Can homeschooling cause Asperger's Syndrome?

Post Reply New Topic

...and genetics, and accidents, and experiences, and diet, and many other things. Unsure if you are agreeing with OP, but even if OP suffered a form of abuse whilst being home-educated that made him develop AS-like traits, it still wouldn't have been the home-educating itself that caused those traits, but the abuse. Children in schools can suffer all the same abuses that home-educated children can.

It's the other way around, Asperger's causes homeschooling. At least it did with me when my teacher enraged my parents to the point that they did not want anything to do with the public school system.
She told them I would never learn to read, drive a car, or get a job and I should be in a "special" class where I would only learn how to brush my teeth and tie my shoes

Consider the real possibility that the cause and effect may go the other direction: Having autism may cause you to be home-schooled.

This was true in my case. I was definitely autistic from my toddler years, and was home-schooled off and on starting in the third grade for two main reasons: One, most schools simply couldn't accommodate me, since I was both gifted and disabled. And two, my mom didn't want me labeled autistic, which would have happened in most schools.

Whether you're a good parent who wants to properly educate a student with an unusual learning style, or a paranoid parent like my mom who believes that being called "autistic" is so bad that it's preferable not to attend school at all, you may keep an autistic student home and teach them there. The autism was there all along, and was the causal factor.

Autism is usually apparent before a child starts school; starting school might be the thing that makes it obvious enough to diagnose, but it's plain that it's been there all along. I do not believe that home-schooling causes autism; in fact it may be a protective factor if the school available is a bad fit and a better environment can be created at home.

I don't think that AS is so easy to cause that homeschooling could cause AS in a child who had been born with a typically developing brain. The social brain seems to start developing and locking in verry merry berry early, from infancy in a child wih typical development.

No

Agreed. Nature AND Nurture make a person, not one alone. Autism is how people with certain brain-wiring relate to their world. Always a combo of inherent traits plus social experience.
And as a a person with a Psychology degree, Personality disorders are pretty flimsy, except for Anti-social.
My current hypothesis is that conditions like Schizoid personality disorder are actually un-dxd Autism Spectrum Disorder, who are comfortable with their isolation.

Sincerely,
Matthew

No it doesn't.

It sure doesn't! I was homeschooled and it was one of the best things that happened to me. I don't even want to THINK about life would have been like had I NOT been homeschooled. My experience with homeschoolers that may have bad social skills etc come from two types of families:

1 The parents homeschool from laziness, don't care about their kids, etc.

2. The parents believe in patriarchy and take it to the extreme, or are trapped in church that takes patriarchy to the extreme. Parents/churches that take patriarchy to the extreme over protect their children, especially their daughters who usually have no freedom.

Homeschooling is awesome. The patriarchal (aka complementarian) beliefs that many homeschoolers have are not.

No. Aspergers is a certain wiring of the brain. Homeschooling can't change the wiring of your brain, but it can give you difficulties in life which are similar to the problems that people with AS have.

====

Empathy is a thing which (some) people naturally have in their brains, it's not something you learn, so homeschooling cannot cause a lack of it.

In wouldnt exactly say it caused autism but Im sure homeschooling doesnt "help" the situation.