The Welch's/Wine Controversy in the Church of Christ

Post Reply New Topic

Hi yall,
As some of you know I am a member of the church of Christ. We typically use non-alcoholic grape juice for our communion. I have always wondered why we do that with Welch's when it was real alcoholic wine during Bible times. Well a while back my old reverend said that the Church of Christ switched to Grape juice from real red wine due to Prohibition. I know some Catholic Churches back then made use of a loophole involving sacramental wine. For some reason I never heard of Churches of Christ using that loophole.

We in the Church of Christ take communion every week. I am a bit surprised that my church changed or stopped or altered a religious practice because it was suddenly made illegal at one point. Grape Juice was chosen partially because there was no need for any special permits and/or licenses.....Ironically, using real wine for communion is and was thought to be too worldly for the Church of Christ.....Its highly ironic to me because the early church drank real wine during communion. Apparently, grape juice for communion may have started in the church of Christ in the 1800's but became widespread during Prohibition and became standard after World War Two.

I was thinking that one good thing about having grape juice instead of wine is that it might not be so triggering for some recovering alcoholics who’d find it triggering, not that I know much about that or anything. Overall, I find the concept of communion very strange.

Around the time the Bible was written most people were drunk on alcohol most of the time because drinking ordinary water could kill you.

It's pretty freaky knowing that if humans didn't learn how to treat water to make it drinkable we would have all gotten cholera or some other deadly water-born illness a very long time ago.