MrMark wrote:
1) the universe works in some sort of orderly manner
2) we can discern what that orderly manner is.
I don't think that Science assumes either of these things. Those are some of the things Science sets out to establish. Both Science and Religion are just ways of understanding what is a very confusing world. Both "assume" some coherence in the world, they have to, to try and explain it. The main difference is, as spacemonkey said, Science is self critical; it makes observations, theories and then tests them etc... Religion is about faith. Both have their uses.
By the way, once again this is not intended as criticism. Also, I am not stalking you to pick flaws in your arguements.