I didn't answer the poll question, because I wasn't sure which one fits me best.
When I'm at work, I am obsessive about keeping the desk area tidy. Everything have to be in just the right place, and everything should be straight. I usually spend the first 5 minutes of my shift tidying up after the person who worked before me.
At home, in nearly all areas of the house, I'm the same way. I always clean up after myself, and always put things back just as they were.
Then, there's my room.
You know that expression "it looks like a bomb went off in here?" That expression was invented to describe my bedroom. For whatever reason, I have the hardest time keeping my room clean. There's always stuff laying around everywhere! I have probably 15 empty soda cans in there right now, clean clothes piled on the floor and at the foot of my bed, mail on the floor or spread out across my desk, etc.
I think the problem is that I'm a bit of a hoarder, and I have way too much stuff to fit in my room, and a lot of that stuff doesn't have a particular 'place', like the things in the rest of my house do, so I get stressed out and overloaded thinking of where I should put something, so I just toss it on the floor. When it gets to the point where I can't safely navigate from the door to my bed, I'll clean; and when I clean, it's SERIOUS. I spend hours sorting, organizing and throwing away. When I start sorting, I'll often discover something I haven't seen in a while, and I'll get distracted away from cleaning. Sometimes I'll decide to re-organize my Blu-ray shelf, which is probably the lowest priority to getting my room in living condition. It's definitely a full day event. Unfortunately, the longest I maintain the resulting super cleanliness is around two weeks. Birthdays and Christmas make this worse, because I get new things and don't know where to put them.
I think your post qualifies you for the piles vote, in my opinion. It's what you do most of the time that best defines you.