Cuterebra wrote:
I hate to admit it, but sometimes women make me hate my own gender.
Anybody ever read The Handmaid's Tale? It made me hissing, spitting mad and sparked a lifelong loathing for the author, Margaret Atwood (well, her writing anyway). I was offended that she saw women as so weak that they would allow themselves to be completely subjugated by men. Disgusting!
I've read it. I thought it was very good, but I do see your point about how passive the women seemed to be. If I think back, I was probably quite irritated at the Handmaid's tale too when I first read it ("why didn't she just run away? Why wasn't there a greater protest??).
The thing is, I can see how it could happen; legally take away one's ability to own money or land, and you are pretty much reduced to being reliant on other people.
When Virginia Woolf wrote 'A Room of One's Own', she wrote in
"order for a woman to write fiction she must have two things, certainly: a room of her own (with key and lock) and enough money to support herself". She was referring to herself and her writing, but it's equally true for any other profession. At the time, there were places women couldn't enter, and even if legally they had some rights, without money or a place to live of their own, they would always be dependant on men.
I think Margaret Attwood was approaching the idea from the other way; what happens to women (or for that matter, any group) when you take these things away? She may not have got it completely right, but personally I felt it quite realistic.
I don't know if there's a moral intended for the story, but to me, she seems to be saying; 'don't let your guard down'. Women may have equal rights now, or near to equal, but we shouldn't get complacent and ignore political shifts that suggest things are going backwards. I think something like that happened in Iran a couple of decades ago; it was a fairly moderate Muslim country and women were educated and were not forced to wear head coverings etc., up until a new political party took over and it became very conservative. I don't know if it still is today.
As I said though, I do see how her main characters can be irritating. I've read most of her books, and I can't remember a single one that has a traditionally happy ending, or a character that you didn't feel like shaking (her men are equally wimpish)