Best Culture for Aspie
No, not really. I've lived on opposite sides of the world and I've come to the conclusion that people are the same everywhere.
A lot people seem to think that Japan is a good place to be if you have AS, but this is true only if you're white. A Japanese with AS who has always lived in Japan won't necessarily have a better life than a native-born American with AS who has always lived in the U.S.--he just has to suck it up and try his best to appear normal for the sake of "family honor."
No, not really. I've lived on opposite sides of the world and I've come to the conclusion that people are the same everywhere.
A lot people seem to think that Japan is a good place to be if you have AS, but this is true only if you're white. A Japanese with AS who has always lived in Japan won't necessarily have a better life than a native-born American with AS who has always lived in the U.S.--he just has to suck it up and try his best to appear normal for the sake of "family honor."
If you're going to be living in Japan for the rest of your life just being white wont be enough once you've been in a community for a while and everyone knows you.
Still, all your quirks will be attributed to your being white and people will be a lot more accommodating to you than to a Japanese who's guilty of the same quirks. They may be doing it consciously, or they may not. But that's what basically will happen.
(I'm going to add that this won't be true in places where there have been quite a number of white immigrants and where the young folks have been somewhat Americanized, but otherwise that's pretty much how I think it would be like.)
EDIT: After reading your previous post, I'm also going to add that it is assumed you know the language and the etiquette well.
I vote for Japan, though that is largely a guess.
I don't think that it's fair to lump America into one category. The mid-west is totally different than New England is totally different than Appalachia is totally different than Texas is totally different than Alaska is totally different than the west coast is totally different than the great plains region is totally different than the rest of the south.
I rather like living in Amish country in the mid western area of America. They tend to leave others alone, aren't very chatty, and very non-judgmental.
I guess I don't understand the question. Without actually experiencing other cultures, what frame of reference would I use to make a determination? And if I can't read social cues, isn't that culturally independent.
_________________
When God made me He didn't use a mold. I'm FREEHAND baby!
The road to my hell is paved with your good intentions.
Thanks! I'm thinking about spending a year there (or another Slavic country) when I finish school (probably teaching English,) so that would be appreciated
As for the thread, I can't really answer, having never left Australia (except one trip to Fiji.) My society is conformist, although there is some tolerance of eccentricity. I suspect we aren't really much different to America in this regard (self-depreciating jokes calling Australia "the 53rd state" aren't too far off sometimes.)
_________________
"Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal." - Albert Camus
I have never seen Americans do that. I heard that happens in certain parts of the south like Texas and Arkansas, but other places (I think especially New England) are all about avoiding eye contact with strangers and ignoring them as best they can. There are even stand-up comedian routines making fun of how much eye contact is avoided between strangers in certain American cities.
I'm not sure about Scotland as a good culture match. I've found it a sufficiently difficult culture to live in that I wonder if others are better matches. That's the culture in general, but because I have the opportunity to meet a lot of Aspies on a very frequent basis then that's the best culture match if available.
I've never experienced living abroad, so I just have some guesses.
I always thought that Japan and asian countries are better to aspergers, because of the introversion, politeness, and they see the life from a different prespective, not so self-centered. My experience with asians in my country tells me the same.
North america and specially south america are not easy to aspergers.
I think european countries are at some point in the center of the scale.
Middle east countries, I have no idea.
But there's one thing I think it's true, if you go to another country most of your awkwardness will be taken as a problem with language\culture adaptation, so will not be taken too seriously.
_________________
Empty yourself of everything.
Let the mind rest at peace.
The ten thousand things rise and fall while the Self watches their return.
They grow and flourish and then return to the source.
Returning to the source is stillness, which is the way of nature
I have never seen Americans do that. I heard that happens in certain parts of the south like Texas and Arkansas, ...
I live in Arkansas.
Random people will start talking to you and telling their life story and asking where you got your shoes at. It's called Southern Hospitality.... it's considered friendly.... but I find it annoying.
If you look busy then they'll be polite and not talk to you... so sometimes I act like I am doing something important on my phone or calling someone so that I can avoid 'forced familiarity' as I call it. They'll talk to you like they have known you your whole life. aaaaah
_________________
Wahren einander vor Zweisamkeit,
denn kurz ist die Zeit die Ihr zusammen seid.
I would kind of think that South Asian cultures would be good for aspies....
Place like India.
I've had many many Indian friends and I always felt oodles more normal around them.
You're not expected to talk to anyone really, unless you have common interests or goals. People are distant and don't force hugs on you.
I may have been more comfortable around them because they never had an American friend, so they never suspected my behavior to be odd... perhaps they just thought I was a normal American?
There are too many variables in figuring this out...there are so many behaviors and traits that differ amongst even us here on WP... maybe something that would make me feel more comfortable would make another person on here panic....
I would say any foreign culture would suffice. Because everyone would chalk it up to being that you're a foreigner, and that's why you're different.
_________________
Wahren einander vor Zweisamkeit,
denn kurz ist die Zeit die Ihr zusammen seid.
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... imensions/
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... nce-index/
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... ientation/
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... nce-index/
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... sculinity/
http://www.clearlycultural.com/geert-ho ... vidualism/
I suspect the best culture for an Aspie will be a culture with high Individualism and high Uncertainty Avoidance; then (according to the tables in the links), the best Aspie-friendly countries will be:
Belgium
Poland
Japan
Argentina
France
Spain
Hungary
Israel
Italy
Czech Republic
Austria
(these are the countries where both Individualism and Uncertainty Avoidance are above average)
I don't think that it's fair to lump America into one category. The mid-west is totally different than New England is totally different than Appalachia is totally different than Texas is totally different than Alaska is totally different than the west coast is totally different than the great plains region is totally different than the rest of the south.
I rather like living in Amish country in the mid western area of America. They tend to leave others alone, aren't very chatty, and very non-judgmental.
I agree, either that, or Europe.
Costa Rican's/Hispanics and the Irish are very friendly, middle-easterners are supposed to be more hospitable than southerners, I hear Czechs are pretty reserved so a lot of aspies are probably drawn to it. All places have their good points but no place is miraculous.
Last edited by Shadwell on 10 Dec 2010, 10:49 am, edited 1 time in total.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Gay rights under woke culture |
03 Nov 2024, 5:25 pm |
SCOTUS declines to hear “culture wars” cases |
09 Dec 2024, 12:45 pm |
CEO defends 84-hour work-week culture amid death threats |
04 Dec 2024, 12:30 pm |
Coming out of the aspie closet |
28 Nov 2024, 6:47 pm |