This is but hearsay from someone I trust, but:
- Unless you only ever have sex with the person you will marry, having had sex outside marriage increases the chances that you will engage in infidelity substantially- and more with each additional partner. According to studies, statistical analysis, and whatnot.
So. . . sex before marriage bad?
Depends on how one defines marriage and how important it is. . . and, of course, on what and how important one finds the benefits of extramarital sex to be.
From a personal standpoint I can say this-
First, I've always felt- and I still feel- that the whole "physical compatibility" thing can be worked around, if, for example, someone wishes to wait. A lot of sex is about communication and experience; on top of this, "try before you buy" doesn't, I think, give anything like an accurate lifetime picture anyway. To me, marriage means for keeps. . . the rest of your life, if you can make that a good thing. . . and a lot of things can reap dramatic changes over a person's lifetime, in both their sex drive and their lovemaking style. . . not to mention their body. Therefore, a marriage can't be stably founded on "physical compatibility"- it has to be founded on an ability and a desire to work things through together.
Furthermore, in this same vein, "compatibility," I think, is highly fluid. Consider something that recently happened to a friend of mine. She has married a married friend who has complained of his wife's low sex drive since the birth of their child, now many months ago. When she started spending time with his wife (the same time, btw, that she started spending time with him). . . well. . .in his words to my friend, "whatever you're doing, keep doing it."
When I asked her what she was doing, she said- "I listen to her. I rub her back. I do her dishes sometimes. . . And I'm constantly telling him to do the same."
A lot of women seem to feel more like having sex when other things- like help with housework- are taking place that make them feel loved, supported, and appreciated. This is not some frigid or manipulative form of blackmail- it's just something that sometimes happens when people are emotionally connected to sex.
In short term relationships, there wouldn't be much reason to figure this out- or to figure out all the other ways that sexual relationships and emotions are rooted into the rest of our lives. The more complex dynamics simply don't come into play. I would like to be married someday because I think that dealing with these complexities over time with the right partner could create a ritchness and depth that might well be impossible to come by any other way. Of course, this is only my best guess, coming from a limited (if unusually. . . fertile?) set of experiences.
When asking, Why no sex before marriage? one might ask Why monogamy? as well. I'm not saying these questions are the same or that people shouldn't ask them, but I don't think they are unconnected.
_________________
And if I die before I learn to speak
will money pay for all the days I lived awake but half asleep