I do it badly, all the time.
I think part of people thinking I'm "staring" might be that I have to be looking *somewhere*, so it might very well be in their general direction.
When I'm "zoned out", I don't really notice things. I "see" them, but it's just kind of like they're irrelevant background noise. The problem is, just because I don't notice that I'm looking at somebody doesn't mean that he or she won't notice that I'm looking through them. Crowded public places make it worse, because then I'm likely to get overstimulated, withdraw, zone out in self-defense, and end up staring in some random direction at some random person.
I have a theory why aspie stares freak out NT people so badly. It's (AFAIK) totally unsubstantiated by hard research, but I'm convinced it's at least semi-plausible.
Due to the way your eyes work, they have to be in motion in order for visual stimulation to occur. However, there's more to "eye contact" than just looking in the right direction. When you make eye contact, you somehow *know* it beyond doubt. I think that what's happening is that the eye's scanning pattern is visible to others, and the scanning patterns of the two eyes change while "handshaking" to make it mutually obvious that the eyes have "locked on" to each other. Maybe an eye that thinks it senses the motion of another will alter its jitter rate by a few hertz, then when it senses the other eye has changed its own shift pattern, shift again and watch for a similar shift from the other eye in response.
Why is this relevant to Aspies? I think that when Aspies go into "blank stare mode", the handshaking protocol gets messed up (relative to NT norms). NTers look into our eyes, their brains sense the presence of human eyes and initiate the 'handshaking' pattern. Meanwhile, the zoned-out Aspie's brain somewhat recognizes the handshake attempt, but throws a curveball and launches into its own response that (to Neanderthals) might have been a protocol extension that implied, "I'm here, I'm busy, call back later". To someone without a Neanderthal heritage, the response either means nothing, or triggers the "WTF, something is seriously weird here!" subconscious alarm, and the NT'er goes sailing off into the Uncanny Valley.
If you want to prove the theory, conceal a 1" peephole somewhere non-obvious and camouflaged. Then bring people into the room who aren't expecting you to be hiding behind a peephole, and see how long it takes them to notice you. Chances are, if they're NT, it'll happen within a matter of seconds. Now replace yourself with a video camera in the same location, and repeat the experiment. You'll see very different results, guaranteed. There's something about an eye in motion, even one that's concealed amidst visual clutter, that makes it totally stand out from the background and be noticeable. To prove it's not just the appearance of an eye, replace the camera with something that has a realistic-looking eye, like the head of a mannequin with glass eyeballs. Same outcome -- lost in the visual clutter.
_________________
Your Aspie score: 170 of 200 · Your neurotypical (non-autistic) score: 34 of 200 · You are very likely an Aspie [ AQ=41, EQ=11, SQ=45, SQ-R=77; FQ=38 ]
Last edited by dr01dguy on 03 Dec 2011, 2:12 pm, edited 3 times in total.