You know those threads you see every now and then where people speculate which celebrities have Asperger's/HFA/whatever? This is like, every one of those threads combined times ten. ASPIE GOD!
I think Jesus was goth, I'm just gonna throw that out there. If Jesus were still alive, he'd listen to Bauhaus and Christian Death while smoking cloves with his D&D playing friends. His tastes in fashion were a little out there (how many people around 1 AD wore immaculate white robes?), he expressed interest in vampirism, and he turned water into red wine (the second gothest drink in existence). Furthermore, no historical figure has been more influential to goth music (though Shakespeare comes close), and you'd be hard pressed to find someone with more dramatic piercings. If you think bridge labrets are hardcore, try getting some through your wrists.
See? I can play the "recreate a deity in your own image" game too.
[edit]: But don't get me wrong, I think you're on to something there.