Page 2 of 3 [ 36 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next

jonathan79
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 1 Mar 2006
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 524
Location: FoCo

08 Jul 2006, 4:38 am

Taruby wrote:
Jonathan79,

I'm confused. I can agree with you that you can have as much hope as anyone else can,


I said this.

Taruby wrote:
but how do you get the idea that you can have more than they can hope to achieve?


I did NOT say this. I said that I have more hope in my life as a non-believer than I had as a believer.


_________________
Only a miracle can save me; too bad I don't believe in miracles.


Last edited by jonathan79 on 08 Jul 2006, 5:00 am, edited 2 times in total.

jonathan79
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 1 Mar 2006
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 524
Location: FoCo

08 Jul 2006, 4:58 am

Fuzzy wrote:
Well, I believe in god. That doesnt make me anything like an American fundamentalist though. fundaMENTAList. Yeah, thats in there for a reason. Someone had a sense of humour..

I believe in science, genetics, fiscal conservatism and Canada, but mostly I believe in ME!

That being said, you cannot heap pity on Emp. Whats between you and god is between you and god, and the same goes for Emp. Emp and atheists have chosen to delay this indefinately. If potential other parties(god) choose to negate this period, there is nothing that anyone, believer or not, can do about it.

People that condemn or claim condemnation for those that dont believe are simply putting their words in gods mouth. The bible might even say it(I dont think it does!), but its still not your place to do. It is hubris. (not saying that anyone local to the topic has done so).

DataImzadi wrote:
Absolutely nothing will convince me that there is no God.


This indicates that you do not have faith. You cannot ever have faith. You have unshakeable belief. Some would say blindness.

You no longer seek understanding, you think you have it. You are the hare that no longer races, thinking you have won, while Emp the tortoise, plods along, never thinking he will get a prize, but still he goes. Heaven awaits you? You have won before the race is over?

Faith is trust against your senses, against rationality. Faith is risk. Indiana Jones provides a perfect answer in the third movie, when he must step into an abyss, trusting that something(a bridge, or God, or whatever) will be there to catch him. Thats faith. Anything else is just knowledge or belief, or arrogance.

Thit is a good reason for prayers to go unanswered. You must doubt to have faith. If you do not doubt(knowledge or belief), you cannot have faith. If all prayers are answered, God is made knowledge, or belief becomes absolute, and faith is moot.

You believe in god, but you have no faith. You make no effort, take no risks. You act and speak as though you have won.

That's really sad for you, DataImzadi.


Fuzzy has provided some of the truest statements that a believer can provide. Although I have to disagree with this statement:

"Emp and atheists have chosen to delay this indefinately."

But, I have no choice, I´m an atheist. :lol:

Also, please do say that you feel sad for us DataImzadi, that means you pity us, which means you think that you´re better than we are.


_________________
Only a miracle can save me; too bad I don't believe in miracles.


Taruby
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker

User avatar

Joined: 4 Dec 2005
Age: 39
Gender: Male
Posts: 54

08 Jul 2006, 5:09 am

jonathan79 wrote:
Taruby wrote:
Jonathan79,

I'm confused. I can agree with you that you can have as much hope as anyone else can,


I said this.

Taruby wrote:
but how do you get the idea that you can have more than they can hope to achieve?


I did NOT say this. I said that I have more hope in my life as a non-believer than I had as a believer.


Jonathan79, your topic sentence came out like this:
Jonathan79 wrote:
Hold on just a minute there, an atheist can have plenty of hope, more hope than a believer can.

If taken separately from the rest of your statement. What confused me is that I didn't link the unknown believer to you since you used an indefinite article that is meant to insinuate any old believer. At least you corrected me in that wasn't your intention, but your words still had a confusing factor in them, good day.



jonathan79
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 1 Mar 2006
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 524
Location: FoCo

08 Jul 2006, 5:24 am

Taruby wrote:
If taken separately from the rest of your statement.


Thats the problem right there, I´m sorry, but I cannot help it if you choose to take part of my statement and ignore the rest and confuse yourself.


_________________
Only a miracle can save me; too bad I don't believe in miracles.


Taruby
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker

User avatar

Joined: 4 Dec 2005
Age: 39
Gender: Male
Posts: 54

08 Jul 2006, 4:24 pm

jonathan79 wrote:
Thats the problem right there, I´m sorry, but I cannot help it if you choose to take part of my statement and ignore the rest and confuse yourself.

I didn't ignore the rest of your statement, I just couldn't link your topic sentence to yourself since it was indefinite. The rest of your statement was all about you and I have no reason to comment on that. Now that I'm awake, your first sentence was hypothetical in that it was using indefinite people that could/couldn't be you and could/couldn't be the same person, right? My problem was I read it as being two separate people and it came out like a statement. It's really not a misread but more of I can take it multiple ways since it allows for that. However, that was unfair of me without asking you for your intentions first, I'll apologize for that.

Anyway, now that I had some sleep, I found another thing:
jonathan79 wrote:
taruby wrote:
I can agree with you that you can have as much hope as anyone else can,

I said this.

Where in your first post do you use the words for any form of equality or even 'as much as'. If you can find it, I'll apologize for wasting your time (Something I do for no real reason).
jonathan79 wrote:
Hold on just a minute there, an atheist can have plenty of hope, more hope than a believer can. I have more hope now than I ever did when I was a believer, in fact I had no hope when I was a believer. This statement is wrong in so many ways that I cannot even begin to describe how wrong it is. Also, I am NOT a ret*d. Different, not defective.

Don't forget that you did correct me that you were talking about yourself in every sentence, however I can't find where you said 'as much as' like you did. I'm probably getting on your nerves so if this irritates you, please have some patience with me. =\



emp
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Apr 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,002

08 Jul 2006, 9:21 pm

DataImzadi wrote:
Emp, I have complete certainty that it was God who chose my genes.


If a person went around seriously insisting that pixies and dragons exist, a sensible person would think he is a freakin' loon, and would have little respect for him.

Seriously insisting that a god exists is the SAME SITUATION as that. Pixies, dragons, and gods are just MYTHOLOGY. And while I quite enjoy mythology, to seriously insist that it is actually true is just plain nuts off-your-rocker bat-shit insane.



Barracuda
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 12 Apr 2006
Age: 35
Gender: Male
Posts: 698
Location: Pennsylvania

08 Jul 2006, 9:57 pm

emp wrote:
DataImzadi wrote:
Emp, I have complete certainty that it was God who chose my genes.


If a person went around seriously insisting that pixies and dragons exist, a sensible person would think he is a freakin' loon, and would have little respect for him.

Seriously insisting that a god exists is the SAME SITUATION as that. Pixies, dragons, and gods are just MYTHOLOGY. And while I quite enjoy mythology, to seriously insist that it is actually true is just plain nuts off-your-rocker bat-shit insane.
How do you know they are just Mythology? Have you been to every single point in the universe, at the same time? That's the only way to prove they don't exist. Emp, as much as you hate it, you can't prove there is no God. But I can not prove there is a God beyond faith, so here we are at a standstill.



DataImzadi
Hummingbird
Hummingbird

User avatar

Joined: 22 Jun 2006
Gender: Female
Posts: 19
Location: Western Australia

08 Jul 2006, 10:32 pm

By pitying you, I'm not implying I'm better than you. But I am saying I have something worth having, and you dont have it.

Emp, I may be an aspie (and as proven last night at a party) I have no idea about normal human relations, even I can see that you're acting like a prick.

Hey, I might be insane, but I'm enjoying every freaking minute of it.

:D

Anyway, you think I'm insane, I think you're insane. One of us is right. Who is it? You can't say that you're right, because there is no proof that God does not exist. I have proof he does exist, but you won't recognise that. Seems we are at an impasse. Oh isn't it lovely to be an aspie?


_________________
I'm still not exactly sure why I'm on this planet...


emp
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Apr 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,002

09 Jul 2006, 6:34 pm

Barracuda wrote:
How do you know they are just Mythology?


How do I know that pixies and dragons are just mythology??? I need not explain it. By this point, sensible people have already accepted that you fell off your rocker and hit your head a little too hard. I will not insult their intelligence by explaining it.



emp
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Apr 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,002

09 Jul 2006, 6:52 pm

DataImzadi wrote:
Seems we are at an impasse.


Nonsense. Any reasonable and sensible person can see that your position is ludicrous. It is just simply insane to attribute your Aspergers to a mythological creature (a god). Your belief is so obviously and blatantly ridiculous that it does not deserve any respect.

And if you were to claim that gods are not part of mythology, it is RIGHT THERE IN THE FREAKIN' DICTIONARY!!

Quote:
mythology n. "a body of myths: as a : the myths dealing with the gods, demigods, and legendary heroes of a particular people"
-- Merriam-Webster's dictionary

Quote:
mythology n. "1. a. A body or collection of myths belonging to a people and addressing their origin, history, deities, ancestors, and heroes."
-- American Heritage Dictionary

Quote:
dragon n. "A mythical monster traditionally represented as a gigantic reptile having a lion's claws, the tail of a serpent, wings, and a scaly skin."
-- American Heritage Dictionary



Great gibbering anthropoids, mythological creatures clearly do not cause neurological conditions such as AS!! !



jaguars_fan
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 17 Apr 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 342

09 Jul 2006, 10:14 pm

emp wrote:
DataImzadi wrote:
Emp, I have complete certainty that it was God who chose my genes.


If a person went around seriously insisting that pixies and dragons exist, a sensible person would think he is a freakin' loon, and would have little respect for him.

Seriously insisting that a god exists is the SAME SITUATION as that. Pixies, dragons, and gods are just MYTHOLOGY. And while I quite enjoy mythology, to seriously insist that it is actually true is just plain nuts off-your-rocker bat-shit insane.


So, your calling us nuts because we believe in a higher power? ok gonadless!
Speaking of intellegence, you clearly don't have any whatsoever. Opps I think you better get back to work. I'm sure your boss will not be too pleased that you on a computer instead of taking orders at the drive thru.



Barracuda
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 12 Apr 2006
Age: 35
Gender: Male
Posts: 698
Location: Pennsylvania

10 Jul 2006, 6:25 pm

emp wrote:
Barracuda wrote:
How do you know they are just Mythology?


How do I know that pixies and dragons are just mythology??? I need not explain it. By this point, sensible people have already accepted that you fell off your rocker and hit your head a little too hard. I will not insult their intelligence by explaining it.
No emp, you have to prove that they absolutely, positively aren't real. For all you know they could be living in Alpha Centuri. The point is, you have no proof there is no God or gods, making your point completely untrue and stupid, you damn idiot!

...Not to mention the fact that you didn't read my whole post, or you would have known what I meant.



emp
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Apr 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,002

11 Jul 2006, 10:32 am

DataImzadi wrote:
Absolutely nothing will convince me that there is no God.


Saying such a thing is symptomatic of a psychological malfunction. I think that gods and gnomes are just mythology, BUT if credible evidence of their existence was presented to me, then I would change my opinion. A belief that can never be changed under any circumstances is a psychological disorder.



Captain_Brown
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Jun 2006
Gender: Female
Posts: 699

11 Jul 2006, 1:25 pm

God wanted everyone to be different. So I think this is why.



DataImzadi
Hummingbird
Hummingbird

User avatar

Joined: 22 Jun 2006
Gender: Female
Posts: 19
Location: Western Australia

12 Jul 2006, 1:17 am

Oh well Emp. Add it to the list of the rest of my psychological and neurological defects. I wonder sometimes if I am as defected as people say, why can I still form intelligent thought.

Emp, may I make a supposition? I think you are an Agressive type aspie. It would explain a lot. I know how you feel. No one understands you, or anything about you, and you can't understand anybody else.
I'm Passive and more likely to blame myself for these faults than seeing problems in the world around me as you do.
I guess it's just another one of the interesting quirks that makes us aspies unique from the world around us, AND unique from each other.


_________________
I'm still not exactly sure why I'm on this planet...


Aeturnus
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 30 Mar 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 842

14 Jul 2006, 1:04 am

emp wrote:
DataImzadi: No, the most likely reason for your AS is that it is genetic. No god did this to you, it is just simply a genetic condition. The exact cause is not yet known, but genetic factors is the best explanation so far. Or it may be a combination of physical factors.


I think he's just using God as a metaphor for something that can't be explained. That's all religion is anyway, metaphor. It tries to explain all the things that can't be explained through science, but it gets very convoluted after a while. Like, the bible talks about a person who could walk on water, which is completely ridiculous. And then, religion tries to debunk science as a myth to proclaim its existence as ultimate. If you want to ask the question as to why one will go to church and believe what he reads in the bible, then you need to ask the bigger question: Why do people join cults to begin with?

I have to ask, though, have you ever thought in terms of a binary tree? Well, try it. There was at one time, whether you're willing to believe it or not, two people, or should I say monkeys, which probably evolved from earlier animals, like we all just might have evolved from fish, and that means we can all be traced back to maybe protozoa who split off into two at some time. Whatever that case may be, the fact remains is that there, at one time, was the first person to have mated.

Now forward a few generations. All of a sudden, there was some sort of genetic anomaly. Maybe that could have happened due to environmental factors or birth anoxia or something, but then the brain of the newborn was different. His wiring was different. This person was a bit smarter.

Now, ask yourself? Was there some unknown reason for all this that can't be explained by science? Possibly. It may even be some sort of evolutionary seizure. Evolution progresses, and we just can't explain scientifically why it progresses the way it does, though we can see patterns through studying of fossils and what not. Now, there might be a hidden reason why evolution needed aspies. Maybe that reason has to do with knowledge progression. If that is true, aspies may hold the key to great feats of intelligence. It is thus a shame that many of us are stockboys and mail carriers and crap like that, when we can be creating technical advances that have a far greater impact. It seems that people like Temple Grandin and Albert Einstein are sort of a rarity. Nobody wants us.

- Ray M -