This is a hall of fame thread for sure. Everyone's making great contributions here, but a few are worth mentioning specifically (don't feel bad). Scoots, congratz on delivering The. Worst. Pickup. Line. Ever. I absolutely love it.
The Jimi Hendrix bit reminds me of a conversation an NT friend and I had about Johnny Mathis (yeah, I know, but this is funny).
Friend: "I know he has some kind of ethnicity to him, but...."
Me [taken aback slightly]: "Yeah, he's black."
Friend: "No way! He's black?!"
I haven't let him live it down yet.