Apologies for being late to the party—
My 2¢:
Yes, absolutely horrible what the Soviets did to the women of Berlin. Inexcusable.
But it’s not incomprehensible what anyone can do to other people in wartime. It’s not good, but it happens. When you consider the relentless assault Hitler raged in the east, he set in motion a series of events that left Germany vulnerable.
In contrast to WWII, WWI saw little to no fighting within Germany itself. Germany had previously attempted land grabs before, and little was done about it because most of Europe had already been involved in imperialism. Nobody went against Germany over expansionist policies. Germany invaded a “neutral” country that had long entered into a treaty with England for protection should Germany ever cross into Belgium. When Germany ultimately failed in their objectives and their government was left in ruins, the Germans collectively gave up.
Had you been within a German city at that time, you’d never know they were at war.
By contrast, Hitler not only brought the enemy within the gates of Germany, he fed his own people to the Russian wolves—the idea being that the German people had proven themselves unworthy and unfit as a superior race. What the Russians did is not excusable in the least, and we should never blame the women of Berlin for what happened to them. But I would like to point out that Hitler’s rise to power is directly a result of the people of Germany elevating him to that status. Hitler only had the power the German people granted him. The German people WERE responsible for that, and that means they are responsible themselves for weakening the Reich and leaving themselves vulnerable. THEY have to answer for the Holocaust. THEY left themselves open to reprisals from Russia when Germany lost its ability to protect its people.
Abuse of others is never right. It would be nice if people would just leave each other alone. Women shouldn’t be afraid of walking down dark alleys at night. But we live in a sick world in which that is seen as an open invitation. Is walking alone through a dark alley at night worth the risk of getting hurt or killed just to make a point? So should we genuinely take someone as seriously when they commit genocide and pick fights they cannot possibly win? In WWI, the Germans fought the Russians to a standstill with the Russians only blinking because of political upheaval. Were the odds of a repeat ever in Hitler’s favor? Highly doubtful, and no doubt Russia could have ultimately pulled ahead in WWI if they’d chosen to try. You can go down that dark alley with some muscle and have a fighting chance. So what happened to the women in Berlin, while undoubtedly evil, should come as no surprise to anyone.