rocklobster wrote:
The_Perfect_Storm wrote:
Light (Death Note) - Pretty much brought order to the world. Crime was massively reduced.
@rocklobster: I don't think that Dr. Tenma belongs up there. He was no hero. His obsession with Johan led him down a dark path. It's questionable whether he actually accomplished anything good in the end.
As for Cloud... I think he was actually unconscious during the entire anime. Zack was the real hero.
Saying Light is a hero to me is like saying Hitler is one. Just sayin'
To me Tenma belongs because he didn't kill Johan. He was trying to change Johan. It's not his fault Johan didn't change.
I take it you never watched Advent Children? He was awake during all of that.
Advent Children isn't an anime. They are completely different styles.
Light was one of the good guys. He definitely had some extreme ideas but he never really wavered from that ideal. And he won, for a long time. End justifies the means.
L, Mello and Near were not heroes. They were all in it for selfish reasons and they didn't particularly care who got hurt.
For me Tenma doesn't belong because he not only didn't accomplish anything, he obsessed for a long time about murder and got involved with criminals regularly. His decision at the end was more about redemption than anything else. He finally got his life back.