Is god sentient?

Post Reply New Topic

According to science, we are sentient because being aware of ourselves and our environment helped our ancestors to survive and reproduce; we evolved from non-sentient life forms over a period of billions of years. I do not think that god is an animal like us, so in my opinion it is incorrect to assume that god shares any of our characteristics. We humans seem to anthropomorphize god a lot, just as we often anthromorphize inanimate objects, plants, and other animals. In my view, god is whatever gives the universe its structure. For example, gravity creates planets. That is an aspect of god. I do not know what other aspects god may have. Maybe god is sentient in a way that we are not. But how could that have arisen, and from what? What ideas could be in the mind of god?

Looking at that, https://www.etymonline.com/word/sentience, I'd answer yes;

Difficult to say and depends on how one defines God.

If one defines God as an omniscient being, then I could see a few lines of reasoning:

1. God is all-knowing and therefore all-sensing and all-aware. Sentience as we experience it is an imperfect approximation of the sentience of an omniscient God from whom our own sentience is given.

2. God is all-knowing and therefore has no need for sentience, sensation, awareness, etc. God does not need sense or awareness because he already innately knows all there is to know. Sentience is a means by which we attempt to grasp an intricate and vast creation of which we have no omniscient knowledge.

3. God is omnipresent in all energy and matter and experiences sentience inasmuch as his creations experience the sentience he himself created. Additionally (if you want), God experiences the "sentience" of inanimate objects by the physical forces which act upon them--regardless of the fact that those objects lack biological or artificial intelligence to be sentient themselves. God's omniscience comes from (or is reflected in) the experience of the sum of his creation outside the illusion of linear time.

4. God transcends sentience. Sentience is merely a result of mundane chemistry and physics. Sentience is an inadequate or inappropriate concept to apply to an omniscient God that transcends the material world of sense and thought.

5. God is omniscient, but still has or can assume some kind of "form" or manifestation (metaphysical or physical) through which he does or can experience sentience in roughly the same way we do.

6. God does not experience sentience directly for any of the above reasons, but can do so indirectly through separate avatars/emanations of himself in the material world.

I could see theists of different religions taking any number of those or other stances. I lean towards #4, but I am not a theist myself.

Of course if we are talking about gods (lowercase) then most would say they are sentient much the same way we are. Apollo/Odin/Set are powerful and wise beings, but they are not omniscient and experience sensation like us more or less.

No.

God is a dumbass.

(sarcasm).

If he isnt sentient, then he isnt 'all knowing'. In fact he isnt any amount of knowing.

So why call him 'god'?

I'm polytheist.

I think there's enough signal to suggest that It is, just that our survival priorities might make It hard to relate to when so often the games It's playing with us cut across grain with that (stating that from the panentheistic rather than theistic perspective).

I’m an agnostic atheist.

I HOPE there is a decent place where one goes after death.

Very interesting question!

God is Unique and Transcendent.

I suppose that according to Quran God is not sentient (unable of feeling pain, but also unable of experiencing pleasure) because there is nothing like Him and the human is not created in the image of God according to Quranic religion. I do not know what are the doctrines about sentientness of God in non-Quranic unitarianisms (such as Bible-based ones which teach that Mosaic Law is still required for salvation).

I found such a text in first description of link in my Google search engine for the phrase is Allah sentient:

Is there a god?
If not, then certainly not.

And that's where I'd bet my pennies.