Belief that life continues after death more beneficial?
Joker
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/684b4/684b4ef4b2ee2b5301dc6cdab4933ce41445cbbc" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 19 Mar 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,593
Location: North Carolina The Tar Heel State :)
Once again some one on WP confuses me gosh I hate it when that happens
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66a22/66a22f7ccac6a249c09e2d83c26465aa37fb0c13" alt="Laughing :lol:"
Because there is little incentive to act virtuously all the time if there isn't a punishment afterwards. Of course, this can be exploited by the powerful, but it helps keep certain behaviours in control. It can be beneficial, on a societal level (keyword: can).
Ah yes, the paradox that Christians (the usual proponents of this argument) are less moral than atheists - some Christians seem to believe the only thing that stops them going on crime sprees and murdering people is the will of God. Atheists are divided from God and therefore have to restrain themselves by their own efforts...
The big issue with these beliefs is that they are so subjective. Do this and you'll be rewarded, do that and you'll be punished. But what are "this" and "that"? Will you be punished with eternal fire for blasphemy, or eating pork, or working on a holy day? Even Christian morality has shifted over time - Jesus was hot on giving up your riches, forgiveness and the destruction of out-of-season fig trees, but the bible happily condones slavery, incest and violence. Are there people in Hell for eating shellfish two thousand years ago while new believers are spared this torment? It's all very baffling.
And that's just looking at Christianity. What if the Buddhists are right and we just come back here?
On the subject of food, I believe the opposite: it was beneficial. Controling what could be eaten or under what condition makes sure that the food won't be toxic or dangerous. Obviously people don't go to hell for eating the wrong type of food at the wrong time, since hell doesn't actually exist, but that fear, false though it is, can be a good substitute for the true one: the food is dangerous, but people are too stupid to recognise it if it isn't spelled out as the will of God.
Evidently, the non-absolute quality of the principles defended by religion make them obsolete at times, like they are today. It may take some time before religions notices is food quality is scrutinised carefully enough that there is no need to make God come into the picture.
The point is, there is no objective benefit to always behaving virtuously, even though that behaviour might need to be encouraged because of its beneficial effects on other people. Saying that this or that is worth ten thousand years of purgatory can be effective. I, for myself, prefer to follow the best possible course from a (or my) consequentialist point of view. That does, however, take a lot of reflexion and a certain amount of self-denial. Some follow rules for the benefit of "the community", for their peers, their family, their colleagues, etc. In the end, even though it can be exploited by who makes the rules, as it often is, fear of punishment in the afterlife is just another such incentive, which has the benefit of being very easy to use for the common people. I don't see it as better or worse than the other, at least as long as people believe in it.
Kjas
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e8008/e8008378aebecc83a5276fb4a02732ba963929a0" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 26 Feb 2012
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 6,059
Location: the place I'm from doesn't exist anymore
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66a22/66a22f7ccac6a249c09e2d83c26465aa37fb0c13" alt="Laughing :lol:"
Me too.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66a22/66a22f7ccac6a249c09e2d83c26465aa37fb0c13" alt="Laughing :lol:"
I can't see how it is beneficial. Why waste what time you have here? The way I live would not change, regardless if the concept of "god" or whatever, turned out to be true or not.
As far as science can tell us now. we already know that energy is never destroyed or created, it just changes forms. Hence where we came from is more or less what we return to.
I highly doubt that in the process of energy changing forms, you somehow retain your consciousness, float up to heaven, only to be greeted next to the big pearly gates by saint peter. That just seems highly improbable to me.
_________________
Diagnostic Tools and Resources for Women with AS: http://www.wrongplanet.net/postt211004.html
I believe in an afterlife, but it's not a strong belief - I could be wrong, who's to say? I also don't think about it that much. I try to focus on my current life and live it well. I figure even if I am a spiritual being living a physical existence, there's got to be some purpose to the physical existence and I should do my best to make the best of it. Living for some future, heavenly existence while I'm here wouldn't make much sense.
If it enhances their life, how could it be foolish?
Pretending taxes don't exist would probably also enhance a person's life, though in reality it is a false sense of security that will lead to consequences. At least with the afterlife, there won't be any let down or consequences; unless one's belief about getting there involves killing
What does believing there's life after death have to do with taxes?
How does believing there isn't life after death lead to a false sense of security?
It is called an analogy. I also did not said anything about *not* believing in afterlife
I get that, and I don't get the connection. Reason being is that you are certain avoiding paying your taxes will get you in the end, and you're most likely right, even if you believe you'll be fine. And you compare it to believing in life after death, but you can't be certain about it. It's just a belief.
Bottom line. Bad analogy.
No, the infamous snapcap lack of comprehension is at play once again
_________________
Opportunities multiply as they are seized. -Sun Tzu
Nature creates few men brave, industry and training makes many -Machiavelli
You can safely assume that you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do
I believe in an afterlife, but it's not a strong belief - I could be wrong, who's to say? I also don't think about it that much. I try to focus on my current life and live it well. I figure even if I am a spiritual being living a physical existence, there's got to be some purpose to the physical existence and I should do my best to make the best of it. Living for some future, heavenly existence while I'm here wouldn't make much sense.
If it enhances their life, how could it be foolish?
Pretending taxes don't exist would probably also enhance a person's life, though in reality it is a false sense of security that will lead to consequences. At least with the afterlife, there won't be any let down or consequences; unless one's belief about getting there involves killing
What does believing there's life after death have to do with taxes?
How does believing there isn't life after death lead to a false sense of security?
It is called an analogy. I also did not said anything about *not* believing in afterlife
I get that, and I don't get the connection. Reason being is that you are certain avoiding paying your taxes will get you in the end, and you're most likely right, even if you believe you'll be fine. And you compare it to believing in life after death, but you can't be certain about it. It's just a belief.
Bottom line. Bad analogy.
Thus Snapcap has spoken.
Thus Joker continues jacking off through postwhore cheerleading
_________________
Opportunities multiply as they are seized. -Sun Tzu
Nature creates few men brave, industry and training makes many -Machiavelli
You can safely assume that you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do
I know people seem to do that, but I tend to assume it's something deeper than that. My own belief in an afterlife has grown out of several things. Reading about near death experiences when I was young, my experience of being with someone when they died, another experience that happened when someone related to me died clear across the country, reading about some fairly well verified cases of mediumship, and so on and so forth. It's an accumulation of things. Still, as I wrote earlier, it's not a strong belief. It's more that the accumulation of reasons makes me think that wow, this is all pointing in a certain direction and that is that there is a part of us that survives physical death.
But again I don't live my life for that. I live my life for what it is now. Certainly my spiritual beliefs, feelings, and questions about death affect how I live my life, but it's not as if I put more importance on what happens after I die than on what happens while I'm alive. I believe in living for today. To me death is a great mystery. Perhaps we have hints, perhaps it's a complete ending. No one knows. I don't fear death as much as I fear some means of death - or leaving something undone that I consider important, such as telling my loved ones that I love them, things like that. As cluttered as my life seems at times, I actually worry about leaving a mess behind for someone else. But I don't fear death. I see it as being like walking through a doorway. Behind that door is either nothing or something....
I highly doubt that in the process of energy changing forms, you somehow retain your consciousness, float up to heaven, only to be greeted next to the big pearly gates by saint peter. That just seems highly improbable to me.
I will tell you why not believing in a life hereafter is useful. If you realize that you only go around once and at best for a limited number of years (if you live to be 100 you will have only 36,525 days), THEN you will learn to use what little time you have as wisely as you know how. Counting the day is a sure cure for procrastination and laziness.
People who think they will be with Jesus forever in heaven are not only kidding themselves, but promoting their own bad character traits.
Eternal Life is Eternal Boredom. It is worse than any Dantean conception of Hell.
ruveyn
Joker
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/684b4/684b4ef4b2ee2b5301dc6cdab4933ce41445cbbc" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 19 Mar 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,593
Location: North Carolina The Tar Heel State :)
I believe in an afterlife, but it's not a strong belief - I could be wrong, who's to say? I also don't think about it that much. I try to focus on my current life and live it well. I figure even if I am a spiritual being living a physical existence, there's got to be some purpose to the physical existence and I should do my best to make the best of it. Living for some future, heavenly existence while I'm here wouldn't make much sense.
If it enhances their life, how could it be foolish?
Pretending taxes don't exist would probably also enhance a person's life, though in reality it is a false sense of security that will lead to consequences. At least with the afterlife, there won't be any let down or consequences; unless one's belief about getting there involves killing
What does believing there's life after death have to do with taxes?
How does believing there isn't life after death lead to a false sense of security?
It is called an analogy. I also did not said anything about *not* believing in afterlife
I get that, and I don't get the connection. Reason being is that you are certain avoiding paying your taxes will get you in the end, and you're most likely right, even if you believe you'll be fine. And you compare it to believing in life after death, but you can't be certain about it. It's just a belief.
Bottom line. Bad analogy.
Thus Snapcap has spoken.
Thus Joker continues jacking off through postwhore cheerleading
Your just mad cause Snapcap owned you lol
I could see it being willful ignorance if there was actual proof to settle the matter, but there isn't, so I can't see how it is.
_________________
*some atheist walks outside and picks up stick*
some atheist to stick: "You're like me!"
No, the infamous snapcap lack of comprehension is at play once again
Yes.
I don't think Vigilans is up to expanding on his point better, maybe someone else could for him?
_________________
*some atheist walks outside and picks up stick*
some atheist to stick: "You're like me!"
For some folk, it could be the opposite. They might not feel like their work is in vain if they just cease to exist. Also, if a group of people were being oppressed, and the group was divided by people that believed and didn't believe in an afterlife, which people would be more likely to fight their oppressors? The people who think this is it and enjoy it while it lasts, or the people that believe that there is a life beyond this, and their physical death here is just one of many. The people that believe in another life might be more spirited to make a move and try to over throw the people that control their lives in an undesirable way.
This is just opinion. Not all Christians are bad.
Eternal Life is Eternal Boredom. It is worse than any Dantean conception of Hell.
ruveyn
How do you know? If life after death is a reality, it's likely that you've been alive before. Are you bored now?
_________________
*some atheist walks outside and picks up stick*
some atheist to stick: "You're like me!"
No, the infamous snapcap lack of comprehension is at play once again
Yes.
I don't think Vigilans is up to expanding on his point better, maybe someone else could for him?
What else can be said about it? It is not hard to understand. One can imagine any situation they want and accept it over reality but it always amounts to self-delusion
I'm not mad at anything, especially not snapcap's misunderstanding of an analogy. I find your posting pointless, semi-literate exercises in dilettantism, cheer-leading like a yappy little dog barking at the heels of its big buddy "YEAH YOU TELL THEM BOSS!! !"
_________________
Opportunities multiply as they are seized. -Sun Tzu
Nature creates few men brave, industry and training makes many -Machiavelli
You can safely assume that you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do
Joker
Veteran
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/684b4/684b4ef4b2ee2b5301dc6cdab4933ce41445cbbc" alt="User avatar"
Joined: 19 Mar 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,593
Location: North Carolina The Tar Heel State :)
No, the infamous snapcap lack of comprehension is at play once again
Yes.
I don't think Vigilans is up to expanding on his point better, maybe someone else could for him?
What else can be said about it? It is not hard to understand. One can imagine any situation they want and accept it over reality but it always amounts to self-delusion
I'm not mad at anything, especially not snapcap's misunderstanding of an analogy. I find your posting pointless, semi-literate exercises in dilettantism, cheer-leading like a yappy little dog barking at the heels of its big buddy "YEAH YOU TELL THEM BOSS!! !"
Yeah your mad don't like it when people gain up on ya ha
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/23259/2325942d5f956e23d0b663fc36737595f5c951a3" alt="Razz :P"
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Five indicted for death of trans man, deceased tortured |
20 Feb 2025, 6:50 pm |
Biden commutes sentences death row inmates |
29 Dec 2024, 11:38 am |
CEO defends 84-hour work-week culture amid death threats |
04 Dec 2024, 12:30 pm |
The Death of "Scientific Creationism"? |
17 Dec 2024, 8:09 pm |