Hi Brian
Welcome to WP!
Yeah, a lot of us have had similar situations with friends. When you're on the spectrum, it's especially hard to find people whose wavelength resonates with your own. I was lucky and found a few quirky non-spectrum gals at a job in my late teens.
Unfortunately, I moved away to complete my bachelor degrees. It's been tough finding new friends since then. Again I was lucky because I lived in San Francisco with all the best fun loving crazies, but it took me almost 10 years to finally start feeling a part of a community again, and then I ended up moving to eastern Kansas a year ago. If you're originally from the Midwest, I can only imagine how much harder it was to meet compatible people.
In the year I've been out here, the only few crazies I've met have all been the bad kind, and the other people that I've interacted with have very superficially friendly to me right up until a bit of my Aspies sneaks out. Then suddenly they plaster on a super wide-eyed exaggerated smile and start speaking to me like I'm a Jr Rainman... I haven't had much luck to be honest.
That said, are there any MeetUps in your area? I just committed to putting myself back out there and lucked across a single not completely defunct ASD MeetUp group about an hour away from me. While I'd rather find some quirky gals again, if I can even find a compatible Aspie friend to commiserate with in person, I'd call it a success
Just remember, if you do reach out, you got to give to receive. Either way, welcome to our community!