ASD and extreme political beliefs

Post Reply New Topic

In the authoritarian society I aim for, the idea would be to scare most would-be criminals out of committing the offense in the first place (therefore they wouldn't get incarcerated in the first place)

I suppose there are far left authoritarian governments where criminals are scared into behaving too (China)

The problem is that that doesn’t really work and would cause more problems than it would solve.

China is an authoritarian government, ostensibly Communist to the outside world but in fact it's a very capitalistic economy. There's nothing "leftist" about China, and (by definition) there's nothing "leftist" about authoritarianism.

There are historical and modern examples of it working.

China was only one example.

What about the Soviet Union? Wasn't the Soviet Union simultaneously authoritarian and far left?

Has anyone else noticed extreme political beliefs (in either direction) are common in the ASD crowd?

If so, what are your theories on why?

On a different online community, a neurotypical claimed the ASD crowd is more prone to brainwash (and that's her explanation of why a lot of us hold extreme political beliefs). I call BS on her explanation.

Here's what I think the explanation is (for why a lot of us hold extreme political beliefs): We're more likely (compared to the general population) to get victimized (because we come across as easy targets).

Victimization doesn't necessarily mean crime victims either (although it certainly includes crime victims).

Here are the ways in which ASD victimization could lead to extreme political beliefs:

If we get victimized by a criminal, we might develop far right authoritarian beliefs (in other words, create a society where criminals are scared into leaving us alone).

If we get treated poorly by a boss because of our ASD mannerisms, we might develop far left pro-worker beliefs. On a related note, ASD adults are far less likely than neurotypical adults to be financially independent (which could lead to us developing the far left belief that the government should help us, or our jobs should pay better, so we can become free of our parents).

If we get treated poorly for our race, we might develop racist beliefs (Racist beliefs can either be far right or far left, depending on your ethnicity, and depending on which ethnicity/ethnicities you're racist against).

If an ASD woman falls victim to sex abuse (which happens to the female ASD population at a higher rate than the general female population), she might develop far left misandrist beliefs.

If an ASD man has bad luck with the ladies (which happens to the male ASD population at a higher rate than the general male population), he might develop far right misogynistic beliefs.

Lastly, one more factor to explain why the ASD crowd is more likely to hold extreme political beliefs: Even though neurotypicals can get victimized too, ASD makes us hyper-focus on one thing. So if we get victimized, we're more likely to make it our lifelong mission to correct the injustice (whereas a neurotypical is more likely to brush it off and move on if victimized)

Has anyone else noticed extreme political beliefs (in either direction) are common in the ASD crowd?

If so, what are your theories on why?

On a different online community, a neurotypical claimed the ASD crowd is more prone to brainwash (and that's her explanation of why a lot of us hold extreme political beliefs). I call BS on her explanation.

Here's what I think the explanation is (for why a lot of us hold extreme political beliefs): We're more likely (compared to the general population) to get victimized (because we come across as easy targets).

Victimization doesn't necessarily mean crime victims either (although it certainly includes crime victims).

Here are the ways in which ASD victimization could lead to extreme political beliefs:

If we get victimized by a criminal, we might develop far right authoritarian beliefs (in other words, create a society where criminals are scared into leaving us alone).

If we get treated poorly by a boss because of our ASD mannerisms, we might develop far left pro-worker beliefs. On a related note, ASD adults are far less likely than neurotypical adults to be financially independent (which could lead to us developing the far left belief that the government should help us, or our jobs should pay better, so we can become free of our parents).

If we get treated poorly for our race, we might develop racist beliefs (Racist beliefs can either be far right or far left, depending on your ethnicity, and depending on which ethnicity/ethnicities you're racist against).

If an ASD woman falls victim to sex abuse (which happens to the female ASD population at a higher rate than the general female population), she might develop far left misandrist beliefs.

If an ASD man has bad luck with the ladies (which happens to the male ASD population at a higher rate than the general male population), he might develop far right misogynistic beliefs.

Lastly, one more factor to explain why the ASD crowd is more likely to hold extreme political beliefs: Even though neurotypicals can get victimized too, ASD makes us hyper-focus on one thing. So if we get victimized, we're more likely to make it our lifelong mission to correct the injustice (whereas a neurotypical is more likely to brush it off and move on if victimized)

I think a big reason is because a lot of us on the spectrum think in a very black-white way (myself included).I hate to think we are at the point where its extreme to think everyone who works full-time deserves a living wage.

I think you're vastly oversimplifying why people develop the views they develop, as though one negative experience is all it takes to develop an ideological stance.

As a proponent of humanitarianism, I don’t believe the benefits are worth the costs for what you’re suggesting. I believe it would be better to go with something like a Scandinavian model which has proven to be quite successful as per the evidence I cited earlier in the thread.

In retrospect, the only reason I had a bleeding heart stance on criminals in my youth was because (before my mid 20s) I always lived in places with hardly any crime. It's easy to "like" criminals when you don't come into contact with any.

Unfortunately, my post would get removed if I verbalized my rebuttals.

In the authoritarian society I aim for, the idea would be to scare most would-be criminals out of committing the offense in the first place (therefore they wouldn't get incarcerated in the first place)

I highly doubt you can scare criminals out of committing crimes in the first, second or any place. It doesn't work that way.

As a former boss of mine said "In countries where you get your hand cut off for shoplifting, the shoplifting rate is probably pretty low"

Not necessarily one negative experience. But if it happens enough times, it can shape your beliefs.

I used to hold a far left stance on criminals.

Then I moved to a big city in my mid 20s. In a span of less than one year, I ended up in positions where I could have died 4 times.

I now hold a far right stance on criminals (and as I said earlier on the thread, my post would get deleted if I elaborated on what exactly I think certain criminals deserve).

In retrospect, the only reason I had a bleeding heart stance on criminals in my youth was because (before my mid 20s) I always lived in places with hardly any crime. It's easy to "like" criminals when you don't come into contact with any.