Any anarchists here?

Post Reply New Topic

This is my first post on WP, but have been browsing the WP forums for some time, because finally, I have found people approaching the world from a 'different' perspective to those of the 'NTs' who surround me, a perspective which is more like my own, and since my biggest interests are Politics and Philosophy (currently perseverating on radical politics), I thought I'd post here first.
I am an anarchist-communist, and want a decentralized, grassroots-organised society of free-association-based communes - similar to the ideas of Peter Kropotkin or Murray Bookchin, this because I think that a free society in which everyone is provided with basic necessities would bring the greatest well-being for the greatest number of people, and that such a society is impossible to reach using vanguard parties because power corrupts. For a historical precedent there is the Paris Commune, the Spanish Revolution, the Makhnovists during the Russian Revolution, or the Mexican Zapatista movement. I also believe in radical social ecology, the idea that man's exploitation of Nature comes from the same oppressive hierarchical structure as man's oppression of man or woman, and also partially in the competitive, 'grow or die' nature of capitalism.
I was just wondering if anyone else here shared my opinions, or wished to debate them (love a good debate!).

I have certain anarchist sympathies, but i am first and foremost a technocrat and anti-capitalist.

I regard the anarchy-state dichotomy as a false.

Hello feralRobot.

Welcome to WP.

I considered myself one when I was younger, but nowadays, I'm not quite sure what my political stance is. Really, I'm in favor of a government that helps its citizens out while expecting almost nothing back, other than that citizens respect one another and don't go around killing/raping/stealing/etc.

I'm a post-leftist.

what do you think of the idea of a holarchic system, where there is no elite or political vanguard but instead each of those who are specialists in his or her field are the governors of his or her field?

In my heart I am an anarchist. I detest and despise government because government in its essence and at its root is an enemy of liberty and freedom. Unfortunately very few people are intelligent enough and have enough self control to make anarchism practical so we are stuck with government as an alternative to howling disorder. Think of Somalia here or Haitii. Government is the lesser of evils, not the best of good things. No government, however noble and hopeful its start has avoided turning into tyrancy somewhere down the line. Thus there are no good governments anywhere on the planet or anywhere in history. There are only bad governments and worse governments.

ruveyn

I'm an ultraminimalist dread pirate. I believe in courts, not states, that are agreed on a basic legal system that protects person and property (actual property, not "intellectual property", or an arbitrary claim to land), and not funded through coercion. When no-one has to work for a living, because of open source automation managed by the adhocrats at the local hackerspace, it's not hard to manage that. All volunteer police services, and you can start your own court if you want to - but if you're not actually being a just court, don't expect people to let you continue. Contract law can be handled through private arbitration. If people want to buy McBurgers, that's up to them, though McCompany are going to have to internalise the costs of being big, and customers will probably prefer the cheaper local place. I don't mind local councils though, to manage property that the residents have collective rights in - roads, parks etc. But they'll be nothing more than a corporation in which every resident has a share. If people want more interference in their neighbors lives, they can go live in a planned community - it would not surprise me if the majority of people ended up there, where they can enforce their own laws, and exile anyone who doesn't, maybe fining them for breaking the covenant that they signed when they joined.

Not quite an anarchist, but no friend of the state.

In a true anarchy, a manipulative sociopath will eventually seize power and become too powerful. Think of him as some kind of evil successor to Papa Smurf.

I did have an anarchist-communist phase for a little while when I was 13. These days I'm just a typical Marxist-Leninist.

_________________
Shy, awkward 16 year old communist girl whose main interests are 9/11, roller coasters and the 1917 Russian Revolution. I might not have any friends but somehow I have a really amazing boyfriend

Welcome FeralRobot
I agree with your ideal's, I used to passionately endorse such beliefs until I realized that unfortunately 'Might makes right' and that human nature will always prevent an altruistic government.