"You can't be autistic, you can speak/write/have a job"
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
![User avatar](./download/file.php?avatar=90110_1451070500.jpg)
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 36,704
Location: Long Island, New York
That's simply the hard cold reality of the situation.
Add to that people who trivialize autism as not a disability. Something they wouldn't want cured. Is an asset to them and gives them special powers etc.
And sorry, need to vent a little. Also some people who go on and on about how they are just fine, and it's only because of the NT's that they have any problems.
There may be other things you could have been diagnosed with though.
And, I could be wrong.
Child of the 70s here. I'm using the word ret*d because that is what Aspies born in the 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s, and 80s had to deal with. There is no sugar coating or making "nice" those situations.
There were NO special ed classes until 1978 at my elementary school. I left 6th grade in 1976. Those first classes were for hearing impaired and the "mildly trainable" retared. The trainable were Cerebral Palsy, Down Syndrome. Birth injuries.
Your little Aspie/Autistic kids when they totally derailed, and everyone said, "That's it". we're tossed into state hospital like this...you were just considered "ret*d" and that was enough. There was no real mental health diagnosis. You're a ret*d, and why bother with a reason? No real treatments except beatings and horse tranquilizers.
http://mcp.mihomepaper.com/news/2012-12 ... qpXm3pOmBY
That's where you went in the 60s and 70s. You were considered not bright enough to be bother to messed with. This is a place Temple Grandin might have been shipped off to had her mother listened to the doctors. You can read the article about what went on there. I think my state had at least 8 places like that from way back when to the 1980s.
You head banged, stimmed, acted up, late potty training, screaming, melt down, was a runner, spinned plates...your doctor suggested the above ^^^^^^^ shipped you off because, "Bless his heart, he can't be helped."
IF you managed to not be low functioning enough to be shipped straight off, had the nightmare of dealing with humanity and no one giving a s**t.
You managed to cobble a life together because jobs expectations where different, marriage expectation were different (people married because that is what you did), and everyone had a big helping of STFU about any unhappiness. You're wife bitched about unhappiness, welcome to the club.
If you couldn't hack it at the sped farm, you where packed off to the state asylum for the insane which made the farm look like a paradise.
My psychiatrist friend worked at a children's home for the "Untrainable and Uneducatable" during 1980-1982. It was a snake bit of anyone who couldn't deal with humanity. Lots of seclusion. Lots of Thorazine shots. Lots of tackle mats and helmets.
The early 1990s was the start of children's psychiatry and people really looking at children as not throw a ways or small adults.
They didn't even test adults for Aspergers until 2010 in my area, because child of the 70s, you managed to pass for so long, who cares?
If people knew what utter horses**t an adult on the spectrum had to do to survive 1950s-1990s, you wouldn't begrudge him/her a diagnosis now. You'd give them a flipping medal. All between you and the farm was a doctor looking at your strung out parents and dialing a phone.
Mt husband's parents had the suggestion of a "home" since he had moderate behavior issues. Lucky for him their religious beliefs stopped them. That was 1972.
The obvoius "mental defectives" as they were called besides retardation and brain dysfuntion, recieved disgnosis of deafness, depression, schizophrenia, epilepsy, child psychosis (which was Gary Numan's diagnosis), and if you were female, hysteria.
But we are talking about in this thread people who were able to kind of pass. Often there was no official diagnosis of anything. Back then there was still a large stigma about going to a psychiatrist. You went if your parents or as in my case your school could not handle you or you and your parents could afford it. It was getting kind of trendy in movies and amoung the rich but that did not trickle down to the average working and middle class family. And if you had to go, it was usually to a general psychiatrist. As late as the early 1970's there were only a few hundred child psychologists in America. That does not mean there was no diagnosis for you, but they were negative colloquial ones fa***t, loser, weak, nerd when that still was a negative, oddball, space cadet, dizzy miss lizzy and so on. But we survived but yet are still doubted by some on a autism support site smh.
If you think it is bad now you should have been reading WP in 2014. Multiple threads at once bemoaning self disagosis and supposed massive overdiagnosis. Constant claims that there was all these elitist lazy trendy excuse makers ruining things for the "real autistics". It was constently claimed that most calling themselves an Aspie did that to disassociate themselves from the "real autistics".
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
![User avatar](./download/file.php?avatar=90110_1451070500.jpg)
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 36,704
Location: Long Island, New York
In this response I not meaning you and Ezra in particular. Signs is the key word. It goes right to the heart of the issue of this thread. If a person is married or has a job but socially ackward the person will be judged not autistic and accused of making it up. Just because a person does not show autistic signs and because sheer will power learned how to pass does not mean a person is not autistic or is a "recovered" autistic. Back then it was pass or be homeless or be institutionalized. You can't see the internal damage, the constant anxiety from fear of slipping up just once and bieng found out(stressed and exhausted makes it more likely the NT mask will come off unintentionally) the depression and self doubt from wondering why what is for everybody else seemingly so easy is so hard for you, the disassociation from passing so long you forget who you are.
Forget about my generation after all it is not your fault it was the way it was. You said you doubt your own proffessional diagnosis. I have seen a lot of posts like yours. This is the cost of all this it is way over diagnosed meme. Autistics instead of dealing with thier autism issues are now wasting precious time and mental energy wondering if they are a fraud autistic fooling the world and themselves. This is horrible. This self doubt is what expanding the diagnostic criteria was intended to get rid of.
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
Last edited by ASPartOfMe on 28 Jan 2016, 6:23 pm, edited 2 times in total.
ZombieBride: You're not a "dropout" until you never go back to high school again. If you don't go back by the time you're, say, 22, and don't get your Equivalency, then maybe you would be considered a "dropout."
I haven't gone to Grad School for a while; yet I don't consider myself a "Grad School dropout."
You might just be taking a vacation from school for a while, until you feel ready to come back. Maybe you'll go for the Equivalency when you're ready. Should you pass, there's no chance that you'll be a "dropout."
I was always afraid of being called upon because I would be found out to be a fraud. Now I realize that it was a deep recognition of the fact that I was faking every interaction I ever had. So, if that was a fake, I was a fake. I crumbled a lot.
I'm tired of killing gooses that lay golden eggs.
I always felt the same.. especially with the mentality that some seem to have about disability. And I'm not even on disability, but if I were, I don't think I should have to feel ashamed of it... But I know I would.. It's just that these people are always the first to question my autism and ask me if I'm on disability. As if I'd owe them my life, if I were.
But also, ever since I was a little kid, I always felt like I was doing something wrong. I would get in trouble for things that I didn't do.. Then get accused of lying about those things, which would get me in even more trouble.. I could be involved in charity work, or helping someone for no other reason than I want to help... and I still feel like I'm doing something wrong.. I feel like I'm a bad person who shouldn't be there.. I think I'm going to mess up and cause problems for the person.. I've come to accept that this is a feeling that just isn't ever going to go away..
So I think it makes sense for me that I feel like I'm doing something wrong with being autistic.. And I do feel it all the way around.. I feel like it's wrong for me to be autistic because others have a problem with it... And I feel like I could be a fraud because I see things from others that I can't relate to. But we all have very different lives and reasons for being the way that we are, that go much deeper than autism.
btbnnyr
Veteran
![User avatar](./download/file.php?avatar=50415.jpg)
Joined: 18 May 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,359
Location: Lost Angleles Carmen Santiago
I haven't met any diagnosed autistic people who appear to be more NT than autistic.
They have a variety of backgrounds and lifestyles, but there seems to me no reason to question their diagnoses.
_________________
Drain and plane and grain and blain your brain, and then again,
Propane and butane out of the gas main, your blain shall sustain!
As the OP, I am having a very, very hard time feeling like people like me are getting dumped on as fakers, not autistic enough, doesn't belong, go away, drop dead, you're not good enough for our club. God this really, really hurts and I don't know why I need to justify myself to anybody.
Because I have a job? I get in trouble every few weeks, passed over for promotions, get all the crud jobs nobody wants. And this is the first job I was able to hold for more than 5 months, over a job history of 30 years.
Because I have a marriage? that's no bed of roses either--fights, misunderstandings, and lots of other things I prefer not to discuss.
Because i am out and about in the world? Because it was an alternative to being at home with parents who abused me in every way possible. I overcame my terror of people because I needed to survive. I endure physical pain, anxiety, and near crippling depression every day because I have to support myself and my physically disabled spouse.
If you knew the absolute hell i had to go through as a child, with nobody to support me or protect me, no special classes, no therapy, nobody fixing me special meals because of my sensory issues, no sensory time out room, nobody making allowances for my differences, bullied at school and hurt at home, if you saw how incredibly angry and awkward I was, if you heard my TEACHER call me ret*d, my parents calling me psychopath, trouble, burden, too dramatic--you might not think I had some happy, easy time. I never said autism is not a disability for me. I never said that it's all fine, or tried to diminish it's impact. It's a burden I carry around every day, but I'm too damned stubborn to give up. There have been times I thought about suicide every single day for months because I couldn't face getting on the subway and going to work one more time, being yelled at by my boss for screwing up again, being yelled at by my wife for not understanding some mysterious unspoken message I'm supposed to know.
Every thing I have learned, every lesson in independence and how to fake normal has been at the cost of a painful experience. Every time I got fired, I learned a little how to work at the next job. Every way I learned to talk like an NT was learned from some humiliating experience. I've lost friends, alienated family members, lost jobs, been evicted from my home, been a victim of violent crime.
It's hard enough trying to find support from medical people with all the ignorance and misinformation about, but it really hurts that I need to justify myself to other autistics that don't even know me.
_________________
Diagnosed Bipolar II in 2012, Autism spectrum disorder (moderate) & ADHD in 2015.
Because I have a job? I get in trouble every few weeks, passed over for promotions, get all the crud jobs nobody wants. And this is the first job I was able to hold for more than 5 months, over a job history of 30 years.
Because I have a marriage? that's no bed of roses either--fights, misunderstandings, and lots of other things I prefer not to discuss.
Because i am out and about in the world? Because it was an alternative to being at home with parents who abused me in every way possible. I overcame my terror of people because I needed to survive. I endure physical pain, anxiety, and near crippling depression every day because I have to support myself and my physically disabled spouse.
If you knew the absolute hell i had to go through as a child, with nobody to support me or protect me, no special classes, no therapy, nobody fixing me special meals because of my sensory issues, no sensory time out room, nobody making allowances for my differences, bullied at school and hurt at home, if you saw how incredibly angry and awkward I was, if you heard my TEACHER call me ret*d, my parents calling me psychopath, trouble, burden, too dramatic--you might not think I had some happy, easy time. I never said autism is not a disability for me. I never said that it's all fine, or tried to diminish it's impact. It's a burden I carry around every day, but I'm too damned stubborn to give up. There have been times I thought about suicide every single day for months because I couldn't face getting on the subway and going to work one more time, being yelled at by my boss for screwing up again, being yelled at by my wife for not understanding some mysterious unspoken message I'm supposed to know.
Every thing I have learned, every lesson in independence and how to fake normal has been at the cost of a painful experience. Every time I got fired, I learned a little how to work at the next job. Every way I learned to talk like an NT was learned from some humiliating experience. I've lost friends, alienated family members, lost jobs, been evicted from my home, been a victim of violent crime.
It's hard enough trying to find support from medical people with all the ignorance and misinformation about, but it really hurts that I need to justify myself to other autistics that don't even know me.
I absolutely agree with all of this. Most of us come here for support, or at least to feel we can connect with others, when we feel so out of place in the world. At least, I know that's why I started coming here. Even when I don't type anything for a long time, I still come here to read and feel like I'm not so completely alone with my problems.
btbnnyr
Veteran
![User avatar](./download/file.php?avatar=50415.jpg)
Joined: 18 May 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,359
Location: Lost Angleles Carmen Santiago
I think it is pointless to talk about not autistic enough or you don't seem autistic.
EzraS doesn't seem autistic in posts, but they say they are, so they probably are.
If I didn't know, I wouldn't consider ZombieBride as someone who seemed autistic in posts, but that doesn't mean they aren't.
Sometimes, someone does seem quite autistic to me just from their posts, and I think it is because they are probably similar to me in autistic traits or personality traits that gives me that impression in my mind.
Sometimes, someone seems very NT online, but they are diagnosed, and they may not seem so in person.
It would be hard for them to be diagnosed and seem very NT in person, unless they were diagnosed early in childhood and developed in a more NT direction later, or perhaps they were misdiagnosed in childhood, sometimes people post to question their childhood diagnoses.
_________________
Drain and plane and grain and blain your brain, and then again,
Propane and butane out of the gas main, your blain shall sustain!
kraftiekortie,
I seemed to come in somewhere in the middle of all this, between when autism had a strict definition and the recognition of autism spectrum disorder. At 23 months (in 1986), I showed "decreased language development" and was brought to a military speech pathology clinic at the Tripler Army Medical Center in Hawaii, where we lived (and I was born). I had a tendency to jabber a lot, they said. An audiology test showed normal hearing, and I played appropriately and showed "prespeech" behaviors. No diagnosis was given then, and my mother was given homework, which involved speech stimulation activities. I would not put 2 words together until I was about 3 or 4.
In Kindergarten, I was removed from my normal school and put in a "psychoed" classroom. I was found to have ADHD, a severe language disorder, and a moderate articulation disorder. I was noted to have "autistic features," but no autism diagnosis was given. I was also found to have macrocephaly (head circumference greater than the 98th percentile). By 1st grade, however, a doctor noted a "pervasive developmental delay" and by the end of 1990, a diagnosis of PDD-NOS was given at the Dwight D. Eisenhower Army Medical Center, in a note addressed to the Walter Reed Army Medical Center as we were moving to Northern Virginia, based on the following symptomatology: "impaired social interactions (oppositional, little notice of other's feelings, poor play but can occ. play parallely w/out difficulty), perseveration + obsessive thoughts, poor tolerance of change, hyperactivity, and difficulty separating fantasy from reality." They noted that at this point my "language was very good" (this was halfway through 1st grade).
Considering the above, it seemed that at around this time I switched to a more Asperger's-type presentation, sorta like how you switched. Later on, in 1993 I would be found eligible for autism resource services at school, which at the time seemed to be a "new" disability that could be accommodated on an IEP. At age 9, a child neurologist at Walter Reed found that my head circumference was now above the 75th percentile (so I did not have macrocephaly anymore). At 13, I would be diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome. In 2013, my diagnosis was updated to autism spectrum disorder.
_________________
"You have a responsibility to consider all sides of a problem and a responsibility to make a judgment and a responsibility to care for all involved." --Ian Danskin
Last edited by beneficii on 29 Jan 2016, 3:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
I was always afraid of being called upon because I would be found out to be a fraud. Now I realize that it was a deep recognition of the fact that I was faking every interaction I ever had. So, if that was a fake, I was a fake. I crumbled a lot.
I'm tired of killing gooses that lay golden eggs.
In the past couple days, I have become increasingly aware that I fake a lot of my interactions. It's like I've learned how to say just the right things to get people to leave me alone, which generally involved presenting myself as much more competent than I actually am. Even as I am struggling with a messy car, exhaustion, forgetfulness, being homeless, and constantly forgetting stuff, I feel like I must present myself very competently and like I have good resources already.
Perhaps becoming aware of this kind of interaction is the first step to overcoming it and presenting myself more truthfully.
_________________
"You have a responsibility to consider all sides of a problem and a responsibility to make a judgment and a responsibility to care for all involved." --Ian Danskin
If someone doesn't care you'll hear it in their voice. Don't care tone starts fairly high then just drops lower. The I 'care' tone starts low and ends high. Tho the NT type are very in tune with this s**t so they can just fake the emotion. But most just say how they feel cause its natural to them.
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
![User avatar](./download/file.php?avatar=90110_1451070500.jpg)
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 36,704
Location: Long Island, New York
Quote from zkydz
"Wanna know one of the things that occurred to me?
I was always afraid of being called upon because I would be found out to be a fraud. Now I realize that it was a deep recognition of the fact that I was faking every interaction I ever had. So, if that was a fake, I was a fake. I crumbled a lot.
I'm tired of killing gooses that lay golden eggs."
My response
Very revealing and informative observation.
Had to post this way because CAPTCHA is not letting me post at all if I use the quote feature
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
To OP, you are not alone. I struggle to find services. I have other issues which I have gotten treatment for, but for autism-related problems I just struggle on my own IRL and come here. It is scary and frustrating. Many times in my life I have wanted to give up. I haven't because, like you, I felt like I had to escape an unbearable home situation.
Other people, including most mental health professionals I've encountered, completely fail to acknowledge my autism and those who are aware of it have nothing to offer in the way of support because they are ignorant of how autism effects me on a day to day basis. They just see me as smart but eccentric or they think I'm stupid or an as*hole. Some probably see me as a hypochondriac.
On the issue of not autistic enough: I don't care what others on WP think about whether or not I am autistic. I know I have the disorder. That's enough for me. I've encountered several people here at WP who can relate to my problems so I keep posting and reading others' posts. I can't relate to everyone's experience but that's okay. We all have certain things in common because we're aspies. I try to focus on that and avoid the controversies that often occur here.
Hi Beneficii,
Thank you for this illustration. I bet this is more common than we think it is.
Have you ever heard of the book Elijah's Cup? It's about a boy who seemed quite classically autistic when very young, but became quite Aspergian later. I met the mother about ten years ago; I met the boy, who is in his late 20's, about a year ago. He seemed somewhat apathetic and depressed when I met him. About 7-8 years ago, he did a comedy routine, and called himself Mr. Inevitable. You could Google Mr. Inevitable.
When I was 5 1/2 years old, in 1966, our whole family went to a special so-called research camp. It was called Harrelson. It was in upstate New York. They did research on maybe about 20 kids, including my NT older brother and myself. This was probably where I said my first words. I wish I could find mention of it online. I did go to a nursery school sponsored by the New York Association for Brain-Injured children NYABIC. You could Google it. The organization still exists, but under another name.
kraftiekortie,
I have ordered the book Elija's Cup by Amazon because you have mentioned it before and it arrived a few days before Christmas, but the pages smell funny, some sweetish funny smell they have, so I have a hard time reading it because I have to put it one arm-lenghts away from me and I don't enjoy reading it that way, and still I can smell it, thought to a lesser extent.
Usually I like the smell of bookpages, but not of that one.
Maybe the funny smell will wear off some day.
_________________
English is not my native language, so I will very likely do mistakes in writing or understanding. My edits are due to corrections of mistakes, which I sometimes recognize just after submitting a text.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
When The Orators Speak |
24 Nov 2024, 6:13 am |
Anyone else speak really quietly? |
05 Feb 2025, 4:53 pm |
I Write Too Much. |
04 Jan 2025, 8:48 am |
Unpopular Game Character Opinion I need to speak up about |
Yesterday, 1:05 am |