Autistic brains 'never daydream'

Post Reply New Topic

this may be tangential, but ...
I have heard that it's impossible to dream (like actual dreams, with pictures and stories, like a movie) in the first moment of falling asleep, but I do that all the time, and I know other supposedly normal people who do it too.

so i think the brain doesn't always do the things that they say it's supposed to...

so maybe when we feel we are daydreaming, we daydream differently, but maybe our brain is relaxing in the way it needs to, instead of the usual way.

this is not very scientific.... sorry.

"All men dream: but not equally. Those who dream by night in the dusty recesses of their minds wake by day to find that it was vanity: but the dreamers of the day are dangerous men, for they may act their dream with open eyes, to make it possible."
-T.E. Lawrence

I am not exactly sure if I daydream or not. There are times when I will be thinking of something and I will get so deep in thought that when I finally come back to reality, I don't even remember where I am. My mind does not usually drift off into random thoughts or things that are normally considered daydreaming. So I guess that I cannot say yes or not on this poll.

wow, i always dream about people, yet there is no way iam NT. i mean, even if i went for diagnosis and were declared not AS, i am not normally social by any stretch of the imagination.

it seems so peaceful to dream without people. i wonder if i could make myself do that...

[tangent]
i always thought we dreamed about what our brains are working on. to put it inelegantly, i thought dreams were sort of the gas and rumblings that your brain gets when it's having trouble digesting things.

the reason i think this is that i often have nightmares (although they are comical once I wake up) about the things that worry me (starting the new semester/ teaching, problematic relatives), and sometimes i dream in a language that i speak badly, but that i am working hard trying to learn.
[/tangent]

I agree with Diamonddavej, the experiment does sound as if it was flawed. I know I definitely daydream, and most of my conscious thoughts are daydreams of some sort.

Sorry, haven't had time to read the whole topic. I don't think I daydream or I do so very rarely. What is the requirement for something to be a daydream, anyway? I think this is the main thing.

Hrm... My mind does wander. Is that close enough?

Daydreaming non-stop is my main problem. First its a visual
process. What I call daydreaming is not random as much as self
directed. I can image anything and see it in my minds eye. I
can build/do anything in my mind. I tend to do it with my eyes open.
You may enjoy a movie or a book but my daydreams are more
interesting to me. There so interesting its all I do:(
Now the random thoughts start right at the moment I begin to
fall a sleep. This is not daydreaming to me but a real dream state.
I rarely remember these random thoughts.

I'm a Daydream Believer. I Daydream all the time.

They're drawing the wrong conclusions from this test.
If I was asked to stare at a cross for 21 seconds, while in an MRI scanner, I for sure would be highly focused in starting at the cross and making sure I was doing it properly and not make my mind wander becasue 'I'm doing a test'. I'm not surpirised of results at all, but I'm surprised about the conclusions they draw.
It's bull. I daydream *alot*!

I daydream all the time, in fact I find it extremely difficult to focus on most things for more than a couple of minutes at a time. As others have said, it must be the specific task of concentrating on the cross which is causing the temporary gap in daydreaming.

I constantly daydream. I am, in fact, daydreaming as I type this.

I'm finding this test hard to believe anyway, as it was only 30 seconds. The only thing it showed was that NTs can't concentrate on something for 30 seconds. Okey-dokey.

Perhaps we daydream with different parts of our brains though? My daydreams are very complex, so much so that I can't explain them without writing a background, which, at an estimate, would be at least 30 pages. So it wouldn't be a bored section of my mind making it up, no?

That could hardly be less true for me. I have difficulty stopping myself daydreaming, if anything - ideas, imaginary scenarios, replaying scenes from TV and movies.

It seems to me that, if anything, daydreaming too MUCH is more of a problem for us. After all, Autism is, fundimentally, a case of being locked in oneself and unable to interact with the _external_ universe. Our inner universe is too consuming and all encompassing.

And of course, the test is highly flawed and proved nothing beyond its extremely contrived conditional circumstances.