Chick-fil-a and the homophobic sandwich
I'm saying they have the right to as Americans.
Are you talking about a free speech right, with this being an example of the nasty sort of speech that should not be illegal? If so, you missed my point. My point was never that what they wanted to do was illegal, but that it was a bad idea.
Skinheads are legally allowed to say the n-word way too much and talk about how black people 'aren't even human' if they want. That doesn't make it a good idea.
If not, then you still haven't explained why being specifically American makes any difference.
_________________
"A dead thing can go with the stream, but only a living thing can go against it." --G. K. Chesterton
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
I'm saying they have the right to as Americans.
Are you talking about a free speech right, with this being an example of the nasty sort of speech that should not be illegal? If so, you missed my point. My point was never that what they wanted to do was illegal, but that it was a bad idea.
Skinheads are legally allowed to say the n-word way too much and talk about how black people 'aren't even human' if they want. That doesn't make it a good idea.
If not, then you still haven't explained why being specifically American makes any difference.
I think you know I'm talking about religious expression.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
Would neo-Nazis have the right to set up a building near 9/11 if they were responsible for that attack? After all, not all neo-Nazis are violent people, they have their precious beliefs too. In fact Nazism can be considered not dissimilar to Islam, especially in many Islamic countries. In fact, Islam is more barbaric in many ways than Nazism was - people are stoned to death most days, most weeks. Women are punished for being raped. Jews and Christians are ethnically cleansed, apostates are executed and so on. This is all in the Quran.
Not all neo-Nazis are violent but for many of them, Mein Kampf is their bible. David Irving is a scholarly man, don'tchaknow?
This, for example, was broadcast on Iranian TV on Holocaust Memorial Day:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUIo0VoPl7U[/youtube]
Free speech, but dodgy free speech at the very best. This is the prevailing attitude amongst a lot of the media and politicians in Iran (see President Dinnerjacket's pronunciation on the Holocaust).
There's a difference between religious freedom and allowing people with well-hidden shady connections (they're very subtle, but they are there - one issue of Rauf's book connects him to Muslim Brotherhood fronts) to terrorism to use your religious freedom as a weapon in order to take a piss on the site of the worst terrorist atrocity on U.S. soil. It's funny how that these people are all very happy for religious freedom when it suits them, yet print a couple of cartoons about Mohammed in a Danish newspaper and they demand the Danish government apologise, threaten the creators of the cartoons with murder (and actually try to carry it out), burn down Danish embassies in Islamic countries and try to suppress free speech (cartoons in Middle Eastern countries of Jews with grotesque big noses, portrayed as Nazis who love to drink Palestinian blood is fine though and definitely isn't offensive at all).
I really think your ideological blindness is preventing you from seeing what's going on here. You can delude yourself to how "American" these people are, but quite a lot of these movers and shakers have connections to terrorism in the Middle East, promote Sharia and the like. Nice people. (Not the ordinary Muslims, but a fair few of the big imams and scholars.)
Anyone with an ounce of sensitivity (like the many American and Canadian Muslims I mentioned earlier who recognised that there is a problem with the site - in fact, Muslim opinion was very divided, with many being ambivalent at best about the site) would accept that this comes across like gloating to many people (even if they didn't believe it was themselves) and found another space for the site. They get their centre and a place to pray and whatever and they don't get people's backs up into the bargain.
(Sigh) I'm not talking about Muslims overseas. I'm not talking about Nazis. I'm talking about Americans of the Muslim faith who have had to live under the suspicion and hate of their neighbors since 9/11. Did you even know that in the rural United States, there have been attempts to stop the building of new Mosques, or have been subject to vandalism - and that's no where near ground zero, or New York city. Then there was that dumbshit white supremacist who figured he'd shoot up a Sikh temple because he apparently thought it was a Mosque. How is any of that right?
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Probably not. The mob's ADD has kicked in.
Actually visagrunt, this thing has everything to do with Chik-fil-a, because it demonstrates liberal anti-Christian bigotry, by putting your (and other liberals) double standard on display for all to see.
You go ballistic when that CEO gives his opinion, yet you have no idea why people are going ballistic over a Muslim "out-reach center" that was going to be put 2.5 blocks from ground zero as a victory monument for radical Islam.
So... you justify some cracker chicken CEO's homophobia by justifying Islamaphobia?
I can't believe I've been sucked back into this diversion from the topic at hand!
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
You go ballistic when that CEO gives his opinion, yet you have no idea why people are going ballistic over a Muslim "out-reach center" that was going to be put 2.5 blocks from ground zero as a victory monument for radical Islam.
I am pleased to see that your complete disconnect from reality remains well and truly in place.
Please, by all means, demonstrate my double standard. Where is it? When have I ever held myself, or people who think like me to a different standard than those who oppose me?
I haven't gone ballistic at Cathy's statement. I have been unambiguous in declaring repeatedly that he has every right to say what he said. I think that he is ignorant and small-minded. But I acknowledge his right to say what he said. I have also been unambiguous in saying that opponents of the Muslim centre are perfectly free to oppose it. Indeed, I know why they oppose it. I think that they are ignorant and small-minded, but I know why they oppose it.
In both cases, I believe the substance of their statements to be wrong. However, I am perfectly capable of supporting someone's right to express statements that I believe to be wrong.
And don't you dare imply that I am in any way anti-Christian. I come into this forum on a regular basis and express my support for people of faith and my respect for their faith. I strongly oppose any attempt to use faith as a basis for making public policy, but that--surely--is one of the cornerstones of the separation of church and state.
I expect an apology from you. But I shan't hold my breath.
_________________
--James
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUIo0VoPl7U[/youtube]
During the NAZI times, Julius Streicher ran crap exactly like this in his anti-Semite rag "Der Sturmer" The Iranians are using the same sort of characetures as did the NAZI anti-semites.
ruveyn
Yes, I'm quite aware that that's nothing but hateful, bigoted tripe. Worse, as it's presented in cartoon form, it's obviously being targeted at children.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Nobody said any of that was right. We've just been saying what a terrible idea it was to try to build a mosque on ground zero.
In part it's such a terrible idea because it could inspire more stupid crap for Muslims to have to put up with.
Keeping in mind that I've never said anything about its legality or illegality, how would this even be an argument for its legality? Banning new mosques on ground zero is not the same as banning new mosques.
_________________
"A dead thing can go with the stream, but only a living thing can go against it." --G. K. Chesterton
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
Nobody said any of that was right. We've just been saying what a terrible idea it was to try to build a mosque on ground zero.
In part it's such a terrible idea because it could inspire more stupid crap for Muslims to have to put up with.
Keeping in mind that I've never said anything about its legality or illegality, how would this even be an argument for its legality? Banning new mosques on ground zero is not the same as banning new mosques.
But should the Catholics be banned from building churches where they want just because some of their priests can't keep their hands off of boys? You can't blame a whole religion because the actions of the worst of their adherents.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
After watching that cartoon(if you can call it that) I feel horribly depressed.Have we learned anything from the past?Not only the people of Jewish faith died in the Holocaust but so did Gypsys,Jehovah Witness followers,homosexuals and another group of people Hitler called
"useless feeders",the mentally ill and anyone who had the balls to say" Hey,where are you taking my neighbor?!"I feel sick.
Not at all. But if all the molestation took place in one single house, I think it would be reasonable to prevent them from building a new church across the street from it. I think it would also be reasonable for anyone (whether Catholic or not) to criticize the church for considering that a good place.
That is quite correct, although completely beside the point.
_________________
"A dead thing can go with the stream, but only a living thing can go against it." --G. K. Chesterton
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Probably not. The mob's ADD has kicked in.
Actually visagrunt, this thing has everything to do with Chik-fil-a, because it demonstrates liberal anti-Christian bigotry, by putting your (and other liberals) double standard on display for all to see.
You go ballistic when that CEO gives his opinion, yet you have no idea why people are going ballistic over a Muslim "out-reach center" that was going to be put 2.5 blocks from ground zero as a victory monument for radical Islam.
So... you justify some cracker chicken CEO's homophobia by justifying Islamaphobia?
Well now you are also using racist lingo too, why am I not surprised...
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Oh but it is on topic, not a diversion.
You see no problem with a Muslim "Outreach Center" being put up 2.5 blocks from Ground Zero, which was obviously an attempt to set up a monument to celebrate those terrorist attacks on 9/11/2001, it doesn't take an Einstein to figure that out.
Yet you think a CEO should be persecuted and his business ran into the ground because he is asked a question and answers the question honestly (and Homosexual behavior according to the Bible is considered sinful), he said that he opposed same sex marriage, he didn't call for violence (something that you conveinently ignore).
Kraichgauer, I'm not sure how to say what should be said to you without flaming you, and if I had lost a family member on 9/11/2001, I would be entirely justified to flame you for your comments.
The Muslim "Community Center," "Outreach Center," whatever the hell you want to call it was being set up 2.5 blocks from where several thousand people were murdered when Islamofascists flew two Jumbo Jets into the World Trade Center. It was being set up to glorify those fanatics and how they killed thousands of people in the name of their religion.
Nobody died due to that CEO, he advocated no violence, he was asked a question which he answered.
I'm going to go calm down now before I really say something that would get me banned which in all honesty would be a completely appropriate response to your comments earlier and the comments I'm quoting.
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Probably not. The mob's ADD has kicked in.
Actually visagrunt, this thing has everything to do with Chik-fil-a, because it demonstrates liberal anti-Christian bigotry, by putting your (and other liberals) double standard on display for all to see.
You go ballistic when that CEO gives his opinion, yet you have no idea why people are going ballistic over a Muslim "out-reach center" that was going to be put 2.5 blocks from ground zero as a victory monument for radical Islam.
So... you justify some cracker chicken CEO's homophobia by justifying Islamaphobia?
Well now you are also using racist lingo too, why am I not surprised...
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Oh but it is on topic, not a diversion.
You see no problem with a Muslim "Outreach Center" being put up 2.5 blocks from Ground Zero, which was obviously an attempt to set up a monument to celebrate those terrorist attacks on 9/11/2001, it doesn't take an Einstein to figure that out.
Yet you think a CEO should be persecuted and his business ran into the ground because he is asked a question and answers the question honestly (and Homosexual behavior according to the Bible is considered sinful), he said that he opposed same sex marriage, he didn't call for violence (something that you conveinently ignore).
Kraichgauer, I'm not sure how to say what should be said to you without flaming you, and if I had lost a family member on 9/11/2001, I would be entirely justified to flame you for your comments.
The Muslim "Community Center," "Outreach Center," whatever the hell you want to call it was being set up 2.5 blocks from where several thousand people were murdered when Islamofascists flew two Jumbo Jets into the World Trade Center. It was being set up to glorify those fanatics and how they killed thousands of people in the name of their religion.
Nobody died due to that CEO, he advocated no violence, he was asked a question which he answered.
I'm going to go calm down now before I really say something that would get me banned which in all honesty would be a completely appropriate response to your comments earlier and the comments I'm quoting.
The people who want to build that outreach center ARE NOT THE ISLAMOFASCISTS WHO PERPETRATED 9/11!! !!
Nor are they trying to glorify the act.
The accusation that they are is BS smeared about by racists and bigots. And you my friend have fallen for it hook, line, and sinker.
And if I had lost someone in the twin towers, I'd like to think I'd still stand up for the rights of even the most despised but law abiding, in the memory of my lost loved ones.
And that's why I oppose the cracker - yes, I'm calling him a CRACKER! - because he's all for stepping all over the rights of other Americans he doesn't approve of.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Nor are they trying to glorify the act.
BS!! !
If they were not trying to glorify that act they wouldn't have been trying to place it at Ground Zero even after the families of people that on 9/11/2001 protested it being built.
Stop drinking the Kool-aid.
And that's why I oppose the cracker - yes, I'm calling him a CRACKER! - because he's all for stepping all over the rights of other Americans he doesn't approve of.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Well, got news for you a lot of people that lost loved ones on 9/11 would probably disagree with you putting it mildly (including American Muslims)!
Kraichgauer it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out the real motivations of that center, and it wasn't to serve as a memorial, if it was meant to be a memorial they would have had the common decency to respect the wishes of the family members whom lost loved ones and move it further away from ground zero.
Thing is you talk about the CEO being bigotted yet you want to silence him and destroy his business, he hasn't advocated anything of the sort directed towards people that disagree with him. You know what that shows, if you want to see the real bigot, you should look in the mirror, and I'm stating a fact here, not an opinion.
Kraichgauer
Veteran
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 48,446
Location: Spokane area, Washington state.
Nor are they trying to glorify the act.
BS!! !
If they were not trying to glorify that act they wouldn't have been trying to place it at Ground Zero even after the families of people that on 9/11/2001 protested it being built.
Stop drinking the Kool-aid.
And that's why I oppose the cracker - yes, I'm calling him a CRACKER! - because he's all for stepping all over the rights of other Americans he doesn't approve of.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
Well, got news for you a lot of people that lost loved ones on 9/11 would probably disagree with you putting it mildly (including American Muslims)!
Kraichgauer it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out the real motivations of that center, and it wasn't to serve as a memorial, if it was meant to be a memorial they would have had the common decency to respect the wishes of the family members whom lost loved ones and move it further away from ground zero.
Thing is you talk about the CEO being bigotted yet you want to silence him and destroy his business, he hasn't advocated anything of the sort directed towards people that disagree with him. You know what that shows, if you want to see the real bigot, you should look in the mirror, and I'm stating a fact here, not an opinion.
Those American citizens who want to build the Islamic center near ground zero want to prove they are part of the American mosaic. They aren't backing down because that would be conceding they are second class citizens. Proclaiming an Islamic victory at the site is a paranoid fantasy.
And if you want to call me a bigot, feel free. But the fact remains, the Chick-fil-a CEO is advocating restricting gays to second class citizenship - something which many Muslim Americans are experiencing since 9/11. That's why I'm sympathetic with both groups.
And I never said the Chicken boss couldn't speak his mind. But those of us who disagree with him have a right to speak ours as well. And that includes not buying his product.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer