Page 4 of 12 [ 188 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 ... 12  Next

DW_a_mom
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Feb 2008
Gender: Female
Posts: 13,689
Location: Northern California

02 Sep 2008, 2:57 pm

intense wrote:
I see what you're saying but doctors themselves who are aware of the level of suffering have recommended terminations to parents. If I knew for sure that the child was going to suffer nothing but terrible pain and medicine could do little to ease that suffering then I would have to try and put my emotional feelings aside and think of the child.

To say it is out of my hands because I am not knowledgeable enough about it would still make me feel like I am failing in my responsibility to the child. Honestly who here would want to live if it only meant excruciating pain without relief?
This is my personal feelings about the subject and it is a difficult one to come to terms with.


Well, I disagree with those doctors.

However, yes, this sort of situation, where good people can disagree about what is the most ethical and humane thing to do, is exactly why the decision needs to be made by those involved, and not the law.

Your personal feelings are just as valid as mine, and no law should say otherwise.


_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).


Age1600
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Apr 2007
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,028
Location: New Jersey

02 Sep 2008, 3:01 pm

intense wrote:
Age1600 wrote:
intense wrote:
intense wrote:
what if it was discovered early on that the child has a painful degenerative disease and would have a VERY POOR quality of life - everyday would mean extreme suffering how would you feel then?

I only ask as sadly these are the kind of decisions some poor people have to make in real life.
None of the pro life people here have answered my question - I wonder why? It is an uncomfortable one isn't it, but some people are sadly forced to make decisions like the one I mentioned above.

Things aren't black and white there are shades of grey, so I ask again if your baby was going to be born with a degenerative disease which causes terrible pain and suffering for a very extended period after it’s birth would you still decide to continue with the pregnancy or not.

I personally would have to think of the child first and if it was only going to suffer for the short time it was going to live for than I would be forced to at least consider a termination, what right have I to let such suffering continue when I could have prevented it.
No matter what my feelings are about the sanctity of life I would have real trouble with the suffering it would cause to go through with the birth of a child that would experience nothing but pain and utter misery.


I know a family who had a baby found out in the womb that the baby may have this weird disorder that affects the way the baby feels pain, even though, the mother still had the baby, instead found out the baby had a disorder that stops the child from feeling any pain at all! So everybody thinks what a great thing that is, no it isnt, in fact the little girl chewed off her hand, she didnt feel it, poked her eye until she was blind, if she fell and broke her leg nobody would know, the mother had to assume that something was wrong, she wasnt getting any signals that it was hurtin her so it didnt matter to her, now that mother tells ppl everywhere that be lucky you feel pain! Now that mother knew her baby was going to be born with this or soemthing related to this but still gave that baby a chance! You have no idea what people are capable of, how even sometimes children who have the worst diseases, disorders in the world who end up being the best advocate and changing this world. Like the baby born with mermaid syndrome, the mother still had her, yet now shes worldwide known, and they had several operations so she could walk, now shes doing amazing. Doctors told my one friend her baby was going to have spinabifida, that you abort it if u wanted to, well she didnt, guess what, the baby didnt have spinabifida! Doctors dont always know much at all. Also what about the actor who has down syndrome, goes to show you that he didnt let his disability stop him, or the people with down syndrome getting married, what about those? Nobody talks about the amazing people out there who despite their disabilities are changing this world as we know it! Nobody knows for sure what their aborting at all, and nobody knows what that child who was aborted could have been, or where they would end up! There are tons of agencies you can just give that baby up to without even letting them know, tons, i use to help out one, open door pregancy center i think it was called, where they got donations and help so people who dont want children can give up their child without all this paper work or ppl knowing their an unfit mother, and give this child a chance to live life. Don't you think everybody should have the chance to live, jsut because one person says this child will suffer, how the heck do you know how that child is going to handle its life, how do you not know that child will rise above it and prove everybody wrong. Nobody can make that decision, that child should have a right to live, right to make their decisions in life.
well that's a great story but unfortunately it isn't allways the case.


What other cases are you refering too then? what about people who abuse the abortion privaleges and just kill babies left and right because they dont bother to use birth control, and dont want a baby, but love the sex, and since abortion is legal, why not jsut abort every child you get pregnant with, thats what many girls think! While many families are desperate to even have a child, my mother was one of them, she found out she couldnt have children, and lost it, took her years just to be able to adopt, had to go through many different tests to find out if their even qualified, yet some parents just can have them whenever they want and abort them also while some are fighting, desperately to even own a child! My mother flew 3 times to colombia, south america to adopt 3 different children while a lot of women are aborting them left and right, some people are actually fighting doing the impossible, speanding tons of money just to be able to say they have a child, i dont think thats fair at all! Yes you hear how the kid needs to get out of the mother, can kill the mother, but usually the best technique is inducing labor and if that child doesnt make it, thats a different story, but if they did do abortion it can cause more serious complications to the woman then anything.


_________________
Being Normal Is Vastly Overrated :wall:


Aurore
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Dec 2007
Age: 33
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,187
Location: Virginia Tech

02 Sep 2008, 3:08 pm

I think it's an important choice but only should be used in extreme situations.
For example: my mom was pregnant with a little girl but at four months was diagnosed with Stage 3 breast cancer. The chemotherapy would kill the baby slowly and painfully if she underwent it during pregnancy. Due to the aggressive nature of her cancer, they both would have died if she didn't have the baby aborted and started treatment. So through abortion she saved her own life in a situation where the baby would die either way, and gave it a chance to die quickly - it was actually the humane option in the situation.
Also, think of cases of infants with anencephaly, where the child develops without most of their brain and sometimes their entire skull. Their entire existence in the rare occurrence that they do survive is unspeakably horrible.
So sometimes, in such cases, I think it is actually the moral thing to have an abortion.


_________________
?Evil? No. Cursed?! No. COATED IN CHOCOLATE?! Perhaps. At one time. But NO LONGER.?


Last edited by Aurore on 02 Sep 2008, 3:14 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Ryn
Velociraptor
Velociraptor

User avatar

Joined: 9 Apr 2008
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 492

02 Sep 2008, 3:09 pm

I am pro-choice, and I can't imagine taking away the option of abortion from anyone. My Mom had me despite hard circumstances, and while her life is good I think it would have been better if she hadn't given birth to me. Having a child has to be one of the single hardest things, mentally, emotionally, and physically to go through and I feel like it's wrong to force that decision onto someone. There are so many circumstances, like abusive households, mental issues, money circumstances, rape, etc that can make abortion not only the better chocie but the healthiest choice for the mother and that fetus. It's fine and dandy to have adoption centers, but to force the mother into giving birth can still lead her into emotional, mental, and physical harm (not just from the baby, but from possibly abusive family or partners).

I'm sure posters above have said it much better than I have exressed here, but this is why I'm pro-choice in all circumstances.


_________________
"I myself am made entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."--Augusten Burroughs


lionesss
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 21 Aug 2008
Age: 49
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,305
Location: not anywhere near you

02 Sep 2008, 3:12 pm

intense wrote:
philosopherBoi wrote:
I am anti-abortion, if you do the deed then deal with the consequences because killing an innocent unborn child is just plain wrong. Oh and to cover it rape is not an excuse, yes something bad happened but two wrongs have never made a right the child never did anything to hurt you.


Now there are two reasons I could see why an abortion should be done, if a father, brother or other close realative father's the child etc. or if the mother will die and take the child with her.
Ok then what if it was discovered early on that the child has a painful degenerative disease and would have a VERY POOR quality of life - everyday would mean extreme suffering how would you feel then?

I only ask as sadly these are the kind of decisions some poor people have to make in real life.


Like I said before I am pro-choice, but in a case like that I am in favor of abortion. If the child is going to be born with a fatal genetic disease, where the child is going to live a painful and zero quality of life and won't live past 5 years of age or so... why let the child go through that kind of hell? And imagine how it would be for the parents to watch! A lot of these diseases like Tay-Sachs and Sandhoff and Neimann-Pick, can be pre-screened. Parents can find out easily through a blood test if they carry the gene. If both parents find out that they carry the same bad gene, they will be referred to a genetic counselor who will give them options.. so in those cases many times diseases like those are avoided anyway (if the parents were to have a reason to believe they may carry the gene based on ethnicity or what have you) But when it comes to diseases like trisomy 18 or 13, the child will likely end up dying a few days after birth terribly deformed anyway. Why let the child suffer at all, and why allow yourself to go through the agony of watching your newborn child die shortly after birth. All of that can be detected before birth and if I found out that my child was going to die right after being born, I know what I would have to do.


_________________
Come chat about the mystical side and everyday part of life on http://esotericden.proboards.com -The Esoteric Den!! !


lionesss
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 21 Aug 2008
Age: 49
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,305
Location: not anywhere near you

02 Sep 2008, 3:16 pm

And I am not talking about cases like Down's Syndrome. People that have Down's Syndrome have a good chance at living a good quality of life. There are a lot of people that have Down's that do live good independent lives and some also get married. I am in favor of abortion if the child is born to basically die sometime in early childhood or earlier.


_________________
Come chat about the mystical side and everyday part of life on http://esotericden.proboards.com -The Esoteric Den!! !


ADoyle
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 16 Dec 2005
Age: 49
Gender: Female
Posts: 913
Location: Southern California, USA

02 Sep 2008, 3:17 pm

I'm pro-choice because I think it should be up to the woman to decide. I think that birth control should be more widely available as that's a way to prevent many abortions.


_________________
"I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason,
and intellect has intended us to forgo their use."
- Galileo Galilei


pandd
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Jul 2006
Age: 51
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,430

02 Sep 2008, 3:23 pm

I am not anti-choice.

In an abortion the only rights bearing entity is parental.

People have the right to make their own choices about the medical interventions that they receive, and this is a right that should only be interfered with (by the state) where it can be demonstrated that the state's duty to protect some right bearing entity or group (consisting of such entities), or uphold some right bearing entity or (right bearing) group's rights, necessitates such intervention.

In the case of abortion, the procedure is of low-risk (relative to generally available forms of elective surgery); I do not see how the state can demonstrate an interest by recourse to any duty to protect any right bearing entity or any group consisting of such (entities), or to uphold the rights of any such entities or groups.



anna-banana
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 30 Aug 2008
Age: 41
Gender: Female
Posts: 5,682
Location: Europe

02 Sep 2008, 3:27 pm

pandd wrote:
I am not anti-choice.

In an abortion the only rights bearing entity is parental.

People have the right to make their own choices about the medical interventions that they receive, and this is a right that should only be interfered with (by the state) where it can be demonstrated that the state's duty to protect some right bearing entity or group (consisting of such entities), or uphold some right bearing entity or (right bearing) group's rights, necessitates such intervention.

In the case of abortion, the procedure is of low-risk (relative to generally available forms of elective surgery); I do not see how the state can demonstrate an interest by recourse to any duty to protect any right bearing entity or any group consisting of such (entities), or to uphold the rights of any such entities or groups.


LOL you sound like such a lawer ;p



cybershooter
Tufted Titmouse
Tufted Titmouse

User avatar

Joined: 2 May 2008
Age: 52
Gender: Male
Posts: 42
Location: London, UK

02 Sep 2008, 3:32 pm

Age1600 wrote:
Yes you hear how the kid needs to get out of the mother, can kill the mother, but usually the best technique is inducing labor and if that child doesnt make it, thats a different story, but if they did do abortion it can cause more serious complications to the woman then anything.


Age1600, what is the source of your medical knowledge? How do you know an abortion "can cause more serious complications to the woman then [sic] anything"?



Age1600
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Apr 2007
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,028
Location: New Jersey

02 Sep 2008, 3:51 pm

cybershooter wrote:
Age1600 wrote:
Yes you hear how the kid needs to get out of the mother, can kill the mother, but usually the best technique is inducing labor and if that child doesnt make it, thats a different story, but if they did do abortion it can cause more serious complications to the woman then anything.


Age1600, what is the source of your medical knowledge? How do you know an abortion "can cause more serious complications to the woman then [sic] anything"?


I had to do many many many studies on abortions in school, the only thing i actually was knowledgable, i took a course in college surprisingly and they wanted me to do follow up studies, had to do a rebudle um i think i mispelled that haha. Went to planned parenthood, opendoor pregnancy, hospitals, doctors who perform abortions, doctors who are against abortions themselves. Talked to many families at childrens specialized hospital, open door preganncy center and planned parenthood center who told their experiences and their thoughts. Before any of that i was against due to my own circumstances, ill find those reports i had to get done, and show u pictures of babies being aborted, or pictures of the actual procedure being done, or even pictures of how the drug RU568 i think thats the name of it, and how it affects the woman, the sideaffects that most ppl dont tell u. I also actually held the metal thing to use to go up inside the woman to crush the babies skull, and what it looked like and how they did it, its absolutely Disgusting! I met babies who were born way to early, who like a poster previous said how the mother had cancer and needed to get the baby out, met a baby who was induced to a similiar incident, the baby and mother survived, the baby was so premature, has cerebral paulsi, and severely undeveloped lungs, but is the cutest baby. So yes a lot of my knowledge on abortions is actually very real, seen, studied, knowledge.


_________________
Being Normal Is Vastly Overrated :wall:


Ryn
Velociraptor
Velociraptor

User avatar

Joined: 9 Apr 2008
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 492

02 Sep 2008, 4:08 pm

Age1600 wrote:
what about people who abuse the abortion privaleges and just kill babies left and right because they dont bother to use birth control, and dont want a baby, but love the sex, and since abortion is legal, why not jsut abort every child you get pregnant with, thats what many girls think!.


Do you really think that "many girls" would prefer to use abortion over birth control? I don't know who're your talking to, but to the typical woman that would be insanely expensive as well as much more traumatic due to it being surgical. You can get generic birth control at Target for like, what, five bucks a month? An abortion costs up into the hundreds of dollars. And often, due to our sh***y education system who is supposedly pro-life, a lot of young women have no real knowledge of birth control or how to get a hold of it. I had no idea what Planned Parenthood was until I was sixteen! I had no idea about cheap birth control, or that I could talk to my doctor about issues like that as early as thirteen without my parents being informed. I've talked with a lot of people about this and they've given me the same crock story about how many girls use it willy nilly, but yet the girls who I have met who discussed their abortions with me don't use it willy nilly. It was often only once or twice.


_________________
"I myself am made entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."--Augusten Burroughs


cybershooter
Tufted Titmouse
Tufted Titmouse

User avatar

Joined: 2 May 2008
Age: 52
Gender: Male
Posts: 42
Location: London, UK

02 Sep 2008, 4:16 pm

Age1600 wrote:
cybershooter wrote:
Age1600 wrote:
Yes you hear how the kid needs to get out of the mother, can kill the mother, but usually the best technique is inducing labor and if that child doesnt make it, thats a different story, but if they did do abortion it can cause more serious complications to the woman then anything.


Age1600, what is the source of your medical knowledge? How do you know an abortion "can cause more serious complications to the woman then [sic] anything"?


I had to do many many many studies on abortions in school, the only thing i actually was knowledgable, i took a course in college surprisingly and they wanted me to do follow up studies, had to do a rebudle um i think i mispelled that haha. Went to planned parenthood, opendoor pregnancy, hospitals, doctors who perform abortions, doctors who are against abortions themselves. Talked to many families at childrens specialized hospital, open door preganncy center and planned parenthood center who told their experiences and their thoughts. Before any of that i was against due to my own circumstances, ill find those reports i had to get done, and show u pictures of babies being aborted, or pictures of the actual procedure being done, or even pictures of how the drug RU568 i think thats the name of it, and how it affects the woman, the sideaffects that most ppl dont tell u. I also actually held the metal thing to use to go up inside the woman to crush the babies skull, and what it looked like and how they did it, its absolutely Disgusting! I met babies who were born way to early, who like a poster previous said how the mother had cancer and needed to get the baby out, met a baby who was induced to a similiar incident, the baby and mother survived, the baby was so premature, has cerebral paulsi, and severely undeveloped lungs, but is the cutest baby. So yes a lot of my knowledge on abortions is actually very real, seen, studied, knowledge.


Forgive me for being so direct, but what you say sounds more touchy-feely rather than real medical knowledge of the subject. I too have seen pictures and films of the abortion process, have studied preserved aborted foetuses, am familiar with the drug RU486 mifepristone and it's side effects (actually most drugs have side effects that people don't talk about), have seen the equipment used in performing an abortion and didn't have any particular feelings about it (but then I've had some medical training). I think you're understandably biased in being anti-abortion, given your family background. It's important to remember that while there might be other people out there in similar circumstances who deserve your sympathy, there will be others in different circumstances, whom you'll need to empathize with and allow to make their own decisions as they see best for their particular set of circumstances.

A pro-choice stance empowers individuals and family units to make the decision for themselves depending on their own unique set of circumstances. The choice can be to keep a baby diagnosed with Down's syndrome, or to abort it, depending on their beliefs and the resources available to them. Once the decision is made, the best that the rest of us can do is to support the choice of the parent(s).



The_Cucumber
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 4 May 2007
Gender: Male
Posts: 514

02 Sep 2008, 4:17 pm

I am against abortion unless it is medically necessary to save the life of the mother. If a mother doesn't feel ready or capable to raise a child then adoption agencies exist specifically for that purpose. Heck, in my state the laws allow any mother to leave a baby at any government building, no questions asked. I'm on the fence about allowing abortions in cases where the child has zero chances of living past early childhood and will be in extreme pain otherwise. However I feel that if this is permitted doctor assisted suicide should also be allowed in adults who have nothing left to live but a slow and painful death.

To me it's not a moral issue it is simply extending legal rights to the unborn.


_________________
The improbable goal: Fear nothing, hate nothing, and let nothing anger you.


Age1600
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Apr 2007
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,028
Location: New Jersey

02 Sep 2008, 4:18 pm

Heres a little cartoon pic of my opinion on abortions
Image




Yes crazy i know, I have more pix i gotta find them though, i think they may be on my old computer. Anyways i did so much research into abortions that it can scare ya, and found out some scary stuff thatll make anybody change their minds, so yes im very knowledgable in this subject and its funny because most subjects im as knowledgable as a 5year old, go figure lool.



Edited because of how disgusting it really was, im sorry if i made anybody upset by these pictures


_________________
Being Normal Is Vastly Overrated :wall:


Last edited by Age1600 on 02 Sep 2008, 5:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Age1600
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Apr 2007
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,028
Location: New Jersey

02 Sep 2008, 4:21 pm

cybershooter wrote:
Age1600 wrote:
cybershooter wrote:
Age1600 wrote:
Yes you hear how the kid needs to get out of the mother, can kill the mother, but usually the best technique is inducing labor and if that child doesnt make it, thats a different story, but if they did do abortion it can cause more serious complications to the woman then anything.


Age1600, what is the source of your medical knowledge? How do you know an abortion "can cause more serious complications to the woman then [sic] anything"?


I had to do many many many studies on abortions in school, the only thing i actually was knowledgable, i took a course in college surprisingly and they wanted me to do follow up studies, had to do a rebudle um i think i mispelled that haha. Went to planned parenthood, opendoor pregnancy, hospitals, doctors who perform abortions, doctors who are against abortions themselves. Talked to many families at childrens specialized hospital, open door preganncy center and planned parenthood center who told their experiences and their thoughts. Before any of that i was against due to my own circumstances, ill find those reports i had to get done, and show u pictures of babies being aborted, or pictures of the actual procedure being done, or even pictures of how the drug RU568 i think thats the name of it, and how it affects the woman, the sideaffects that most ppl dont tell u. I also actually held the metal thing to use to go up inside the woman to crush the babies skull, and what it looked like and how they did it, its absolutely Disgusting! I met babies who were born way to early, who like a poster previous said how the mother had cancer and needed to get the baby out, met a baby who was induced to a similiar incident, the baby and mother survived, the baby was so premature, has cerebral paulsi, and severely undeveloped lungs, but is the cutest baby. So yes a lot of my knowledge on abortions is actually very real, seen, studied, knowledge.


Forgive me for being so direct, but what you say sounds more touchy-feely rather than real medical knowledge of the subject. I too have seen pictures and films of the abortion process, have studied preserved aborted foetuses, am familiar with the drug RU486 mifepristone and it's side effects (actually most drugs have side effects that people don't talk about), have seen the equipment used in performing an abortion and didn't have any particular feelings about it (but then I've had some medical training). I think you're understandably biased in being anti-abortion, given your family background. It's important to remember that while there might be other people out there in similar circumstances who deserve your sympathy, there will be others in different circumstances, whom you'll need to empathize with and allow to make their own decisions as they see best for their particular set of circumstances.

A pro-choice stance empowers individuals and family units to make the decision for themselves depending on their own unique set of circumstances. The choice can be to keep a baby diagnosed with Down's syndrome, or to abort it, depending on their beliefs and the resources available to them. Once the decision is made, the best that the rest of us can do is to support the choice of the parent(s).


Actually i dont have feelings until i actually saw babies who were aborted in real life, thats when the feeling actually hit me for the first time, and u know what it was the worst thing i ever saw. And yes i held the actual little device they use and saw how its demonstrated, and then was told how serious it can be. Also most circumstances can be taken care of by inducing labor instead of abortions, and its not just my personal experience or opinion, its what ive seen from families, places, and doctors that makes me choose to be against abortion. Medical stuff, i can go on alll day about, know all the history on abortions, know the causes, the pain, and everything. My iq may not be high but when it comes to this stuff, i know what im saying!


_________________
Being Normal Is Vastly Overrated :wall: