...but actuarial work can be creative. Yeah, your first few years in the profession are best described as "spreadsheet monkey", but even then, I've had occasion to be creative with problem-solving. (I'm 47, decided to do a mid-life career switch to actuary 3 years ago, been working as "spreadsheet monkey" now for 2.5 years.)
Actuaries in consulting firms have to talk to lots of people, but in an insurance company, you mostly talk to your fellow actuaries, who are all at least within spitting distance of the spectrum, trust me. (Heck, I think my boss might be an undiagnosed Aspie himself....)
If you're good at math, like a stable profession, and like to make good money (typical starting salary after bachelor's degree is $55k/yr, and you usually hit $100k within 5-6 years if you make good progress on exams), I'd definitely recommend checking out at least the first two actuarial exams. If you pass them, and especially if you thought they were easy, dive on in. I took the first two exams, passed them with little trouble, and then fired off resumes (already had a B.Sc. in computer science, plus an MBA, although that wasn't as big a deal). Google "be an actuary" for more info.