How Important Is Gender To Your Identity?
Oh well, I'm vegan so the only thing I curry are beans, and vegetables when I do season them up. I made a vegan lasagna the other day where I seasoned eggplant that I roasted prior with turmeric and curry powder as well as black pepper, chili powder and paprika. That is cooking done correctly.
CockneyRebel
Veteran
Joined: 17 Jul 2004
Age: 50
Gender: Male
Posts: 116,782
Location: In my little Olympic World of peace and love
^ I relate to this. In a way I find it fascinating when people do feel a pull to a specific gender identity because I have no idea how that would feel. I do not feel female, but my body is, so that's what I say I am. *shrugs*
I have never been a typical female, but I have never been a typical anything. In some ways I may seem more male, in other ways more female. I don't know what I am... maybe gender fluid or gender neutral. I dunno. But I do believe that had I been born in a male body I would likely be sitting here saying pretty much the same kind of thing.
I guess I don't understand the logic here - if someone isn't born a male how would they "know" what a being a male feels like.
Plus what does not "identifying" as a male or female mean? Um... if a woman likes to play rugby then does that automatically mean she doesn't "identify" as a female? Why can't she just identify as a "woman who likes sports?"
(Plus not all guys like sports anyway, so if a guy prefers playing music to playing sports then does that mean he doesn't identify as a "male" or he's just a male who likes sports).
dossa
Veteran
Joined: 24 Aug 2009
Age: 47
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,590
Location: The right side of my couch...
^ I relate to this. In a way I find it fascinating when people do feel a pull to a specific gender identity because I have no idea how that would feel. I do not feel female, but my body is, so that's what I say I am. *shrugs*
I have never been a typical female, but I have never been a typical anything. In some ways I may seem more male, in other ways more female. I don't know what I am... maybe gender fluid or gender neutral. I dunno. But I do believe that had I been born in a male body I would likely be sitting here saying pretty much the same kind of thing.
I guess I don't understand the logic here - if someone isn't born a male how would they "know" what a being a male feels like.
Plus what does not "identifying" as a male or female mean? Um... if a woman likes to play rugby then does that automatically mean she doesn't "identify" as a female? Why can't she just identify as a "woman who likes sports?"
(Plus not all guys like sports anyway, so if a guy prefers playing music to playing sports then does that mean he doesn't identify as a "male" or he's just a male who likes sports).
I would have no way to know what what being a male feels like. I have never been one. For myself, it comes down to not really knowing if I understand what it feels like to feel female. I have heard people say things about feeling like a woman regardless of what their actual body is. Same can be said about feeling male regardless. I have no idea how to connect to that because I just do not feel like one or the other. It's an adjective to me to describe a body type, not a feeling or idea.
Male or female, to me, has nothing to do with things like playing rugby or other gender stereotypes. That lack of stereotype also helps fuel my confusion when it comes to people feeling male or female... if that makes sense. Example... my spouse knows a guy who says he rejects all gender based stereotypes. He is a stay at home dad, has long hair and a big ole beard on his big ole body... seriously this guy is a bear of a man and looks kinda intimidating even though he's a softie... he also listens to musicals and bounces at bars and loves romance, sewing, and motorcycles. But at the same time, the things he says that make him not buy into stereotypes are themselves based in stereotypes. It confuses the hell out of me. Like what? He says he rejects gender stereotypes but uses them as examples of how he is shattering them by blatantly disregarding them? To me his behavior is like non conformists who live their life by observing what the masses do and then doing the opposite... they still live their life based on the norms. It makes sense to him though. I get it makes sense to him, but I fail to understand it.
I admit to having a lack of understanding about what gender is all about beyond a description.If I have no real connect to either, it would seem irrelevant to me which kind of body I was in. I don't think suddenly growing boy bits would make me feel a connect to maleness. But you know, I can't say for sure because I'm not planning on sprouting a penis any time soon. Heh. Not sure if that made sense or not.
_________________
"...don't ask me why it's just the nature of my groove..."
I personally find myself to be agender . Gender is a meaningless concept to me . Like I get that there are some that identify as being either masculine or feminine , regardless of anatomical sex , but I just can not relate to it . I even imagine that if I were to have been born as the opposite sex , I would have been as content with having grown up as a girl as I am now as a male person . For what it's worth , I have taken a test that purports to graft gender range , and I scored slightly in the feminine category . http://www.hemingways.org/GIDinfo/sage/test.htm I did not feel that this test is all that appropriate though , as it asks such questions as what my political views , and erotic preferences are . If your views are more left-wing , as mine are , you will get a result more in the feminine category , and conversely , the more right-wing the more masculine you are , according to the test . This is how arbitrary gender identification can be .
Yeah, I think that if one takes the gender is a social construct view then "gender identities" are pretty much meaningless; under that view everyone is just a "human" with the only difference being the reproductive functions.
(I personally don't believe it's a social construct though, I think society influences roles but I believe it boils down to testosterone and estrogen, and since men naturally produce more testosterone they tend to be drawn more toward "competative" activities like sports on average, but this will still vary somewhat from person to person rather than being totally "black/white").
Sweetleaf
Veteran
Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 34
Gender: Female
Posts: 34,870
Location: Somewhere in Colorado
Gender wise I act manly, albeit but somewhat off.
Heh those things are only a problem if women let them be. Granted the "biological" parts are not easily changed unless you get "that" removed" but everything else wearing make up, shaving, etc is only a problem if one lets it be. Before I learned I was genderqueer and struggled to even identify myself as a female shaving and wearing make up was never a thing that was high on my priority list. The only area I shave are my pits because if I don't then my deodorant would quit on me faster and my sweat smells like curry powder from all the seasoned cooking I do ...
That's not 100% true...other people can react negatively and judge you for it which can be a problem even if you do your best not to make it one. Not saying it is the same thing as being forced to shave, but there definitely is social pressure for females to shave body hair. I don't anymore because I prefer not to and social pressure isn't enough to convince me to do it.
_________________
We won't go back.
Currently it's not important for me, but I don't exclude possibility that it might be in some degree important in future. Life where gender identity dose not have any significant importance for some person is usually life where one is dedicated to his/her(it does not matter!) special interests and dose not form family.
When someone wants to have family, gender identity is important. Since people who want to have family are much more common then those who don't, gender identity is generally important to people.
What impact dose AS have for someone gender ID importance, I am not sure, but I think that for AS people, gender ID has much less importance.
Gender wise I act manly, albeit but somewhat off.
Heh those things are only a problem if women let them be. Granted the "biological" parts are not easily changed unless you get "that" removed" but everything else wearing make up, shaving, etc is only a problem if one lets it be. Before I learned I was genderqueer and struggled to even identify myself as a female shaving and wearing make up was never a thing that was high on my priority list. The only area I shave are my pits because if I don't then my deodorant would quit on me faster and my sweat smells like curry powder from all the seasoned cooking I do ...
That's not 100% true...other people can react negatively and judge you for it which can be a problem even if you do your best not to make it one. Not saying it is the same thing as being forced to shave, but there definitely is social pressure for females to shave body hair. I don't anymore because I prefer not to and social pressure isn't enough to convince me to do it.
You're welcome not to but most men aren't going to find it attractive, and if you don't have any greater reason for not doing it other than just wanting to "do the opposite of whatever people tell you" then that seems like a petty reason, IMO.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
When the mask becomes an identity |
09 Oct 2024, 1:01 pm |
identity theft |
19 Aug 2024, 7:04 pm |
Identity Crisis |
22 Oct 2024, 7:00 am |
gender confusion |
13 Oct 2024, 7:09 pm |