Sand wrote:
fidelis wrote:
I usually consider a religion a set of beliefs that explain an afterlife. As soon as science does that, I will revise this, but I don't think I will be alive to change this hugely informal definition when it falls apart.
An afterlife is only one component of religion. A more central one is the belief in a supernatural architecture to the universe demanding a god of one form or another that requires some form of obeisance. It doesn't necessarily mean a formal group organization is involved.
I wouldn't think it would require a formal group. I don't think it requires a god either. The supernatural architect is an important one, but I think an afterlife is the most important one. This is of course a matter of opinion, and I have no real way of backing mine. If you have some form of reasoning to back your opinion I would see no need to hold on to mine, seeing as mine is merely an informal tool for quickly distinguishing between religion and something else. It's just a piece of all religions that is found in nothing else. The definition doesn't really serve me any purpose. Using the definition you just gave though, I would still say that satanism isn't my religion, but rather a philosophy I can agree with.
Are my beliefs considered a religion. I believe in an afterlife, but no god. I give no explanation of this afterlife, because I don't know it. I only know it must be there. Is it a religion Sand, or if it isn't, what is it?
_________________
I just realized that I couldn't possibly realize what I just realized.