
_________________
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer