Would you rather live in a Communist or a Fascist Empire

Post Reply New Topic

Bertrand Russell called them "Sylla and Charybdis", and I think he was absolutely right. I also agree, with him, that communism is marginally preferable, in that it's at least nominally based on the common good; but I despise both.

I would welcome death. I'd turn myself in as a traitor and allow myself to be executed.

I want to point out that Communist vs. Fascist may not be a fair comparison.

Communism is a formal philosophy of government and has inspired the formation of political parties across the globe. Many people have sought power in the name of Communism, and many millions have proudly self-identified as Communists, in fact during the Cold War roughly 50% of Italians did so (disclaimer I am strongly anti-Communist nevertheless what I just wrote is unarguably true).

In contrast, there has only been one bona fide Fascist party in history i.e. Italy in the first half of the 20th century. Apart from that, "Fascist" is primarily a pejorative term used to characterize politicians and governments by their enemies, especially leftists of all stripes.

In particular, "Fascism" has always been the formal term used by Communists to identify whatever it is they happen to be "struggling" against. For example, the government led by Francisco Franco Bahamonde in Spain (1930s - 1970s) is widely spoken of as Fascist, but that is mostly because it came to power by militarily defeating its Communist (and Soviet-supported) opposition. Likewise the government of Augusto Pinochet Ugarte in Chile (1970s - 1980s) was considered Fascist, as it came to power by overthrowing a Communist leader.

I can recall reading some Cold War propaganda (probably Soviet Life) in which some American citizens and Soviet citizens were stopped on the street and asked questions about Fascism. The Americans mostly expressed ignorance of the topic whereas the Soviets all had deeply insightful and far-reaching things to say about it, implying that people raised in the Soviet Union were way more sophisticated politically than Americans, and that Americans OTOH were easy prey for evil Fascists, due to their ignorance.

I will assume the OP probably meant to say "régime" rather than "empire", in which case I would have to say Fascist, because that could be anything at all, possibly including some extremely brutal oligarchy but could conceivably also include the US (where I happen to live) which has been accused more than once of being Fascist.

Just because nobody, with few exceptions (Mussolini and Oswald Mosley are the first two that spring to mind), has embraced the term "fascist", it doesn't mean that it isn't an organised political philosophy. It is, and Pinochet and Franco were quite clearly adherents of fascism, regardless of the obscurantism of the Bolsheviks in their overuse of the term.

A lot of Americans don't even realize that the Nazis were not communists.

I'd want a quick, (mostly) painless death in any totalitarian regime.

Also I know that other developed countries are just as bad but I was raised under the delusion that Amuuurica was the greatest country because we're so nice to everyone including "evil" countries and we helped the world and everybody loves us and wants to move here blah blah blah.

Yeah, imagine my shock and feelings of shame when I found out about all the bad things that the US continues to do to this day.

According to some murricans, the country I live in *is* commie. But only because we have "free" health care.

America most certainly doesn't have a free healthcare system. It has an ineffective and corrupt healthcare system designed to enrich pharmaceutical companies and private healthcare providers. The only country in the world with an effective and free healthcare system is the UK, though that's being driven down the toilet (purposely) as well.