adult sentences for minors

Post Reply New Topic

Do you think minors should be tried as adults for crimes they've committed?

There is a reason why we have age of consent laws. There is a reason why one has to be a certain age to drive a car, buy alcohol, vote, join the military, sign a binding legal contract or live completely on their own with no parent or guardian. This is the same reason why minors should not be tried and sentenced as adults. If a person is not old enough to consent for sex with an adult, drive a car, buy alcohol, vote, join the military, sign a binding legal contract or live completely on their own with no adult guidance - then they are certainly not old enough to be held equally accountable as an adult either.

the humane thing would be to recognize that people's brains develop at different rates and that it is fundamentally unjust to punish a child brain the same as an adult brain.

Society's treatment of youth is despicable enough. Only if you are a child can you be physically beaten for having an opinion. Only if you are a child can you be held against your will and forced to sit in one position for several hours a day, having to ask permission to pass urine. Only if you are a child can someone grab you by the arm and haul you around roughly for having the nerve to not obey them without question. Only if you are a child are you expected to hold your peace when someone who has authority over you, which is apparently everybody, is clearly in the wrong. Only if you are a "child," to include 17 year old youth, can your boyfriend be sent to prison on felony charges if he happens to be in the wrong age-group, regardless of whether or not he has been the only human being in your life who has ever actually treated you like a person. You have fewer rights than a dog, and you are treated more poorly.

If children cannot have adults sent to jail for misdemeanor assault and battery for grabbing them roughly and cannot have them jailed for taking their property, then sentencing them as adults does not make sense. We already treat them like garbage, and this would be doubling down on it. It would be treating them as accountable in a society in which they do not have the attendant rights. It would be salt and vinegar on the wounds.

If you are a kid, then having respect for the law is a failing of character. You do not owe respect to an entity that treats you with no respect or dignity at all, and I cannot believe that a kid who bows to such treatment could possibly have a moral spine. Not only should kids NOT be sentenced as adults for committing crimes, but for certain types of crime that are injurious only to property rather than the person, they should be given accolades. Oppression warrants rebellion, and rebellion under oppression demonstrates the presence of a moral compass.

the one whose last name used to start with a V seems to be quite a piece of work.

What ever happened to Thompson? I read the whole article, but it didn't mention anything about Thompson after release. And he was the one diagnosed as a psychopath, right?

I think it was V who was the 'path.

death [relatively speaking] is the easy way out. the hard way is supermax for the duration of one's natural life.

ted k. seems to be one of the few inmates therein who is handling it ok. everybody else they have to keep drugged up as they start self-mutilating themselves after a while.

Its depends on the individual and the crime that was done, how much of a threat they are to society. I have problems with incarceration in general so that would naturally extend to minors as well. Minors are certainly capable of murder, rape, and violent assault so I don't feel comfortable saying that no minors should be sentences as adults.