Wolfpup wrote:
I HATE Metal Gear Solid 3. To me the gameplay is completely broken. Ditto for Portable Opps. I'm expecting nothing from MGS4 as a result, but I guess I'll own it because it comes "free" with the new 80GB PS3 bundle.
How is it 'completely broken'? Is it because the lack of radar makes it harder on you?
Wolfpup wrote:
MGS2's story was weak, and overall the location was weak compared to the first game, but it was still a strong release.
My problem was all that postmodern crap at the end, and the Patriot's badgering of Raiden. Otherwise, a decent, if preachy, storyline.
Wolfpup wrote:
IMO MGS1 is the best in the series artistically and in terms of gameplay. Kujima seems to be throwing out a lot of "oh look, it's just a game!" because he's scared to have his games judged on their real artistic merits-at least that's my take on it.
I thought the Gamecube remake was artistically inferior to the original. I set them up side by side when I rented it, and was shocked by how much more artful the original's presentation is. I don't think a bump in resolution and texture filtering begins to make up for that.
I still think the Gamecube version is better in many respects, the voice-overs being probably the most important, with gameplay next. The graphics were a welcome upgrade, although I agree that the presentation in the cinemas can be OTT at times.
french_immersion wrote:
yay MGS 1 was by far the best. Cant beat the gritty look and cutscenes in that game. Meryl getting shot by Sniper Wolf is a moment you dont forget. The recent Metal Gear Solid games have been much worse in terms of plot, and they seem to have got ridiculously OTT. Like The Fear in MGS3 who isnt even human. and Vamp in MGS2.
The Fear is pretty out there, but it was said that he split his tongue through surgery, so it's really only the stealth and the eyes that need to be explained. The Fury worries me more (those freaky flaming heads) in terms of supernatural abilities.
In terms of unforgettable moments in the original MGS, Meryl's questioning of Snake just after he defeated Psycho Mantis, the death of Sniper Wolf, Gray Fox's speech just before being crushed by Metal Gear Rex (I thought Greg Eagles was decent, if a bit too Shakespearean, in that sequence, and Rob Paulsen was more naturalistic, but more boring, in the remake), and key sequences in both endings. In the Otacon ending, Snake's self-loathing when he discovers Meryl is dead, and in the Meryl ending, when he says to Meryl that he will live life for others. And the 'My name...is David'.
_________________
(No longer a mod)
On sabbatical...