"Mark all topics read"

Post Reply New Topic

This is a very minor change that I think might be really appropriate for this site.

I used forums sites for many many years before I learned what "Mark all topics read" meant. I only learned what it meant several years ago because I was running some forums at the time and I wanted to speed up my site as much as possible, so I was removing unnecessary things so there wouldn't be as much stuff to download on each page. I didn't know what that link did, so I removed it.

That day I got so so so many complaints from people at my site asking why I had removed the link for making all topics look like they didn't have any new posts since the last time they'd been read.

My thought was basically "Oh. So that's what it does."

I had always interpreted "Mark all topics read" as "Mark all topics [that you have] read" instead of "Mark all topics [as having already been] read". I didn't understand why I would want to mark all of the topics that I had already read, because the icons changed for those topics already, and I didn't understand what was happening when I clicked the link.

I would recommend changing the language file so that "Mark all topics read" is "Mark all topics as read". I know that it's a very minor difference, but "Mark all topics read" can be interpreted in at least two ways, and I think that users of this site in particular might benefit from specificity.