Aspies in Dysfunctional Families (Scapegoat and Lost Child)
nirrti_rachelle
Veteran
Joined: 21 Jul 2005
Age: 50
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,302
Location: The Dirty South
I was doing some reading on the roles of children in dysfunctional families. I come from one myself where my mother was emotionally abusive toward me (never the other kids) and an enabler to my drug-addicted stepfather who was physically and verbally abusive toward her. My mother took care of my physical needs but we never really bonded and my stepfather, though present in the home didn't think I was "his responsibility".
As for my biological father, he used his religion as an excuse to find me unworthy of his precious family. My brother and sister, though years younger, could break my things, misbehave whenever I babysat and whatever, but since it was done toward me, it didn't matter to my parents. I was even blamed for their behavior being told they acted better when I wasn't around so I was sent every single weekend, without fail, and everytime school holiday to my great-grandmothers so I woudn't be around.
After years of this crap, I got depressed, suicidal, ran away twice and got thrown in one of those psychiatric treatment programs for teens where they put you on lock-down. I was branded the problem, even though my whole family was screwed up and things only got worse for me. I only found peace after moving out on my own. Now, I can't imagine why anyone would ever want to move back in with their parents.
I was essentially what psychologists called a "lost child" during my childhood years and "scapegoat" during my teens. The lost child is the one who's invisible, never speaks up and withdraws to protect himself. The scapegoat is the one who acts out all the family's pain, being the most honest about the situation. Since he's the "squeeky wheel", the family focuses all the attention on him to avoid the real problem, which is the dynamics of the whole family.
Aspies, I've noticed, tend to come from these kind of families in a disproportionate amount. It's as if we're the perfect scapegoats or lost children. We don't have the ability to go into denial and are usually the most logical in all that mess. We also tend to be withdrawn naturally and have trouble voicing our needs and with all the drama going on, we can get neglected......and forgotten. If diagnosed, we are blamed for problems as AS can be the perfect diversion for parents to use.
_________________
"There is difference and there is power. And who holds the power decides the meaning of the difference." --June Jordan
hyper_alien
Veteran
Joined: 18 Apr 2006
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,039
Location: In the arms of me lover
This sounds so familiar.
In my family my parents blame me for the problems- even when it is them that are screaming at each other.
They blame my AS for what they are and how they live their lives.
It makes me so angry.
_________________
Me.
Last edited by hyper_alien on 28 Sep 2006, 1:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I came from a dysfunctional family. And I was/am the scapegoat. But you draw my attention to something I find fascinating - you're right, I didn't go into denial. But where did I go, then? Because I certainly went somewhere. The best I can figure out is that I went into Numb & Dumb. There are memories (not retrieved, I always had them) without meaning or emotion. Until I was safely adult, away from them, and into supportive therapy. *Then* I figured out what those memories were about. I have sibs in denial, now I understand better how they can do that. Thank you.
I was a scapegoat from birth until I moved out... literally.
Soon after the excitement at my birth faded, I was labeled a "difficult child" because I never slept through the night, cried constantly, and didn't "cuddle" much.
During my pre-school years, I was hyperactive and strong-willed, and my mother began comparing me to my sister, who is two and a half years younger than I, and neurotypical. I was labeled "the problem child" because I was insensitive to my mother's grief at my father's death, which occurred when I was two. (My mother claims that I did not understand that he had died; my memories--two "snapshot" memories of the time--seem to indicate that I understood death quite well, but perhaps I didn't respond to my own or my mother's grief in an expected way.)
By the time I was nine, and my mom married my first stepfather, I had already been called "unmanageable"; I hated to be washed, hated having my hair brushed, refused to wash dishes or have anything to do with slimy, sticky, or smelly substances while cleaning, and didn't like wearing clothes. I was driven crazy by inconsistencies in my environment, especially when it came to discipline--my mother's discipline was often mood-dependent. Enduring disappointment was impossible. During this time, my temper tantrums peaked; any of the aforementioned things could set them off.
When I was nine, my family endured a six-month marriage to a terminally ill bipolar man. I got my first taste of true abuse and extreme inconsistency, and my mother was convinced, by this man, that I was the family problem. After he died, I was taken to counseling for my bad behavior; I disclosed the abuse, but nothing was really done to help me or my mother and sister. By this time, I was clinically depressed--which, of course, resulted in more bad behavior.
By age twelve, when my mother married another man (who was also abusive), I was desperately trying to enforce order in my world. I would write up "family contracts" which included rules that everyone would live by, chores assigned in a predictable manner, a weekly family council to resolve disputes. These requests were ignored; I was after all just the "problem child", not to be listened to. I still threw temper tantrums, especially when my parents were inconsistent or lied to me.
During my teen years, I spent a lot of time reading, immersed in one interest or another. I would probably not have gotten through those years if it were not for my intense fascination with physics.
A small respite from the direct abuse from my stepfather came when he was arrested for counterfeiting money. I stole the evidence my mother would have burned, blockaded myself in my bedroom, and called the police. My stepfather got probation. I told the police that I had been beaten by my stepfather, but as there were (at the time) no marks to show for it, nothing was done. My mother blamed me for causing the family more trouble.
As an adolescent, I did none of the classical "rebellious" things: I never drank, used drugs, left the house without permission (day or night), skipped school, or got a grade lower than an A-minus. I ran away from home only once, after a death threat from my stepfather, and returned late the next day. And yet I was labeled "rebellious"--I still hated touching dirty, wet things; I still longed for predictability; I still didn't see the point of hygiene; and I still had temper tantrums.
College changed a lot of that: After a year, I was bathing regularly; and doing my own dishes became a necessity--a choice between the smell of cold food and the touch of dishwater. My meltdowns decreased to near-zero, replaced in secreet by self-harm. After three years, I even had friends, for the first time in my life.
But a surprising problem occurred: At college, I was, for the first time, safe from abuse, mistreatment, bullying, and ridicule. All my life before then had been geared towards surviving those things; and now I had no idea how to cope.
My grades dropped to failing; I was hospitalized after a major self-injury episode that required a few stitches (five, I think) because I'd been too clumsy with the razor blade. I was kicked out of school twice, first for mental-health reasons; then because my grades were too low.
It was a year before I could find the courage to tell my mother about my self-injury; six months after that, I was diagnosed with Asperger Syndrome, and a lot of my "difficult child" behaviors fell into place.
My mother, who always meant well, still doesn't quite believe her "stubborn, defiant genius child" has a "pervasive developmental disorder". She seems to prefer to believe that I am just strong-willed and needed consistency.
Currently I am teaching myself how to cope in a world where you don't have to fight for survival and sanity. I'm taking antidepressants, though I really hope I won't have to take them forever, and learning a lot of strategies when it comes to studying--both to deal with the executive dysfunction that comes with AS, the distractability I believe stems from either depression or undiagnosed ADHD, the Aspie preoccupation with special interests that distracts me from schoolwork, and the lack of motivation that comes with depression. My main philosophy is to stop trying to "just do it", and instead to find creative ways around those problems that are stopping me from doing what I know I'm capable of doing. Smashing my way through college by sheer willpower hasn't worked so far; it doesn't make sense to keep trying to do it that way.
Before college, I had just always depended on a good memory: Hearing something once, or reading it once, was enough to pass the test--I even wowed Sunday school teachers by learning a Bible verse after one reading. But during college, especially with a physics major, I needed to learn to study--something I had never learned as a child because I simply didn't need that skill.
So now the focus is on learning how to study, learning how to work, learning how to live... all while trying to keep from drowning in enough debt to buy my creditors a rather expensive house.
_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com
Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com
For god sake's you were two years old when your father died and your mother expected empathy from you about it? No two year old would understand death in the family and as the child gets older they wouldn't even be sad about their dad being dead because he or she never knew him. Some people are weird. Children don't understand death until they reach adolesence. (spelling).
I think I really freaked out my family when I was 9 and they told me my mother had died.
My response? "Ok can I go now?"
I still havent been able to explain to them that I didnt know what to say and the room full of people that looked like they all wanted to hug me was freaking me the f*ck out
_________________
One pill makes you larger
And one pill makes you small
And the ones that mother gives you
Don't do anything at all
-----------
"White Rabbit" - Jefferson Airplane
I am in such a family unfortunately, my dad can be verbally abusive and withholding torwards my mom and everyone else in the family. Denial is the name of the game around here. I am consiered "The Good Child" where I find myself taking on parental roles especially since I am the oldest.
It seems a lot of us had many things in common during our growing up years. I bounced back and forth between two very dysfunctional households. Now I realize that both my parents were likely very mentally ill, but at the time I thought it was entirely my fault. I remember spending a lot of time hiding under furniture, when we had any.
my mom was diagnosed manic depressive (the old term for bipolarism) and depression, bipolarism and schizophrenia run for 3 generations on her side of the family.
i'd actually written PARAGRAPHS explaining stuff, but none of it seemed coherent.
maybe i just don't like opening that can of worms. or that repeating it ad nauseum to every shrink kinda spoiled things for me. hngh.
basically, yea, alot of abuse ran in my family, i was gonna type mostly verbal, then i remembered the times my mom pinched, knocked our heads with her ring (huge topaz in it, i hate yellow), rule of thumb is hidden injuries. my paternal grandma told me i'd been abused sexually as a baby by her as well. i wouldn't be surprised, but part of me doesn't want to believe her.
i'm still picking up the pieces, sometimes i wonder if my BPD and bipolarism were induced and unnecessarily genetic, or that maybe i'd been undiagnosed AS and somehow learnt how to enter the mainstream, albeit stick out like a sore thumb haha!
eccentric? that's me, minus the wealth.
My mom had a difficult time after my dad died--she says that I made her life more difficult because I was so difficult, and she couldn't handle me alone. She figured that I should've seen how hard it was for her, and been a more well-behaved child.
Maybe an NT child would've seen that its mother was grieving... I don't remember ever noticing that, though really my memories don't start to be coherent and sequential until about age 4--two years later.
_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com
Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com
My mother took me to counselling about my "bad behavior" and causing fights in the family. Back then, I thought it was a stupid attempt to make me take blame for our problems. Looking back, though, a large part of it was caused by my behavior. It is very hard to look at it objectively, and it's easy to just be defensive, but that's the truth. If you really try and take a look at it from others' point of view, it might actually be some of your behaviors at fault.
_________________
"Hitting bottom isn't a weekend retreat, it isn't a goddamned seminar. Stop trying to control everything and just let go!"
Yes--but it it was a behavior you either couldn't help, or didn't understand were annoying people, then what could you have done about it?
A four, five, six year old child does not have the responsibility to keep the family happy...
_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com
Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com
A four, five, six year old child does not have the responsibility to keep the family happy...
That's the point of the counsellor. To help you see the problem, and fix it.
_________________
"Hitting bottom isn't a weekend retreat, it isn't a goddamned seminar. Stop trying to control everything and just let go!"
And if the family simply decides you are the problem, and don't even think of seeing a counselor, because obviously you just need more discipline?
_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com
Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com
edited out irrational emotional outburst
Last edited by Jenova on 02 Oct 2006, 11:41 am, edited 1 time in total.
my son is 9 months old, when he See's me walk into the room from work the first thing he does is try to come to me to be held, he is more of a daddy's boy then a mommas boy.
just because a child is young do not assume they do not or would not miss someone or feel the loss years later, remember some have photographic memory's, i can remember when i was two years old, ( hell, I can remember crawling when before i learned to walk), a child may not understand death but they do understand loss, take their loss to heart.
many autistic people get used as the weakest link in family's when the stress is on and the chips are down, sometimes if with a good family they become one of the strongest, when things was going not good I my self tended to go for long walks and hikes, or delved into reading and exploration, staying out of their way, but then again i was most always a loner.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Getting Lost |
15 Jan 2025, 6:38 pm |
Having problems with neediness -- lost skills - help! |
19 Nov 2024, 6:15 pm |
Child Abuse conviction - Rochanda Jefferson |
15 Jan 2025, 6:54 am |
Peter Yarrow Folk Music Icon, Activist, child molester dies |
11 Jan 2025, 1:13 pm |