What i hate about SSI
Not everyone that complains is a whiner with a low work ethic. Sure people take advantage of "the system" but those people are the outliers, the vast majority that receive benefits do so under full qualification of the law, both intent and letter.
I was fortunate enough to be left a decent plot of land with no mortgage by my parents. I don't have a normal "job" I live a subsistence lifestyle, my labor is used to make my own personal food, house repairs, etc, with a little left over production to sell at market to pay property tax and miscellaneous expenses that require currency. I'm very fortunate that I don't have to rely on government assistance, because in all honesty my inability to communicate in small groups has doomed any job I've ever held, regardless of the skills and work ethic I possess. Now, I read these forums and I see a lot of other autistics who have the same job issues that I had and they are forced to rely on government assistance. I can't help but feel empathy and compassion because that very easily would be me if I were not lucky enough to have generous parents that got satisfaction from long term planning.
It's a remarkable gift I received: the ability to provide for myself, truly provide for myself, not rely on a job, or some other person, but to truly sustain one's self purely from one's own labor. Now if you asked most autistics on SSI if they'd rather stay on SSI for perpetuity or say live my lifestyle, the vast majority would most likely take my lifestyle. That's because they're not lazy whiners, the vast majority do want to work, earn an income, or at least feel that they are providing for themselves, but the jobs that they can fit into just don't exist or they're overlooked for those jobs in favor of someone more "normal".
These problems will only increase as time goes by, our society has been weighing social skills over actual production numbers since WWII ended and the trend is moving that direction exponentially. There's going to be a lot more autistics on SSI in the future, demonizing them as lazy whiners won't rectify that problem, but giving them the opportunity to show their work ethic will-- even if that's on a small 10 acre farm, far from society, just providing for themselves.
Apology to Bea, my aspie senses got the better of me and I did a very narrow reading of your post. I apologize for my above post (still keeping it up for other's benefit), I read one sentence that rubbed me the wrong way while ignoring all the other valuable advice you offered. Again, I apologize for going on a tirade due to one comment. I still stand by my assertion of people on SSI, but I would be remiss in not acknowledging that it was a minor point in a larger picture you were trying to frame.
Thanks for that, Aristophanes.
Actually, being on any kind of disability does a mind warp on you, and this is worth mentioning. First you question if you are really entitled to this benefit. Maybe you COULD work if you just tried hard enough. Then you try to work and fail miserably; or like a lot of autistic people, you hold it together at first but maybe then you have a meltdown. You're mad at yourself, but maybe you try yet again. Another lost job. Now you feel worthless. Someone insists you apply for SSI, or SSDI if you qualify, but to complete your application, you have to write a lot of negative (though true) stuff about yourself, which is really depressing.
For this reason alone, I suggest you have another person work through the process with you. It can be a friend, relative, paid advocate, or case manager in an agency. Most people will get very discouraged by being forced to put all their weaknesses and shortcomings in writing. Having another person help you do this can buffer some of the emotional impact.
_________________
A finger in every pie.
The SSI rules are pretty strange. For example if you have a relative pay for groceries or your rent, your SSI can be reduced by up to 1/3 of the SSI. On the other hand that same relative can buy you clothing or or pay for your cell phone, and the SSI will not be reduced. Supposedly the idea is that they consider that you are getting special shared benefits if you are getting free food or shelter covered by a relative. If you live with your parents, the SSI is reduced by 1/3 as well, unless you are paying rent. I believe if you live with another person getting SSI you would get the full amount, but the rules are rather confusing.
Not everyone that complains is a whiner with a low work ethic. Sure people take advantage of "the system" but those people are the outliers, the vast majority that receive benefits do so under full qualification of the law, both intent and letter.
I was fortunate enough to be left a decent plot of land with no mortgage by my parents. I don't have a normal "job" I live a subsistence lifestyle, my labor is used to make my own personal food, house repairs, etc, with a little left over production to sell at market to pay property tax and miscellaneous expenses that require currency. I'm very fortunate that I don't have to rely on government assistance, because in all honesty my inability to communicate in small groups has doomed any job I've ever held, regardless of the skills and work ethic I possess. Now, I read these forums and I see a lot of other autistics who have the same job issues that I had and they are forced to rely on government assistance. I can't help but feel empathy and compassion because that very easily would be me if I were not lucky enough to have generous parents that got satisfaction from long term planning.
It's a remarkable gift I received: the ability to provide for myself, truly provide for myself, not rely on a job, or some other person, but to truly sustain one's self purely from one's own labor. Now if you asked most autistics on SSI if they'd rather stay on SSI for perpetuity or say live my lifestyle, the vast majority would most likely take my lifestyle. That's because they're not lazy whiners, the vast majority do want to work, earn an income, or at least feel that they are providing for themselves, but the jobs that they can fit into just don't exist or they're overlooked for those jobs in favor of someone more "normal".
These problems will only increase as time goes by, our society has been weighing social skills over actual production numbers since WWII ended and the trend is moving that direction exponentially. There's going to be a lot more autistics on SSI in the future, demonizing them as lazy whiners won't rectify that problem, but giving them the opportunity to show their work ethic will-- even if that's on a small 10 acre farm, far from society, just providing for themselves.
I was going to say that that really wasn't what Bea was saying, but then you caught it so moving on...that.sounds.amazing. It's like my dream come true (for you). The one downside, i'm sure, is healthcare which i used to say ptthhh to, but now i need it and wow does it cost!! ! Nonetheless, wow!
_________________
"When does the human cost become too high for the building of a better machine?"
2) It's incredibly inconvenient to do this. The phone lines take hours and often you never are spoken to, and it's pretty much impossible to do it online, so you have to go to an office with a bunch of creepy people and sit down for HOURS. The SSI office hours are also insanely short, and they tend to be located in the ghetto.
3) It's hardly any money. Generally it's between $500 and $750 a month, which is not even enough to rent a studio apartment. With food stamps and a roommate, you can just barely make ends meet and enjoy a nightly ramen or baked potato.
4) if you work, you have to give a huge chunk of money back to the government, to the point it's the equivalent of making $5 an hour or less if you make minimum wage. If you are a waitress, you might be making less than $2 an hour after what you have to give back. This makes working part time far less worthwhile.
5) The system is complicated and you are constantly bombarded with mail from them, making sure you're still you're still "legit disabled", as if having a disability is the same as having the flu. It is purposely done this way so people accidentally commit fraud or miss a deadline so they have an excuse to stop giving them benefits.
6) The $2,000 asset limit is draconian and hinders people from rising above collecting benefits, when they could hypothetically get off them by making wise investments or starting their own business. It doesn't seem fair to ban SSI recipients from investing when in many cases that's the only way they could otherwise make an independent income. This is especially revelant to Aspies who tend to be smart but not good at working with other people/the public.
I think it's because conservatives want the poor and people with disabilities to be as miserable as possible, if they can't work. What do you think? I suppose I'm grateful I get the benefits because otherwise I'd be homeless but damn, it's almost like being on probation.
I see what you're saying. I applied for SSI back in 2011, and got denied by April of that year. And it was all because they listened to what that doctor in Glen Burnie said instead of looking for my school records. My stupid ass sister even tried to talk me out of earning money online because she attempted to instill this false hope that I'll be approved first time. The only ones they give SSI to the first time are recovering drug addicts and alcoholics. If you have any other life threatening condition like HIV, heart disease, diabetes, lupus, etc., you're gonna get the run around. Then, if you do get approved, they make it hard for you by not giving out enough money to live off of and tell you to report what you do. BTW, I had no idea receiving SSI was like this. There are some people who are too sick to work like a neighbor of mine who had two strokes about six years ago, so I wonder if she has to go through this to receive a check. I also know she doesn't qualify for food stamps anymore. It's a bad system and they've been doing this for years. My mom was right about one thing: it's nothing but a game out here.
I disagree with several of Jenine's statements. I will not enumerate them here, but I'd like to add to what I have said before.
You need to discuss with your doctor, therapist/psychiatrist if applicable, and any others who may be contacted, the different reasons you feel you are disabled, and what sorts of things they would say if contacted. If they are not supportive, get someone else before you try to apply.
Second, you need to be a good writer as well as know what Social Security Administration is looking for, in filling out the "essay section" of the application. This is a place for short, pithy statements of concrete problems interfering with employment. My daughter (who got accepted on first try) described the sequence of problems she had getting out the door in the morning, from dislike of the sensations of showering, to fears of going outside her home. She had to describe what happened in previous attempts at employment and college, that caused her to fail - which is depressing, so a lot of people may not go into enough detail. She described her panic attacks and the sensations those involved. I helped by taking her descriptions and refining them to be concise yet compelling. If you can't write this the right way, get someone to help you, such as a social worker at a disability agency.
Third, you should list every single medical diagnosis you have, even if at first it doesn't seem relevant. You probably won't get SSI for having irritable bowel syndrome, alone; but if you have IBS, severe eczema, panic attacks, suicidal depression with homicidal urges, diagnosed (not self-diagnosed) autism, and sensory issues interfering with hygiene, you probably will be. If you have acne, no, that doesn't qualify for SSI. But if you have acne but continually pick at your lesions due to self-harm or obsessive issues - in addition to everything else - then that does contribute.
Most of us on the spectrum do have several co-morbid conditions, so you have to list them all.
Fourth, you need to complete your application as fully as possible, including looking up doctors, dates, addresses, etc. This is no time to get sloppy.
If you can do all of these things, your chances of success on the application are much improved.
As to whether they give you enough to live on - well, there, I agree, it is something of a game. There are a number of assists you can get in the US and I'm sure other countries. Free bus passes, assistance with utility bills, subsidized housing, government medical benefits, food stamps, food pantries, free limited-minutes cell phone, are some of the things that make this work. If you try to maintain a good relationship with your family and friends, they may give you a number of things you couldn't afford on your own. My daughter was given a tablet computer and a game console that friends had grown out of. Also learn to shop garage sales and thrift or resale shops, for all sorts of household furnishings and personal possessions.
If you're more invested in griping than getting on with it, then, disregard everything I've written. But I may dispute your gripes, not that I don't want to be supportive but you may discourage others from applying for a program they need.
_________________
A finger in every pie.
You need to discuss with your doctor, therapist/psychiatrist if applicable, and any others who may be contacted, the different reasons you feel you are disabled, and what sorts of things they would say if contacted. If they are not supportive, get someone else before you try to apply.
Second, you need to be a good writer as well as know what Social Security Administration is looking for, in filling out the "essay section" of the application. This is a place for short, pithy statements of concrete problems interfering with employment. My daughter (who got accepted on first try) described the sequence of problems she had getting out the door in the morning, from dislike of the sensations of showering, to fears of going outside her home. She had to describe what happened in previous attempts at employment and college, that caused her to fail - which is depressing, so a lot of people may not go into enough detail. She described her panic attacks and the sensations those involved. I helped by taking her descriptions and refining them to be concise yet compelling. If you can't write this the right way, get someone to help you, such as a social worker at a disability agency.
Third, you should list every single medical diagnosis you have, even if at first it doesn't seem relevant. You probably won't get SSI for having irritable bowel syndrome, alone; but if you have IBS, severe eczema, panic attacks, suicidal depression with homicidal urges, diagnosed (not self-diagnosed) autism, and sensory issues interfering with hygiene, you probably will be. If you have acne, no, that doesn't qualify for SSI. But if you have acne but continually pick at your lesions due to self-harm or obsessive issues - in addition to everything else - then that does contribute.
Most of us on the spectrum do have several co-morbid conditions, so you have to list them all.
Fourth, you need to complete your application as fully as possible, including looking up doctors, dates, addresses, etc. This is no time to get sloppy.
If you can do all of these things, your chances of success on the application are much improved.
As to whether they give you enough to live on - well, there, I agree, it is something of a game. There are a number of assists you can get in the US and I'm sure other countries. Free bus passes, assistance with utility bills, subsidized housing, government medical benefits, food stamps, food pantries, free limited-minutes cell phone, are some of the things that make this work. If you try to maintain a good relationship with your family and friends, they may give you a number of things you couldn't afford on your own. My daughter was given a tablet computer and a game console that friends had grown out of. Also learn to shop garage sales and thrift or resale shops, for all sorts of household furnishings and personal possessions.
If you're more invested in griping than getting on with it, then, disregard everything I've written. But I may dispute your gripes, not that I don't want to be supportive but you may discourage others from applying for a program they need.
About what you just said. I was very specific the first time I applied for SSI. I told them about being diagnosed with PDD-NOS sometime around my 4th birthday, also having ADHD and said that this was all in my school records. I even went down to an SSI application center in Columbia with my dad to get help in filling out the form. At the time, I was still working that hospital job, but it was about to end. All I'm saying is that even if someone has an even more life threatening condition, they can still get denied. In my case, despite being specific about how my Autism affects me, I was still denied because they couldn't find my diagnosis in my school records. So, I gave up because I was afraid of being denied over and over again regardless of if I listed all the specifics, which I did mention most of them. Maybe it's different where you live, but here in Maryland chances are you're not gonna be approved the first time. I didn't say all this to discourage anyone who needs disability benefits from applying, but I was just listing how hard it is to do so.
So wait, on SSI you can't have anyone even your parents help you financially? That seems pretty messed up to me, like your mom couldn't pay for a phone line to call you on? I don't understand how they expect people to survive otherwise, people on SSI don't even get enough to live independently in a lot of places with their entire check.
If an individual receives Social Security Administration SSI benefits, they are limited to receiving less than $85.00 a month from anyone. Amounts beyond $85.00 will result in the SSI benefits being reduced slightly (not dollar-for-dollar, but somewhat). HOWEVER, family members and friends may (and are encouraged) to pay the individual's bills that aren't related to housing, food and cash assets. Family members and friends may also give gifts of any value (clothes, shoes, books, DVDs, Blu-Ray discs, vacations, appliances, cameras, stamp collections, coin collections, etc.) EXCEPT gift cards. They may even give the individual a motor vehicle as long as its re-sale value is below $5,000.00. And, they may pay other expenses (continuing education, medical and dental expenses, haircuts etc.) that aren't related to housing, food and cash assets. Finally, parents or siblings may make "Special Needs Trusts" for the individual. A trust lawyer within the individual's state should draft the trust papers. When the trust is created, the family members may fund it with cash benefits to be used after the fund-maker's death. If and when the individual needs additional money to pay for the items that are described above, the trustee decides if the cash allowance is legitimate and valid.
Sorry to be so detailed, but there are many ways that family members, friends and others can assist an individual who receives SSI benefits without jeopardizing the benefits.
_________________
Diagnosed in 2015 with ASD Level 1 by the University of Utah Health Care Autism Spectrum Disorder Clinic using the ADOS-2 Module 4 assessment instrument [11/30] -- Screened in 2014 with ASD by using the University of Cambridge Autism Research Centre AQ (Adult) [43/50]; EQ-60 for adults [11/80]; FQ [43/135]; SQ (Adult) [130/150] self-reported screening inventories -- Assessed since 1978 with an estimated IQ [≈145] by several clinicians -- Contact on WrongPlanet.net by private message (PM)
Jacoby
Veteran
Joined: 10 Dec 2007
Age: 33
Gender: Male
Posts: 14,284
Location: Permanently banned by power tripping mods lol this forum is trash
So wait, on SSI you can't have anyone even your parents help you financially? That seems pretty messed up to me, like your mom couldn't pay for a phone line to call you on? I don't understand how they expect people to survive otherwise, people on SSI don't even get enough to live independently in a lot of places with their entire check.
If an individual receives Social Security Administration SSI benefits, they are limited to receiving less than $85.00 a month from anyone. Amounts beyond $85.00 will result in the SSI benefits being reduced slightly (not dollar-for-dollar, but somewhat). HOWEVER, family members and friends may (and are encouraged) to pay the individual's bills that aren't related to housing, food and cash assets. Family members and friends may also give gifts of any value (clothes, shoes, books, DVDs, Blu-Ray discs, vacations, appliances, cameras, stamp collections, coin collections, etc.) EXCEPT gift cards. They may even give the individual a motor vehicle as long as its re-sale value is below $5,000.00. And, they may pay other expenses (continuing education, medical and dental expenses, haircuts etc.) that aren't related to housing, food and cash assets. Finally, parents or siblings may make "Special Needs Trusts" for the individual. A trust lawyer within the individual's state should draft the trust papers. When the trust is created, the family members may fund it with cash benefits to be used after the fund-maker's death. If and when the individual needs additional money to pay for the items that are described above, the trustee decides if the cash allowance is legitimate and valid.
Sorry to be so detailed, but there are many ways that family members, friends and others can assist an individual who receives SSI benefits without jeopardizing the benefits.
Thanks for clearing that up, it seems like they don't want people getting money towards things they can also get the government pay for which I guess makes sense in terms of preventing fraud and making sure they meet "economic need" altho I think their definition of "economic need" is very draconian.
Pure Conservatism, OTOH, would leave the disabled to be looked after by their families, churches and communities, rather than Big Government, so you'd be free to be dependent on your relatives, or some charity, or get a job and make your own way - then you could make your own money to invest and start your own business. Of course, you could ditch the SSI and do that now.
Your theory sounds good, but in reality, the family, church, and charity aren't always there. I know. I have been working with poor and marginalized people for years. It's a nightmare trying to help people solve their problems--even with all the "liberal, big government programs". The resources oftentimes are not there. Or you have to deal with incompetent people. Or you have to deal with downright abusive people who are suppose to help but neglect or exploit the people they are supposed to care for. I don't know what the answer is. We don't live in a perfect society, but I know pure conservatism isn't the answer. That's how things were before these programs were created. The fact that people weren't being taken care of is why these programs were created.
To the original poster, I agree. SSI is a pain. It's hard to live on government assistance, and it does limit your life. Hang in there and keep your head up. I wish I had some specific advice I could give you about how to improve your situation but I don't really know enough about your particular situation.
As much as I hate SSI, I would be dead without it. Because of a mental illness independent from suspected autism, I get hospitalized on average once every three months. My anxiety is so severe and can hit me at any moment that I sometimes struggle to even leave the house, and when I do I have to go to a restroom or another quiet area several times due to sensory overload/disassociation. People who tell me to "get a job" do not understand the following:
-I spent 2 years, from ages 18 to 20, actively searching for a suitable job. Every single job that I can do, at least in my area, hasn't even considered me due to my lack of experience.
-I once worked at a Taco Bell for a week and the stress and stimuli of it put me in the hospital.
-If employment was easy enough for me that I could make more money than $733/month, I would. I don't enjoy being poor and the only SSI recipients that love it are the ones who scam the system and collect multiple checks.
As for family, my family cares about me enough to let me live with them for only $300/month, but they are not going to take care of me. They, like so many others, have an ignorant view on mental/social disabilities and the only reason they don't bug me so much about not having a job is because I pay them something.
If this were the 1950's before SSI existed I would either be dead or living in an asylum.
PS Most conservative families are close knit, so they assume everyone is like that. Not the case at all.
_________________
The world is backwards and upside down. So far they show no signs of hearing my voice; I am silenced and discounted yet I continue to shout until I can shout no more.
Sweetleaf
Veteran
Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 34
Gender: Female
Posts: 34,911
Location: Somewhere in Colorado
Pure Conservatism, OTOH, would leave the disabled to be looked after by their families, churches and communities, rather than Big Government, so you'd be free to be dependent on your relatives, or some charity, or get a job and make your own way - then you could make your own money to invest and start your own business. Of course, you could ditch the SSI and do that now.
Your theory sounds good, but in reality, the family, church, and charity aren't always there. I know. I have been working with poor and marginalized people for years. It's a nightmare trying to help people solve their problems--even with all the "liberal, big government programs". The resources oftentimes are not there. Or you have to deal with incompetent people. Or you have to deal with downright abusive people who are suppose to help but neglect or exploit the people they are supposed to care for. I don't know what the answer is. We don't live in a perfect society, but I know pure conservatism isn't the answer. That's how things were before these programs were created. The fact that people weren't being taken care of is why these programs were created.
To the original poster, I agree. SSI is a pain. It's hard to live on government assistance, and it does limit your life. Hang in there and keep your head up. I wish I had some specific advice I could give you about how to improve your situation but I don't really know enough about your particular situation.
^This. Also if people on SSI could just 'get a job' they wouldn't be on SSI in the first place something people like the poster donnie darko should get through their thick skull, it is income for people unable to work because of their disability. If someone knowingly able to work substantial employment is on SSI they are committing fraud and do not represent even half the people on SSI.
_________________
We won't go back.
I have had about 9 jobs in the last three years, I have been unable to keep and hold down jobs. Other than my Haunted House work as an actor. Yet, that is not nearly enough money, we get shows sporadically with the Murder Mystery and I get 20 dollars for each night I work. But that's two weekends so that's only 40 dollars, plus tips. Alongside the fact that I get paid seasonally 450 for my work at the Haunted House, during the Haunt season. It's still not enough to live off of.
I have also had 8 different housing situations within the last three years. I have been unable to keep a stable living situation.
I am currently fighting for SSI or SSD, but I am told because of my age, I'm 26 and look about 14-17, and that they are benefits to my condition.
So far I have not seen a single Autism benefit to my condition in the workplace, in my relationships, in my living situations.
So, what am I suppose to do?
People tell me to go to work, seems like an easy enough solution. Honestly it isn't. I have worked under the sun for so many different jobs. So many different places. I am either not face enough. Can't cope with the work load. Or consistently harassed by managers.
The "tough love" system in the workforce doesn't motivate me when someone is "yelling" [this is how I feel] at me, about how to work faster and better. It's not motivating, it's degrading and spirals me into meltdowns and anxiety and depression.
So, what am I suppose to do?
There is no perfect solution. It's go through all these loopholes and all these obstacles to prove I cannot function properly. Or try to find another job that I cannot keep.
Neither provides a livable situation. Or a stable life.
Whatever happened to the pursuit of happiness? Whatever happened to everyone having equal rights?
Because this system is slowly killing me mentally.