marshall wrote:
What makes you so sure people just "want to be miserable"?
I can't speak for the OP, but everyone I have ever met chooses to be miserable. It depends on your definition of misery of course. Most people choose to support the system we live in that leads to frustration and stress for some, and pain and death for others.
Why do they choose this? Because there are different levels of misery. People choose a moderate level i order to avoid the unbearable horror of the lower levels. If they try to make things better then the benefits will probably only be felt after they are dead, whereas the costs are felt now. There is a small risk that things could get far worse for everyone. Moderate misery appears to be the safe option for most people.
marshall wrote:
Maybe depressed people would have a little more strength to face their problems if they weren't forced into believing they were just lazy, weak, or self-willing themselves to be unhappy.
I agree. The laziest and weakest people I know are the intelligent ones who rise to the top. They have the ability to see a better world but choose not to. Even the best of them is like this. Yesterday I listened to a famous philosopher who argues that we should do more to help the poor. Sounds like a good man, right? At one point in the long interview he admitted that he ignores a fatal flaw in his argument (it relied on economic behavior that is extremely unlikely and he admits that he does not understand economics). Luckily for him the interviewer was not an economist either, and was predisposed to agree with his views. Rather than pursue that flaw the philosopher instead chose to ignore it. By an amazing coincidence, his choice to avoid the hard question results in him being rich (he considers 300 dollar shoes to be cheap) and famous (even a minor book sells tens of thousands of copies) and popular (his fans adore him, because he makes them feel moral). It also ensures that the poor will always stay poor, so he is guaranteed a job for life.
The laziest and weakest people I know are those at the top. The ones at the bottom are usually forced to work at things they don't enjoy, and forced to endure things they want to avoid, so they don't have the luxury of being lazy or weak.