twoshots wrote:
I don't get it.
Really, I know it's difficult to read between the lines here, but I really think that anyone who thinks this is stereotyping whites should take a closer look.
#62 - Knowing What's Best For Poor People wrote:
They feel guilty and sad that poor people shop at Wal*Mart instead of Whole Foods, that they vote Republican instead of Democratic, that they go to Community College/get a job instead of studying art at a University.
Now, consider the stereotype that all republicans are white men. This paragraph reaches new heights of absurdity: vast swaths of the white population are here being actively discounted as being really 'white'. This entry is absolutely absurd. The use of the term 'white' is playing a satirical role; I haven't quite fleshed out my interpretation to the point where it's worth posting, but it definitely is that this is not "stereotyping whites". Note the distinct
lack of redneck jokes for example.
Yes, people who have a firm grasp of the way white people really are and think would know that the claims this site makes are absurd, but such non-white viewers are definitely in the minority.
The site seems meant to be viewed in
either one of two ways: either 1) satire about how whites are wrongfully seen, or 2) deliberate exaggeration of white traits in order to make a more subtle point that whites are dorks with their heads up their butts. If it wanted to be a real satire site, it could say something like, "People think whites are...", and
then give the list. But to claim, just straight out, absurdities about whites is something that can't be known by the reader to be in jest, if it is. Because, as we know,
countless absurd claims about particular groups of people appear all over the web. So, to say, "Well, he is only joking" when there's no evidence of that is just making assumptions. The site is ambiguous as to its aim.
But see,
every white person knows that criticism of minority groups, whether in jest or not, is strictly forbidden, and that they will be called "racist" if they dare to even honestly evaluate a minority group. Oh, but we're all modern and colorblind in our thinking these days, right?

All the people who think everyone's all cool with each other still interestingly keep the lines of conversational segregation sharply drawn, and discourage frank and open discussions of the differences -- toward a result of sustained ignorance. Hypocrisy, or blindness?
_________________
Christianity is different than Judaism only in people's minds -- not in the Bible.