invisiblesilent wrote:
I found this interesting. Was the percussion v flintlock thing a choice you made or was the choice made for you by circumstance? What is the accuracy/power of this thing going to be like compared to a modern rifle? How *safe* is it compared to a modern rifle i.e. is there even a slight chance it will blow up in your face? I know nothing about classic firearms, the only rifles I have ever fired have been relatively modern, the "oldest" type I've used was a bolt action .22 and if those are well maintained they are safe as houses.
Percussion was purely based on price for me in this instance. Percussion offers more reliable ignition, but you do need a cap to get it going; flintlock can be a little less reliable to set off, but you only need the flint and the same powder as you used in the actual gun to work. Plus, flintlock is a little harder to shoot due to the fact there's a slight delay between the flint igniting the small amount of powder in the pan (which then sends flame into the chamber of the gun and bang!), and said delay can be a little disconcerting, especially with a heap of flame and smoke covering your face -- if you flinch at the powder in the pan igniting, you'll miss when the full load in the gun ignites. Percussion is almost instant, like any other gun when the hammer hits the primer.
Accuracy and power are somewhat equivalent to modern rifles (especially if you use more modern projectiles); if it's specifically called a "rifle", it'll have rifling in the barrel that'll impart spin on the projectile like a modern one. The old roundballs though do lose a lot of velocity as they fly (hence, power); a lead ball isn't very aerodynamic. A .45 Cal roundball, starting at say 1800 feet per second, will go down to around 1000 at 100 yards. Said velocity loss equates to less penetration and greater bullet drop. So, decent at short range with the roundball (100 yards). The so called maxi-balls and whatnot are similar in shape to a normal bullet (long and heavier than roundballs), so they retain velocity a lot better. Sure, you could sling a .45 or .50 cal roundball out to 800 yards or so, but hitting won't be an expected thing most times; good if it happens. Whereas a...modern bolt gun in .308 Winchester will be expected to hit a man-sized target at 800 yards most times. A .45 cal muzzleloader is good for midsized deer (just giving an idea of the power), whereas the .50 and .54 cal ones are better for the larger species of deer and bear. You can buy modern SABOT rounds for them, which tend to require a faster twist barrel than the older reproduction designs; they effectively enter the range of powerful modern cartridges (kinda defeats the purpose of using a primitive weapon IMO. I'm just going to be shooting lead balls like they did in the 1700s in mine).
Safe as anything else. They're modern reproductions (there are antiques of course, but people don't shoot them for a hobby). You could fill the barrel entirely up with blackpowder and ram a ball on top and you won't harm it or yourself (you'll just get a lot of unburnt powder blown out of the barrel. The main thing is that the ball must be seated securely against the powder; no air-gap or anything (that's a pipe-bomb then with all the effects of that); so you just make sure you ram the ball down real good. O, and never use modern smokeless powder; too high pressures, and it will burst the barrel and potentially cause injury; that's an easy rule to follow though.
It's a fun hobby, if a little hard to get started. You generally aren't seen as a scary gun nut if you tote a gun design from the 1700s either.