HisDivineMajesty wrote:
The convoy is often described by Israel's most ardent supporters as a bunch of gun runners, yes.
However, medical supplies are, apparently, also refused on a regular basis. And it's not even Israel's government in charge of the area.
What a charming bunch of weasel words. "Apparently," refused on a, "regular," basis... you can tidily sweep any exception under the rug that you've woven there.
Let's get down to a few facts:
1) Israel unilaterally and completely withdrew settlements from Gaza, over the objections of Israel settlers. It is lamentable that she has not been so forthcoming on the West Bank, but nonetheless there is an express recognition that Gaza is and always will be Palestinian territory. To be sure, the blockade of airspace and territorial waters continues, and that is properly criticized as an incomplete disengagement from Gaza--but given that the Quartet imposed economic sanctions on Gaza after Hamas' election, the blockade should not be viewed in isolation.
2) The blockade of Gaza was not undertaken unilaterally by Israel. Gaza has a land border with Egypt, and any Israeli blockade is irrelevant if Gaza has an open border with Egypt. The fact is that Egypt (and more importantly Egypt's military) is just as concerned about the arming of Hamas as Israel is. Throw Lebanon and Jordan into the mix, and suddenly the only state bordering Israel that has an interest in unblocking Gaza is Syria.
3) Palestine is composed of two very different pieces of territory, administered by two very different political parties. Ramallah is a showpiece for what Fatah has been able to achieve on the West Bank. Abbas has stated that Fatah and Israel are agreed in principle on a land swap (though quantum has yet to be settled). So far the only thing that Hamas has been able to negotiate with Israel is a prisoner exchange (though that achievement should not be minimized).
4) Humanitarian aid to Gaza transits the land border daily. Enough? Probably not. And even the relief that does make it through is subject to misappropriation--Hamas has comandeered aid shipments and sold them to the highest bidder, or kept them for its own purposes.
I am a strong proponent of a two-state solution at the earliest opportunity. But that opportunity cannot come until Palestine demonstrates the capacity to be self-governing. Fatah and the regime on the West Bank are most of the way there. Hamas and the regime in Gaza are nowhere. Until Fatah regains political authority over Gaza, and the ability to police its own citizens, the blockade will be a fact of life not only on the Israel and Mediterranean borders imposed by Israel, but also on the Sinai and Red Sea borders imposed by Egypt.
_________________
--James