314pe wrote:
I don't care about the money, but I'd like to keep mutual friends. Now one of our mutual acquaintances is asking me to reconcile with them. He's saying it's ok to have sex with a girl your friend really likes and there's no need to ask your friend. And a friend shouldn't feel bad at all. He thinks I'm idealistic and shouldn't be upset about this. Is this really normal? What's the point of having a friend then?
In my social group in college, it would be considered o.k. to sleep with someone your friend liked under these circumstances: the person your friend likes has told your friend that there is no possibility of a relationship *and* you told your friend that you also have feelings for this person and that the person let you know the feelings are mutual BEFORE you did anything with the person in question. This would also be considered o.k. with a friend's ex, as long as some time has passed and you spoke to your friend about it first.
It would NOT be o.k. to sleep with someone your friend likes if your friend has been dating that person, and the person has not told your friend that they don't want to date anymore beforehand. And, it certainly would not be o.k. to do this while your friend is in the same house and may be able to hear you under any of these circumstances.
There had been situations that arose similar to yours due to extreme drunken stupidity. However, the friend who hurt the other friend would apologize profusely about it and never put the blame on their friend for "thinking it will work out". Plus, I really think it was unnecessary for the girl to outline specific characteristics of yours that you have no control over when she told you it would never have worked out. I think that was mean. And, none of my friends would (although would be embarrassed) blame the other friend for speaking about it.