Verbal Communications Differences and Difficulties Sticky
Googling "Eliminate" didn't do me any good. Do you know the company name?
Yah, pen and paper would be as good as a white board, except perhaps when you need something they can read on the other side of the table. As long as I have a good sense of the kinds of options available, it will be easier to start talking about this.
Yah, pen and paper would be as good as a white board, except perhaps when you need something they can read on the other side of the table. As long as I have a good sense of the kinds of options available, it will be easier to start talking about this.
Oh, Elluminate (sorry about sp) wouldn't be Google-able (is that a word?); this is simply a University-specific feature of academic Interactive Communication, which is used for remote viewers/listeners. Outside of academics, similar type systems are used too - but this is high-tech and interactive amongst users (not for individual use)! Such as for a lecture series with members abroad, etc. This is accessible ONLY with faculty permission at my University - no individual uses this. Sort-of like Skype for long-distance. Not for one-to-one communication or close interactions. Those who might use such an interface would be, for ex., political diplomats or business executives. I have access to this in my course since there are some remote students, so limited to classroom. (This system costs exorbitantly).
Pen & paper, and writing does work, but DANA or NEO (by Alphasmart, you can Google Alphasmart) are just more efficient to facilitate communication. Trust, I've done both and NEO is just more sophisticated - writing (on paper) equates to being ignored. I know that's rough but just reality. I wish I could show you a DANA or NEO and they're both in a reasonable price range! Neo, for example, costs ~ $150 ish and has features - easy to easy, very portable and readable. Alphasmart does specialize in resources for those with 'special needs' with Autism in forefront.
I'm at University in a rigorous academic/research program so it's imperative I can communicate; hence, NEO. (For me, this is tax deductible - a medical expense and this can even be covered by some med insurance - check that out)!
There are text-to-speech programs on laptops too but then laptops are cumbersome to carry around - just not practical for communication purposes. Some have said that text-to-speech doesn't solve anything since this is virtually like speaking - doesn't address the original difference in communicaiton speech anyway. Text-to-speech can work well for those who are mute due to physical disabilities, for instance (like damaged vocal cords - not our case). I hope that helps, Anemone.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown
so i havent posted on here in awhile until somebody brought this to my attention again, i think im losing more and more of my attention span, either way wonderng how everybody is doing? we had our autism walk and autism benefit car show this past weekend...
Saturday i didnt sleep the night before but had some gluten free soup which i loved only gluten free thing i eat lol, and off we went, well somebody asked if i was low functioning i stood in ther entrance where it was the most windiest and headshook, and just became fixated on the sign above me blowing the wind like a good half hour, i didnt speak once jus some signs basic signs, i went from table to table cuz there was autism fair there, looking and feeling all the rubber on the pens trying to feel the best one, no luck. I met some of the characters, bugs bunny, elmo, cookie monster, mickey and buster from blueclars, well i picked at their hair and watched it blow in the wind made their hands clap, made them twirl me in circles rubed my hands all over their fur. for some odd reason as much as somebody tells me theirs a person inside i dont understand or grasp it, anyways, the walk started we did 3 laps, which was fun, i flapped, headshook, i love to rock while standing also, jus normal stuff, i also somehow bit my lip and blood was everywhere, and my eyes hurt due to the sun so i punched myself a couple times to relieve that, before the walk started i got upset cuz it was taking long so i tried to bite jim, and poke him in the eyes, and then punch myself, while going into whining fits to giggling fits. After that we went to a car shoot for him, which i jus clapped everybodys hands, spun, ran back and forth, ppl ask me questions or how am i i jus reply with ello, idk why its sorta a reaction, i carry my rubber keyboard around wherever i go literally wherever i go even my new pan with a rubber handle i love hehe. Anyways after that we had a schedule change i melted down, not a good time, more plans got changed, but we did a walk to help relieve some added stresse which helped some the stares i get when i walk around is crazy i do a lot of self injurious behviors if upset anywhere i go well after i foudn out the ride i wanted to go on at the boardwalk wasnt up, i started hitting myself in the face, we had to quickly hurry back to the car, i love to wail myself with punches in my jaw, my chin, my eyes, my cheeks everywhere, if were next to somthing i headbang .
Sunday, was our car show for autism, which was fun, we went to ihop for breakfast i was at my lowest/stimmiest moment, i was all over only using the words where lady and gatorade the whole day, then we went to the show where everybody knew i had autism, but everybody was so nice, when we were there jim had to leave me to go see something while i was in the car, one of his friends walked up and was like can u be left alone? i jus shrugged as i rubbed my pan handle against my face rocking occasionally flapping. A couple days before that i was texting oen of his friends to relay a msg to jim, and his friend told jim he was shocked in amazement i had real thoughts, he didnt know cuz i never spoke, like jus cuz we cant speak we dont think either, it was weird but whateve i let it go, like i always do. anyways at the show jim got a 100 dollar certificate for audio for his car, hes turnin his car into an autism car complete with puzzle pieces as vinyl graphics, which is fun. everybody was so supportive, and sweet, they pat me on my head, tickle me, talke to me like im 2, i dont eve have conversations, one time one of his friends sat in teh car with me to hang with me for a bit i was eating some candy put in his lap see if he wanted any he said no i was listenin to jonas brothers he danced to try to get me involved, i jus sat there rocking biting and rubbing my keyboard this time, he talked to me asked me some questions i didnt reply i jus sorta pulled out more stimmy toys and put them in his lap like my fettucini ball he put on his head to be silly then on my head, then smiled pat me on the head and left. it was a typical interaction with me. then we went to jims work, where i sat in the back sleeping in the chair which i found out i even rock and bite in my sleep lol, then we went home and slept hehe. Thats was my typical weekend .
how was everybody elses weekend, what ya do ?
_________________
Being Normal Is Vastly Overrated
Hi Age1600! Lab Pet has missed you - good you had fun at your Autism walk & benefit last weekend.
I've developed a new module for my immunocytochemistry (=ICC) technique. I sautered copper wire onto split rings and fashioned 'neural nets' using amphibican netting. The neural tissue I've cut is @ 30 micro (via instrument) so the netting was quite apparently too rigid and risks tearing the delicate neural tissue. I know my pH range so I'm confident about incorporating nylon into my ICC procedure.
So...I actually went to a Craft/Fabric store (don't laugh); I needed chiffon, or equivalent. I bought bridal veil, made from toule. The (embarrassing?) part: The clerk asked if I was the bride, and about wedding season! Oh no. I couldn't really verbally answer and would have no idea how to possibly describe/explain WHY I needed bridal veil (for my laboratory). Anyway, I got a FREE bag of bridal buttercream mints, individually wrapped. Each candy wrapped is printed "Thank you for sharing our special day" and has a picture of silver wedding bells and ribbon. Geez. So I brought my 1 lb bag of bridal mints to lab. My advisor/PI nearly made himself sick - he ate quite a lot of bridal mints. I suggested they could be donated to the Chemistry Dept. secretary who has a communal candy dish - he did.
Do I get extra-credit for this endeavor? But my neural nets work beautifully and I've renovated the technique.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown
Hi again -
I am still trying to come to terms with a lot of the way I was forced to communicate.
I also was walled off and can still get that way on ocaasion.
However, I am not wanting to communicate anymore and I do not understand why someone wants to.
It's really weird. When I could not I would think of all these words to say and be very upset. Now that I can communicate and have mastered the art of "social Mimicky" which someone on her so wisely described, now I findit was idiotic. Most of the interactions I have had wth people have been:
1. Harmful
2. Stupid- just social masturbation
3. irritating
Most have not lead to anything meaningful.
When Iw as mute:
1. I could carry a thought to a very long length. I could formulate ideas because I was not interrputed.
2. I could compose poetry and write.
3. I could feel things more deeply.
4. I was able to discern the way things worked.
5. Many many others
Now I am feeling like an average idiot. I do not like ti
Sorenna: What you wrote does make sense, in that speaking/verbal can detract from thinking. For me, speaking becomes tiresome - fast. And just not congruent with my thoughts. But I do speak when I must.
Oh, just an update (Anemone will be interested): I had to replace my alphasmart...sigh. But I use mine a lot and electronics have a finite lifespan. Anyway - new information. I just ordered a new NEO ($219) AND, guess what, a Text 2 Speech Kit supplement for the NEO ($129). I know that's pricey but I'm a graduate student (and very academic - sciences) so I need my NEO.
I believe some medical insurance can cover for NEO, or any alphasmart product, since it's a facilitated speech device. When my taxes were prepared my alphasmart purchase was deductible as a medical expense.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown
Received Text-to-Speech device in the mail but, admittedly, haven't yet installed the software to NEO. This is a sacrifice I had to make for my academic program; without I resort to just writing which is disadvantgeous. Verbal speaking, by others, is the dominant form and writing is dependent upon reader, so this is the logical choice.
BUT I CANNOT STOP CRYING!! ! I feel as if I've relinguished my own voice. I can speak, and do - somewhat. But now that I'll present (verbally, via mechanical) my voice is no longer mine. With assurance, no other grad student knows what this is like, nor any faculty. I'll try to get over this transition - hard.
Separately, as some may know already: I do have an advocate (sort-of); she's a public health nurse. Nice lady but truly doesn't 'get it.' And no amount of explaining, explaining, explaining, will ever insert the data into her Neurotypical brain. Quite sure I'd do better without. Anyway, she's on holiday (yeah!) so don't neeed to do her for a while, at least. Time consuming pain.
She had instigated a once-a-month meeting with 3 others I know well and trust. Theorectically, this is ok except I'm not present during this. The others I'm fine with but not this nurse/advocate. Later, after this 1st meeting, I found from my friend in attendance that she did say to the other (totally without my knowing), that she is aware I communicate with other ASD individuals, in reference to Wrong Planet.
Her stance, which she stated to the others, is this is bad. Her reasoning? This then separates me from the 'real' society and others. Unbelievably ridiculous! Further, she knows NOTHING of this community for ASD individuals, who we are, what we do, etc. And she's oblivious about autism as well.
I am hurt she didn't tell me this was what she was thinking - I had no idea. Then for her to say this 'in secret!' Quite distrubing and now I feel I must justify/explain that I certainly may communicate with others of my own kind - just inane. I'm a scientist and function well; beyond presumptous of her. Just yuck.
Sorry for the whiny post - rather distraught with her and the preconceptions.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown
KingdomOfRats
Veteran
Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,833
Location: f'ton,manchester UK
Hello LabPet,
am sorry if haven't understood-but why not use both the device and real voice-just having TTS doesn't mean have to give up any verbal ability that do have,why not use the machine for speaking when finding it too difficult to do physically?
this is what am do,as have usually got a part of the day/every day when brain switches speech back on [though limited/echolalic].
It sounds like that lady needs to look at the ADA,as she is leaving self out of things because of disability,and instead of using WP as something bad against self,she should be on here reading it,
or get some books or DVDs on autism.
And if people were not to understand about why are using the TTS at one time,but not another-teach them to understand,write a blog about own experiences and show them.
Have had similar experiences with people passing on info [after giving links to own blog and WP to trusted support staff,someone had passed them onto other staff,service/home managers and LD nurse].
don't want to make things worse,but be careful about posting on the boards viewable by anyone on WP [think thats all apart from members only], as may end up in trouble or lose job,have seen what some support staff write about the council [who they work for] on their facebook accounts,and they say they could lose their jobs if the managers read it.
_________________
>severely autistic.
>>the residential autist; http://theresidentialautist.blogspot.co.uk
blogging from the view of an ex institutionalised autism/ID activist now in community care.
>>>help to keep bullying off our community,report it!
Hello KingdomOfRats, and others: You're right about using the Text-to-Speech Program; I only intend to use this when I have to give a verbal presentation. I do prefer to write, but NTs are verbal so need 'a voice' sometimes too. I can and do speak - but need to feel comfortable.
So sorry those at your facility aren't too 'Autistic friendly.' Do wish you had more freedoms since you have so many friends here.
Since I'm in academics & research I do have this indepence, but am still 100% Autistic - Really wish various neuro/psych often do not recognize this discrepency.
One who just joined, Stephanielynnkeil, will join us.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown
lelia
Veteran
Joined: 11 Apr 2007
Age: 72
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,897
Location: Vancouver not BC, Washington not DC
About your May 4th post: Yikes!
I have some friends from Alaska staying with me now and they say this winter they had 63 below weather and were dumping coal in their heater every two hours. That is lung-freezing. How did you cope?
I loved your story about the fabric purchase. I'm interested in your techniques.
Hello all. I have not visited here for awhile as I have been immersed in social skills classes. They are run by a local charity for people with autism. Generally the experience is a positive one and I do believe I am learning useful things. Some of the other people using the service are not overly verbal, but I am the only one who has identified themselves as being mute and placed importance on the recognition of this. Unfortunately I had a really bad experience on Wednesday and since it was related to being mute this is the first place I thought to come for advice.
What follows is a really long letter. I have blanked out the specific details as I am unsure whether to actually give this letter to those involved. I would hate to decide not to then find out someone identified the situation written about here and passed the letter on regardless.
But I do need to share this with people, if not those involved, because I was supremely hurt.
I walked out of the ***** workshop on Wednesday (13 05 09). My recollection of this event is outlined below. Based on similar previous events I believe this incident will be conveyed to you in unsympathetic terms. This is unfair given the limited range of ways I could react in what was an unnecessarily disabling situation.
Ordinarily I look forward to the workshops and have been excited at the possibility of volunteer work as a *****. This has proved to be encouragement enough to put aside past grievances with the jobcentre and try again to register as a job seeker. I have relied a lot on my mother to make the necessary telephone calls but the motivation has been my own. I mention this as a way to illustrate how positive my approach to work has become. It saddens me to think you may be told I acted inappropriately by walking out of the session because I have put a lot of effort into trying to make a success of myself through the workshops.
This is not a letter of complaint, but neither do I defend nor try to justify myself.
At the start of the lesson R***** (the group leader) announced that the group was going to play a game and told M***** to speak on my behalf. It was an instruction from one staff member to another. At no point was I asked if I required or wanted assistance. This was completely unnecessary and deeply humiliating as it undermines the method of communication I have developed over the years, turning it from something I do as a gesture of respect (towards those who are unfamiliar with mutes) into a parody of 'proper' communication. I am perfectly able to communicate for myself. Though I will admit that it is practically impossible to inform someone that their help is not required when the method of communication necessary to convey this idea has been so seriously devalued in front of everyone that it is rendered obsolete.
I do appreciate people reading aloud my comments. It is an easy way to share my thoughts in a group situation. What is not appropriate is for someone in a position of responsibility to decide that I need someone else allocated to me in order for my contribution to be meaningful. This is not about making my comments accessible to the group. It is a question of perceived weakness and singling someone out as weaker than the rest.
May I reiterate that it was decided by R***** before the game had begun that M***** should speak for me. There was no misinterpretation of my ability after observing me play. It was deliberate and planned. I resent being treated like a problem that needs to be solved. Not only is it an inaccurate view of my ability, it also disarms me when defending myself. Again: it is practically impossible to inform someone that their help is not required when the method of communication necessary to convey this idea has been so seriously devalued in front of everyone that it is rendered obsolete.
It is not the act of someone attempting to speak for me that is an insult. It is a helpful gesture, but only when asked for. In the workshop on Wednesday I was unable to counter the false belief that I needed help. It is not enough for the perpetrators of this insult to say that I should have said something instead of walking out. I was forced into the role of someone who needed assistance in order to communicate meaningfully. I did nothing to warrant attention being turned on me. What is more, I am not prepared to enter into dialogue with any bully, authority figure or otherwise. I am quiet, non-confrontational and pacifist; I object to having to fight with people who, unprovoked, take it upon themselves to decide what is best for me based on their own prejudiced beliefs about what it means to be mute.
I find it difficult to write about my feelings so I would like to quote someone else as an analogy to this experience:
“We are like sailors
Who on the open sea
Must reconstruct their ship
But are never able to start afresh from the bottom.”
(Otto Neurath 1882 – 1945)
This is particularly meaningful to me due to the late age at which I received my diagnosis. I am unable to start afresh from the bottom. I have to continue to build on whatever it is that I currently sail on. Whilst some of the foundations are shaky they are not completely unusable. I might sail on the same sea as everyone else, going in their direction, but my ship is alien. The tools I have to reconstruct my ship are very fine but I do not know how to use them. It is an arduous task to create useful new structures on top of strange pre-existing ones when the blueprints to do so are in a language I do not understand. The last thing I need are pirates unexpectedly attacking me and forcing me to remodel my ship in an image of theirs.
I do not want to be forced into another situation where people I trust become pirates who hack my ship to pieces because they do not recognise it as a fully working vessel worthy of being sailed as it stands.
Despite the humiliating way my autonomy was dismissed in the workshop I did try to join in the game. What was left of my confidence deteriorated with every unnecessary prompt to give an answer. It is meaningful to contribute to those questions in which I believe that my answers are thoughtful reflections of opinions that I genuinely hold. It is worthless to provide generic answers in the name of teamwork, and I resent being forced to do so. I value the responses I write in workshop exercises as it is the primary way people get to know me. When I contribute something without being prompted to do so my team gain an answer and an insight into their team-mate, but more importantly, it is a success in my attempt to explore the world on terms that are meaningful to me as a mute and autistic person. Take that away from me, choosing instead to allocate a spokesperson who prompts for answers and forces each response, and you get nothing more than a robot providing output in isolation. As an adult there is no conceivable situation where I would stay and give people the power to do that.
I attend the workshops because I am committed to the pursuit of learning new skills and making friends. I might appear more remote and less responsive than other members of the group, but I consider myself to be a valid, autonomous member capable of good quality spontaneous interaction if given the opportunity to conduct myself with dignity. It takes a really dire situation to make me walk out of a workshop.
And it takes a lot of confidence to return. I am willing to discuss with others what it means to be mute, but not when they force me into unnatural situations and devalue my method of communication. I need to be taken seriously in order to express myself. This is a difficult thing to do with accuracy, because any attempt to tell people why I acted the way I did will be misinterpreted as an apology by those who hold false beliefs about me. I can raise awareness, but I refuse to justify myself.
Thank you for reading this,
(my name).
lelia
Veteran
Joined: 11 Apr 2007
Age: 72
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,897
Location: Vancouver not BC, Washington not DC
At the start of the lesson R***** (the group leader) announced that the group was going to play a game and told M***** to speak on my behalf.
...
Wrong.
I'm guessing, a little, but maybe:
Before the start of the lesson, R***** took you to one side, quickly explained the game, and asked you if you thought that having M***** read out your comments would speed the game along, or whether you had a better idea.
At the start of the lesson R***** (the group leader) announced that the group was going to play a game and mentioned that you had requested that M***** read out your contributions.
...
Whatever the case, I can see how you were involuntarily placed in an untenable position, and walking out seems a highly appropriate way to deal with the situation. However, sending your letter is also necessary, as you do need to ensure that the reasons for your action are clearly understood.
_________________
"Striking up conversations with strangers is an autistic person's version of extreme sports." Kamran Nazeer
At the start of the lesson R***** (the group leader) announced that the group was going to play a game and told M***** to speak on my behalf.
...
Wrong.
I'm guessing, a little, but maybe:
Before the start of the lesson, R***** took you to one side, quickly explained the game, and asked you if you thought that having M***** read out your comments would speed the game along, or whether you had a better idea.
At the start of the lesson R***** (the group leader) announced that the group was going to play a game and mentioned that you had requested that M***** read out your contributions.
...
Whatever the case, I can see how you were involuntarily placed in an untenable position, and walking out seems a highly appropriate way to deal with the situation. However, sending your letter is also necessary, as you do need to ensure that the reasons for your action are clearly understood.
No, absolutely not. I have described the incident fully. What happened in this situation was completely unexpected and different to how interaction usually takes place. These are small groups and other members are in close enough proximity to read the things I write for themselves (should they wish to). It is only the case that something gets read aloud when the opportunity to project something specific to someone far away arises, and on these isolated occasions this a joint decision made with whoever offers to read the comment aloud. I am usually addressed as an independent person of reasonable intellect and ability. There was no need for someone to suddenly decide that I require someone else to speak for me, based on no evidence or previous experience of doing things like that. It was a decision someone made without consulting me.
After reading back through the letter in its capacity as 'sent', some errors that were not obvious when writing it became apparent.
One mistake is the way I wrote of being forced into that unnecessarily disabling situation. It is more accurate to remark that I had not before been subjected to that kind of treatment in the workshops. It was unexpected and, unprepared for it, I had no pre-written statements to help convey my thoughts. I can spontaneously write responses that can be considered factual and are “checkable”, such answers to questions about Kings and Queens of England, or locations of rivers around the world, etc. However when asked for my opinion I have nothing to write at all, the references I have for likes and dislikes are not easily expressed in words. When it was decided that someone else should speak for me I suddenly found myself in an unwanted situation without sufficient communication skill to resolve it (except to physically leave). Yet I did choose to attend the workshop and so it does not seem accurate to say I was forced into the situation. It is not as though they broke into my house whilst I slept and fastened me into a straight jacket. If I do send the letter this idea of force needs rewording.
I am still unsure whether to send it. Those people work for a charity, they did not act maliciously, it is their inaccurate and false beliefs about me that I oppose. Is it sound to respond to this situation with a letter? I do not have to attend. They provide a service to help people with autism learn social skills. They have no responsibility whatsoever to respect my particular methods of communication or question their beliefs about what constitutes legitimate communication.
I resent this situation because had it not occurred I would have been happy to continue attending. I am grateful for the opportunity to have joined, some people are not so lucky to be able to access such services. Still, I doubt the validity of my choice to attend on my own terms.
ViatorRose: You are articulate and wrote a cogent letter. An observation.....often neurotypicals (socio/verbal) do not consider the logic of their choices but act upon their standards which are dictated by arbitrary social standards. As defined by them. Being NV give the reader a great deal of power so you/we are at a disadvantage. Here's why: READING is interactive and takes some effort on 'others' part whereas one who SPEAKS is communicating to 'other' where they are passively taking in the message. Verbal is naturally more palatable to Neurotypicals. That's a hard step for them to take but the NV route not lesser!
KingdomOfRats video on Makaton is beautiful - I love to watch her sign. And this does require her 'listener' to WATCH her words instead of just passively listening. And KoR writing is always true-to-life. Not to bash neurotypicals, but much of their speech is merely filler.
Therefore, your letter is necessary. As to whether they'll read, then think - who knows. Maybe they'll reconsider their actions in the future.
You could write some 'ground rules' so they know how to better associate with an intelligent NV Autist (you) instead of their neurotypical autopilot. Might consider getting an advocate to implement this too. ViatorRose - I stand behind you 100% if you choose to send your letter. They did force you into a disabling situations which is pretentious at best. Your leaving was right.
Hello lelia: I love Alaska and somehow acclimate to the cold. A big plus for me is that wintertime darkness doesn't bother me. I feel sorry for those who suffer with the dark...seasonal affective disorder. If the inside is warm and cozy (like your friend's place) then winter is nice; I exercise inside and stay busy in my laboratory. I think staying active is the key.
I am innovative in my lab procedure and there's nothing I won't try....good my advisor, others, have a sense of humor
Being a chemist involves creativity and some mechanical sense too.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown