Bart21 wrote:
I can't stand anything fiction myself.
If there is a movie with something in it that doesn't excist or hasn't excisted i can't stand there.
The only exception i have made was LOTR because it was just so dam good.
Anything fake simply doesn't interest me.
How do you reconcile this fact with using an avatar of a puppet from a fiction film?
When you say "fake" are you speaking in terms of realism? To use your avatar as an example, there is nothing done in the Saw movies that could not theoretically be actually carried out, given time/money/psychosis. As opposed to the fact that much sci-fi relies on things that cannot happen, or do not happen.
You say you liked LOTR .. which was written in a very realistic manner. It is essentially an alternate history. It also doesnt go overboard with the "fantasy" elements. How do you fare with close future sci-fi? Post apocalypse stuff, or films where the sci-fi element is very understated?
One of the key tenets of fantastic writing (and by extension filming) is the suspension of disbelief. To create a different set of rules, and obey them, or to create something fantastic, that works within certain parameters.
Most good sci fi relies on this, and the ones that seem to work best are the ones that dont push the boundaries of reality. Same with fantasy. However, there are a few conventions .. theres usually sound in space, even though we all know that wont work, simply because it works better dramatically. Handling silence in space has been done, and done well at at times, but its just more exciting if you can hear the explosions etc. Same thing goes for the fudging of FTL travel.. because having a film where it takes 80 years to go from a to b is going to be dramatically a bit shite.
My guess is, its an escapist thing for most. This world is a bit dull, so its nice to "get out of the house" sometimes.
I noticed someone mention theyre a bugger for hole-picking.. which is half the point of watching these films for me. I love doing it, and picking up all sorts of odd facts about them as well. Gives them a longer shelf-life, and helps me hone my analytical skills.
_________________
"There is a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart,
that you can't take part" [Mario Savo, 1964]