The tea party protests, your opinion please...
richardbenson
Xfractor Card #351
Joined: 30 Oct 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 13,553
Location: Leave only a footprint behind
People are misunderstanding the political spectrum in this thread. Instead of seeing politics as a line, it is more effective to see it as a 3-D cube.
The three axis are :
Social conservative - Social liberal
Economic conservative - Economic liberal
Statist - Libertarian
It is this simplistic view of politics that leads so many to misunderstand the core of the Tea Party Protests. Of course there is the ignorant, nasty element that is highlighted in news media, but that is an intellectually dishonest representation.
What, you expect intellectual honesty from the media? As if there's a market for that...
_________________
Your boos mean nothing, I've seen what makes you cheer.
- Rick Sanchez
techstepgenr8tion
Veteran
Joined: 6 Feb 2005
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 24,523
Location: 28th Path of Tzaddi
Well... my parents...my aunts...my uncles...pretty much all went. I was stuck out of town at work but - I did get to make a hat out of tinfoil .
Seriously though, I'm very happy about it. What its all about is exactly this - these are people (I'm one of them) who believes that the constitution held a depth of wisdom that we're pulling ourselves away from, we've been disengaging ourselves from an understanding of history, and sadly we're getting close to repeating it in some far less than useful or helpful ways.
The tea party protestors are for: keeping government small, keeping it limited, keeping deficits minimal or paying them off, they're people who are thirsty for liberty - ie. equality of opportunity preferably over equality of outcome. A country's acceptionalism and prosperity come from its rights to life, liberty, and land - they're three of the most powerful motivational and productive forces in the sphere of human influence.
Yeah....but....uhhuhuhuh....these slapnuts voted for George W Bush who saddled us in two huge wars and started this whole spending spree so...uhhuhuh....they're just a bunch of ret*d koolaid-drinking Limbaugh nuts anyway.......
Glenn Beck actually said something pretty funny...as in he said something....waited a second and finished it up "We're here quite frankly because......Democrats suck...........and Republicans suck". I think everyone acknowledges that the Republican party is just as much of a big government party and sold out the real conservatives further down the tracks. I think, while the tea party protesters are in fact protesting the actions of Turbotax Tim, Hank, Barry, Nancy, and Harry, they're also really trying to make their voices heard so that the only party they really feel they have any recourse to have listen to them and accept them back in - the Republican Party - knows what its alienating. They *want to reform the party* to go back to having a much stronger component in conserative economics. Also, the more of Rush I hear - people really can't slate him for....well.....anymore than visually looking like a socialist's characture of 'the evil capitalist' - everything I heard out of his mouth at CPAC I completely agreed with.
That's just it though - no one expects conservatives not to take jabs at the current administration - its been going around the last 8 years. On the other hand, its really even more an act of them trying to smack the senate and house Republicans, tell them to wake up, and even more so - they're speaking to all the independents out there, hoping to make it a party even more I think that would embrace libertarians more than it does now; as in have the economic and good-of-country issues dominate over many of the specific religious issues.
That said though - people may think its useless but, its like anything else - it seems that way for a bit but, it makes a ripple in the public discourse and consciousness, the very fact that it did make the news has people talking and thinking about the issues they addressed. That's the best that they could hope for and I think its exactly what they wanted.
techstepgenr8tion
Veteran
Joined: 6 Feb 2005
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 24,523
Location: 28th Path of Tzaddi
What, you expect intellectual honesty from the media? As if there's a market for that...
Nah, the government should tax Fox News at a higher percentage to help carry them .
Seriously though, I'm very happy about it. What its all about is exactly this - these are people (I'm one of them) who believes that the constitution held a depth of wisdom that we're pulling ourselves away from, we've been disengaging ourselves from an understanding of history, and sadly we're getting close to repeating it in some far less than useful or helpful ways.
The tea party protestors are for: keeping government small, keeping it limited, keeping deficits minimal or paying them off, they're people who are thirsty for liberty - ie. equality of opportunity preferably over equality of outcome. A country's acceptionalism and prosperity come from its rights to life, liberty, and land - they're three of the most powerful motivational and productive forces in the sphere of human influence.
Yeah....but....uhhuhuhuh....these slapnuts voted for George W Bush who saddled us in two huge wars and started this whole spending spree so...uhhuhuh....they're just a bunch of ret*d koolaid-drinking Limbaugh nuts anyway.......
Glenn Beck actually said something pretty funny...as in he said something....waited a second and finished it up "We're here quite frankly because......Democrats suck...........and Republicans suck". I think everyone acknowledges that the Republican party is just as much of a big government party and sold out the real conservatives further down the tracks. I think, while the tea party protesters are in fact protesting the actions of Turbotax Tim, Hank, Barry, Nancy, and Harry, they're also really trying to make their voices heard so that the only party they really feel they have any recourse to have listen to them and accept them back in - the Republican Party - knows what its alienating. They *want to reform the party* to go back to having a much stronger component in conserative economics. Also, the more of Rush I hear - people really can't slate him for....well.....anymore than visually looking like a socialist's characture of 'the evil capitalist' - everything I heard out of his mouth at CPAC I completely agreed with.
That's just it though - no one expects conservatives not to take jabs at the current administration - its been going around the last 8 years. On the other hand, its really even more an act of them trying to smack the senate and house Republicans, tell them to wake up, and even more so - they're speaking to all the independents out there, hoping to make it a party even more I think that would embrace libertarians more than it does now; as in have the economic and good-of-country issues dominate over many of the specific religious issues.
That said though - people may think its useless but, its like anything else - it seems that way for a bit but, it makes a ripple in the public discourse and consciousness, the very fact that it did make the news has people talking and thinking about the issues they addressed. That's the best that they could hope for and I think its exactly what they wanted.
my thing is this, under THIS admistration, they are recieving massive tax breaks and stimulus money, yet they protest. 8 YEARS AGO they were taxed at a higher rate yet they never protested, what is the difference between now and then? Easy, its minority liberal in the white house that has them riled up. Obama hasn't even been in office 100 days yet! Signs seen at tea party protest
sign #1
sign #2
thank god they aren't using kids as props like the those liberals, OH WAIT A MOMENT!
sign #3
and this lovely number sign #4
and now, before you libertains throw a b***h fit, I add the disclaimer that these aren't representing the entire protest and blah blah blah.
_________________
I am a freak, want to hold my leash?
techstepgenr8tion
Veteran
Joined: 6 Feb 2005
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 24,523
Location: 28th Path of Tzaddi
That math leading to race leaves a lot of salient factors out. We're taking on a 10 trillion dollar budget and passing it on to our kids. The stimulus is coming out of our pockets, its not free money as there is no such thing.
Also for someone to delegate this as a racist country or that conservatives who would hold rallies of this like are, in reality, first and formost doing it to endulge a closet racism - you have to conclude that they see none of the criticisms made by these people as valid. Sadly the criticisms being leveled are very traditional, not racial opression traditional, I mean in the sense of economic structure - the shape of the country that these people want to live in.
As far as the tax cuts to the middle class though, you may remember that after 9/11 and some of the financial meltdowns that preceded Sarbanes Oxley, Bush did enact a big tax cut - one that's actually scheduled to expire soon; don't know if Obama will pick that up, I'd like to think so, and I in fact would be in favor of any tax cuts he makes.
The big problems are this right now:
1). Huge spending
2). Little or no transparency, for all the talk of the need for it and the campaign promises of putting a bill on the internet five days before it was to be voted on - the spending of a trillion dollars was 'too urgent'.
3). You have Turbo-Tim telling the banks that they can't give the money back to the government, they locked in to be controlled, decided they don't want or need it - also not good.
4). On the education note - school vouchers in DC - killed by congress in favor of unions.
That may not fall squarely on Obama, in fact all of the above points fall on the left that's taken over the democratic party. As president he either ratifies or vetos ideas, as a liberal he moves with the party on a great deal of issues and, in the world's most powerful position he's taking some heat - as a country we'd do the same for a white guy any day of the week.
There are domestic and foreign policy issues that are irritating conservatives as well. If I got off of the monetary and talked about the closing of Guantanamo without a backup plan, the possible caving in to political pressures from Moveon.org to endite some of the Bush whitehouse with war crimes or at least investigate for trial - I know that it can't be discussed here because I also know that some people would think all of those things are great; that's a rift that really nothing can be said on, people either believe one way or another, just that if Obama should feel the need to take decisive action in a crisis - really hope he's not up for endictment after his term is up.
To sum it up though its ideology. If a group of people have principles on where they believe the country should go (which I believe both sides do) and they see those principles being enfracted on - they'll react. It doesn't take race, gender, or any of that.
That math leading to race leaves a lot of salient factors out. We're taking on a 10 trillion dollar budget and passing it on to our kids. The stimulus is coming out of our pockets, its not free money as there is no such thing.
Also for someone to delegate this as a racist country or that conservatives who would hold rallies of this like are, in reality, first and formost doing it to endulge a closet racism - you have to conclude that they see none of the criticisms made by these people as valid. Sadly the criticisms being leveled are very traditional, not racial opression traditional, I mean in the sense of economic structure - the shape of the country that these people want to live in.
As far as the tax cuts to the middle class though, you may remember that after 9/11 and some of the financial meltdowns that preceded Sarbanes Oxley, Bush did enact a big tax cut - one that's actually scheduled to expire soon; don't know if Obama will pick that up, I'd like to think so, and I in fact would be in favor of any tax cuts he makes.
The big problems are this right now:
1). Huge spending
2). Little or no transparency, for all the talk of the need for it and the campaign promises of putting a bill on the internet five days before it was to be voted on - the spending of a trillion dollars was 'too urgent'.
3). You have Turbo-Tim telling the banks that they can't give the money back to the government, they locked in to be controlled, decided they don't want or need it - also not good.
4). On the education note - school vouchers in DC - killed by congress in favor of unions.
That may not fall squarely on Obama, in fact all of the above points fall on the left that's taken over the democratic party. As president he either ratifies or vetos ideas, as a liberal he moves with the party on a great deal of issues and, in the world's most powerful position he's taking some heat - as a country we'd do the same for a white guy any day of the week.
There are domestic and foreign policy issues that are irritating conservatives as well. If I got off of the monetary and talked about the closing of Guantanamo without a backup plan, the possible caving in to political pressures from Moveon.org to endite some of the Bush whitehouse with war crimes or at least investigate for trial - I know that it can't be discussed here because I also know that some people would think all of those things are great; that's a rift that really nothing can be said on, people either believe one way or another, just that if Obama should feel the need to take decisive action in a crisis - really hope he's not up for endictment after his term is up.
To sum it up though its ideology. If a group of people have principles on where they believe the country should go (which I believe both sides do) and they see those principles being enfracted on - they'll react. It doesn't take race, gender, or any of that.
and now, before you libertains throw a b***h fit, I add the disclaimer that these aren't representing the entire protest and blah blah bla<------ That is why I put a disclaimer in my post for this reason! Also, Obama hasn't been in office for even 100 days yet, so mind cutting him some slack as he tries to sort out the clust f**k of the last 8 years plus an economic meltdown? Kthnxbi!
_________________
I am a freak, want to hold my leash?
I agree, it took people 2 years to critique Bush yet apperently only 30 days to critique Obama.
_________________
I am a freak, want to hold my leash?
techstepgenr8tion
Veteran
Joined: 6 Feb 2005
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 24,523
Location: 28th Path of Tzaddi
This is where I'd have to let it go. If you do believe that the last 8 years were a clusterf*** so to speak and you can't empathize with what the reasons are why all of this is going on - there really isn't much more to be said.
I have to ask though, my response earlier was based on the first paragraph - where you mentioned that because you think they had higher taxes then than they do now; that the only reason you could think of that they would be out there is because he's a minority (you couldn't have meant liberal minority by the party being minority - they have both houses). So, your free to clarify that you didn't mean that the's people are out there waving signs more than anything because their racist, I'll accept that, just pay attention to what your words are adding up to.
You don't want to have to stand in line for groceries?? The government will put money in your account every month - you don't even have to go down to the bank to deposit your check. But you do have to stand in line when you pay for your groceries - just like the rest of us wage earners.
Many of the people who grew up in this environment believed that all goods and services should be provided by the central government.
EDIT: Not allowed to post URLs despite meeting the qualifications (5 or more posts, more than 5 days) stated. So... until that is resolved, lame hackery:
www DOT pbs DOT org/newshour/extra/features/july-dec01/russia_coup DOT html
Just a quick google on "food lines" and "Soviet Union." I'm sure there's quite a bit more out there, but my primary sources were grade school textbooks from 15-20+ years ago, so I'm not entirely sure what all is available online. I haven't bothered to read up on the subject since high school.
I really must admit I'm baffled by your unfamiliarity and interpretation of her lines.
EDIT: Ok, apparently I'm not allowed to post URLs despite having at least 5 legitimate posts and having been here (albeit mostly lurking) for far more than five days.
_________________
I expected the Spanish Inquisition, but I got mustard instead. Stupid Burger King.
(Plus Biden reminds me of an unholy fusion of Dick Cheney and Dan Quayle.)
_________________
I expected the Spanish Inquisition, but I got mustard instead. Stupid Burger King.
The debt was also a big deal in the clinton years. For some reason the debt is only taken seriously when democrats are in office, despite the massive spending of the republican predecessor.
I agree that the debt and deficit are extremely important, I just wish it's something that would get attention all of the time and not just be used as a political weapon to try and thwart democratic administrations. It's so crassly handled that it inevitably leads to another right-left fight.
The debt is to republican politics what the homeless are to democrats. A handy knife.
In my view, compared to the travesty the last president waged on our economy, the current one is doing very well despite not even being in office for 100 days. As for the protesters, I would like to say that they are coming off none to well. I will not debate whether they are in the right or the wrong (Because no matter what is said, Vibrate and Dox are "right" ) however, I would like to point out that there the claim of not being represented is false. compared to 1770, we are extremely well represented (Note I said compared to, not actually) and the abuses suffered under the british tyrannical rule are 100x worse then anything the current president has done so far, actaully the opposite, he has closed down the sites were torture took place.
_________________
I am a freak, want to hold my leash?
Its too bad that even with all the protest Sponge-Barack Obama-Pants isn't even listening. Even those other stooges in the system seem to only care about themselves.
_________________
How to Know God Personally through Jesus Christ
http://www.ccci.org/
Does God Exist? Here is proof he does.
http://www.everystudent.com/features/is ... 2godMANp2w