Coke points, although I will probably cash them in for the KitchenAid mixer next time they have items in the 10,000 plus range. I've gotten a Dremel and a couple of DVDs from them in the past
Mopeds. Some to keep, some to sell, all to ride, never have less than 2 or more than 5
Reel to reel tape recorders, currently I have 4
Random pieces of scrap metal on the roadside, I use them for welding
Music equipment; 1 acoustic guitar, 5 electrics, 2 basses, a drum kit
Old maps
wheat back pennies
a console stereo
I collected candles for a while then quit
USB cables
broken cell phones
Beatles books and records
Stickers, buttons and patches; about a dozen Bettie Page ones floating around somewhere
Homies toys
ticket stubs
Solar garden lights
Birthday cards
show flyers from ex-bands
Thank-you gifts from clients. One of my most heartwarming tokens is a Napoleon Dynamite figure presented to me by the movie director