NarcissusSavage wrote:
The whole idea of needing to kill his son(or himself?) to even be able to forgive mankind for eating an apple confuses me to no end though.
I could never quite get that either. Although I thought that while the whole row started over an apple, as in any dispute, there was a lot more to forgive by the end of it.
God sacrificed the human part of himself in order to no longer hold a grudge against humans in general.
If I did believe he existed I would have to conclude he disconnected from our world at that point and went off to do something else. I also thoroughly annoyed my teachers in primary school by asking why Judas was held as being bad when he had done God's will and made the ultimate sacrifice himself in order for God to accomplish the sacrifice of Jesus.
I thought that
either he was a traitor and the killing of Jesus was wrong
or he was following God's will and the killing of Jesus was God's will. Can't have it both ways in my opinion.
What I actually think is that his followers were so devastated by the tragic turn of events that they became convinced that a "plan B" for the greater good had been put into action and called it the greatest sacrifice which was made for us, the details don't fit because they were grasping at straws.
But before that conclusion was reached they first condemned Judas as a traitor for causing the death of their leader.
I find one of their conclusions more reasonable than the other.
If it hadn't then been adopted by some pretty ruthless world conquering psychopaths as a way of controlling the population, would it have survived until today?
In the same way, one more recent cult in the US believed they were to be taken to god in a spaceship while the rest of the world perished, on a certain date. Cult members quit their jobs, gave away possessions and waited for the spaceship. When it didn't come they didn't conclude they had been mistaken, they were more convinced than ever and said the strength of their belief had caused the creator to change his mind and saved the world. Therefore they felt a huge sense of achievement instead of the obvious alternative feeling.
Just one of many such "end of the world" occurances.
Is it so different? The followers of Jesus believed the end of the world was imminent both then and now.